Nashville's Best BBQ Restaurants

Nashville’s main drag smells like hickory before you even park. That smoke hangs over the courthouse square and the hardware store, and it should.

We’ve got two pits worth your appetite, and they pull in opposite directions: one is a sit-down supper club for the sweet-tea crowd, the other a gravel-lot operation where the sausage snaps against a paper plate. Both nail the char.

One stars a vinegar-kissed pork shoulder worth the drive from Columbus; the other, an Italian sausage with peppers that outshines every rib in a ten-mile radius. Pick your smoke.

Sugar Creek Barbeque Co

Some places you drive past. Sugar Creek Barbeque Co is a place you drive to. The pulled pork arrives with a gentle, smoky pull, each strand carrying its own quiet flavor. The sauce, a thin vinegar kiss, lets the meat speak for itself. Inside, the room hums with the low chatter of locals who know exactly why they are here. A woman refills sweet tea without being asked, and the air smells of hickory and patience. It is not a spectacle. It is better than that. It is a small town holding its own against hurry, one tender bite at a time. Worth every mile of Indiana blacktop. I left full, but more than that, I left glad I stopped.

You might also want to check out the best bbq restaurants in Lafayette.

Trolly's

Trolly's sits low and smoky, the kind of place where the smoker out front does its own talking. I ordered the Italian sausage with peppers, and it arrived with a char that snapped, the peppers soft and sweet against the heat. The pulled pork, too, held its own, moist and honest. Out back, the picnic tables invite you to stay a while, and the breeze carries woodsmoke like a cologne. Service moves quick, friendly, no fuss. There is a lazy rhythm here, a reprieve. Nothing fancy. Just meat, smoke, and time. I would not change a thing. Sometimes the best seat in Nashville is a plastic chair with a paper plate.

You might also want to check out the best new restaurants in Crown Point.