Northern's Best Antique Stores [Updated 2026]

Each of these twelve spots is a treasure trove, bursting with stories waiting to be uncovered. My journey took me from quaint little shops tucked away in charming towns to sprawling warehouses filled with vintage wonders. Along the way, I've developed a keen eye for quality and authenticity, ensuring that my picks reflect the absolute best of what Northern Indiana has to offer.

You might wonder why you should trust my expertise—well, let’s just say I’ve spent countless weekends scouring these stores, haggling for the perfect piece, and chatting with passionate owners who live and breathe antiques. So, buckle up as we dive into this delightful world of nostalgia and craft!

Exit 76 (Edinburgh) Antique Mall

Highlights
Largest antique mall
Well organized booths
Wide walking aisles
Helpful staff available
Cafe and restrooms on-site

Exit 76 (Edinburgh) Antique Mall is one of those charming places where you never know what treasure awaits around the next corner. As the largest antique mall in the area, it’s a veritable playground for antique enthusiasts! I was pleasantly surprised by how well organized the booths were, each one inviting me to explore its unique collection without feeling overwhelmed. The wide walking aisles allowed me to meander leisurely, browsing through an eclectic mix of vintage furniture, quirky collectibles, and nostalgic knick-knacks.

One particularly delightful aspect of this antique haven was the helpful staff who were not only knowledgeable but also genuinely passionate about the items they curate. They provided excellent insights into the history of certain pieces, enhancing my shopping experience further. To top it off, I appreciated the on-site cafe and restrooms, ensuring that I could indulge in a caffeine fix while taking breaks to relish my findings.

If you’re looking for a delightful day out where you can unearth hidden gems, I wholeheartedly recommend Exit 76 Antique Mall. It truly offers a delightful mix of nostalgia and charm that will leave you enchanted!

You might also want to check out the best antique stores in Indianapolis.

Countryside Antique Mall

Highlights
Great variety of booths
Fairly priced items available
Inconsistent pricing issues
Unfriendly customer service
Potential for competitive finds

Countryside Antique Mall is a treasure trove for antique enthusiasts, filled with diverse booths that showcase everything from vintage furniture to quirky collectibles. As I strolled through the aisles, I reveled in the great variety of items available. It felt like a journey through time, each piece whispering stories of its past.

Now, let’s talk about pricing—you’ll find fairly priced items that won't break the bank, although I did encounter some inconsistent pricing that left me scratching my head. While some booths offered delightful finds for a steal, others had items marked a bit higher than expected.

One aspect that slightly dampened the experience was the customer service. I found the staff to be a tad unfriendly, which contrasted with the warm ambiance of the store itself. A cheerful greeting can go a long way in making a shopping trip more enjoyable!

Nevertheless, the potential for competitive finds is certainly there, making it a worthwhile stop for anyone on the hunt. With a little patience, you might just stumble upon that perfect piece to complete your collection. Overall, Countryside Antique Mall offers an adventure that's hard to resist!

You might also want to check out the best lakes in Indianapolis.

Bloomington Antique Mall

Highlights
Treasure hunter’s paradise
Multiple floors of booths
Friendly vendors and staff
Great deals and unique finds
Fun experience for collectors

Stepping into the Bloomington Antique Mall felt like entering a treasure hunter’s paradise. With multiple floors of booths, the variety is simply staggering. Each corner unveils unique finds—from vintage toys to exquisite furniture pieces, it’s a delight for collectors and casual browsers alike.

As I navigated through the aisles, I was greeted by friendly vendors and staff, who were always ready to share stories about their items and offer their insights. Their passion for antiques is infectious, making it easy to get lost in time while exploring the quaint selections.

One moment, I was admiring a charming 1950s tea set, and the next, I stumbled upon a rare vintage vinyl collection—each item priced reasonably, which adds to the thrill of the hunt. If you're looking for great deals, you'll undoubtedly find them here.

The ambiance couldn’t be more inviting, enhancing the overall experience. Whether you’re on a quest for that perfect piece to complete your collection or just looking to indulge your nostalgia, Bloomington Antique Mall is a delightful expedition into history that you simply must not miss.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artists in Indianapolis.

Constables Antiques

Highlights
Incredible war memorabilia
Knowledgeable owner, Mike
Military vintage clothing collection
Historical artifacts from various conflicts
Original movie props available

When I stepped into Constables Antiques, I was instantly transported back in time. The air buzzed with history, especially as I wandered through their stunning collection of incredible war memorabilia. As a fan of vintage treasures, I was particularly entranced by the military vintage clothing on display, which now holds its own stories waiting to be uncovered.

The owner, Mike, has an incredible wealth of knowledge — he regaled me with tales of the historical artifacts from various conflicts that peppered his store. I found myself captivated not just by the items themselves, but also by the passionate stories behind them. From original movie props that once graced the silver screen to meticulously preserved items that echo the bravery of those who wore them, every corner of the store held something unique.

Visiting Constables is like stepping into a living museum, where everything has a special place in history. If you’re a lover of antiques or just want to explore a treasure trove of the past, this store is a must-visit! Prepare to walk away with not just a purchase, but a captivating story that might just inspire your own adventure.

You might also want to check out the best pumpkin patches in Indianapolis.

Copper Top Customs

Highlights
Fair prices
Kind and welcoming owners
Amazing and unique finds
Well-organized shopping experience
Delightful small-town charm

Copper Top Customs is truly a gem tucked away in Northern, and let me tell you, it delivered a delightful treasure-hunting experience! From the moment I stepped inside, I was captivated by the kind and welcoming owners, who seemed genuinely excited to share their passion for antiques.

The store itself is beautifully organized, making it easy to navigate through a variety of curated finds. Every corner is packed with amazing and unique pieces, each with its own story just waiting to be discovered. I was particularly drawn to a stunning vintage lamp that would be a perfect addition to my living room!

What I appreciated most about Copper Top Customs was their fair pricing; it’s refreshing to find a place where you can truly feel like you’re getting a good deal without compromising quality. The atmosphere radiates a charming small-town vibe that invites leisurely exploration, making it hard to resist digging a little deeper.

Overall, if you're in Northern and have a knack for antiques, Copper Top Customs is a must-visit. You'll leave with not just a unique find, but also a heart warmed by the charm of the place!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in Indianapolis.

Second Stories Antiques

Highlights
Incredible selection
Unique gift options
Beautifully organized displays
Two floors of treasures
Reasonable prices

Stepping into Second Stories Antiques felt like embarking on a whimsical treasure hunt! Tucked away in a charming building, this delightful shop boasts an incredible selection of antiques that truly reflects the rich character of the area. As I wandered through two sprawling floors of treasures, my senses were delighted by the beautifully organized displays—each corner presents a curated showcase that invites exploration.

What I found particularly enchanting were the unique gift options scattered throughout the store; if you’re looking for that one-of-a-kind piece to impress a friend or loved one, this place is a goldmine! From vintage jewelry to quirky home decor, there’s something to catch every eye.

Now, you might think such treasures would come at a hefty price, but Second Stories surprises you with reasonable prices that make bringing a piece of history home a reality. Whether you’re an avid collector or just curious about antiquities, this shop is a must-visit. I truly felt like every object had a story, waiting to be shared. If you find yourself in Northern, don’t miss the chance to explore this gem—your next favorite antique awaits!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Kokomo.

Mercantile 37

Highlights
Unique gifts by local artisans
Tasty food with generous portions
Friendly and helpful staff
Vintage items and custom furniture
Easy parking and accessibility

Mercantile 37 is a delightful gem in Northern that beautifully blends vintage charm with a contemporary twist. As soon as I entered, I was warmly greeted by the friendly staff, who are not only knowledgeable but also eager to share stories behind the unique finds that adorn the shelves. This place is a treasure trove of one-of-a-kind items, showcasing lovely vintage objects alongside custom furniture created by talented local artisans.

What sets Mercantile 37 apart is its commitment to community; it proudly features unique gifts made by local artisans, creating a vibrant atmosphere that reflects the spirit of Northern. After browsing through the eclectic collection, I took a break at their cozy café where I indulged in a delicious meal. The portions were generous, and the food was simply delightful—perfect fuel for more treasure hunting!

The easy parking and accessibility make this charming store even more appealing. Overall, I left Mercantile 37 with not just a few cherished finds but also a heart full of joy. If you’re looking for an antique store that radiates warmth and creativity, this is definitely the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best rv parks in Indianapolis.

Gilley's Antique & Decorator Mall

Stepping into Gilley’s Antique & Decorator Mall is like entering a whimsical time machine! The vast collection of antiques here is truly impressive, showcasing everything from vintage furniture to quirky decor items. Each aisle unfolds new treasures waiting to be discovered, making it impossible to resist wandering for hours. The knowledgeable staff are not only friendly but also eager to share the fascinating histories behind their pieces. If you’re hunting for a unique find or simply want to bask in nostalgia, this place is a must-visit. Overall, Gilley's is a delightful gem in the heart of Northern's antique scene!

You might also want to check out the best antique stores in Indianapolis.

Southport Antique Mall

Stepping into the Southport Antique Mall feels like taking a delightful trip back in time! This charming haven boasts an impressive array of treasures, from vintage jewelry to quirky mid-century furniture. The eclectic mix keeps the hunt exciting, and each corner reveals a new surprise. I particularly loved the friendly vendors, always eager to share stories behind their unique items. The atmosphere is inviting, making it easy to lose track of time as you wander. If you’re on the hunt for something special—or just love a good browse—Southport Antique Mall is an absolute must-visit in Northern!

You might also want to check out the best waterfalls in Indianapolis.

Yellow Moon Antique Mall

Stepping into Yellow Moon Antique Mall felt like diving into a delightful treasure chest! The moment I crossed the threshold, I was embraced by a whimsical atmosphere that sparkled with history. Each nook reveals unique finds, from vintage furniture to quirky collectibles, all waiting for their new home. The staff was genuinely helpful and passionate, sharing stories behind select pieces that brought them to life. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just curious, this charming spot offers a playful adventure through time. Don't miss it—your next favorite trinket might just be waiting!

You might also want to check out the best florist in Carmel.

Carmel Old Town Antique Mall

I recently wandered into the Carmel Old Town Antique Mall, and it felt like stepping into a time capsule! This charming haven is brimming with quirky finds and timeless treasures. Each booth tells a story, from vintage jewelry to retro furniture, tantalizing my inner collector. The staff is friendly and eager to help, adding to the welcoming atmosphere. As I explored, I couldn’t resist the delightful aromas from nearby cafes, making it a perfect spot to unwind after a treasure hunt. If you’re on the lookout for unique pieces with character, this mall is a must-visit in Northern!

You might also want to check out the best bed and breakfast in Nashville.

Midland Arts & Antiques Market

Upon stepping into the Midland Arts & Antiques Market, I was whisked away by the delightful chaos of treasures that awaited me. Every corner of the spacious warehouse brims with character, showcasing an impressive array of vintage finds—from stunning jewelry to quirky furniture. The atmosphere is vibrant and inviting, encouraging leisurely exploration. I was particularly taken by the knowledgeable vendors, eager to share their stories and insights. For anyone seeking a charming adventure in antiquing, this gem is an absolute must-visit. Don’t forget to check out their local art section; you'll find unique pieces that truly capture the local spirit!

You might also want to check out the best lakes in Indiana for Swimming.