The Absolute Best Deli in Indianapolis [Updated 2026]

With a decade spent savoring every sandwich and sniffing out the perfect pastrami, I’ve made it my mission to uncover the hidden gems of Indy’s deli scene. After diving into twelve top-notch locations, I can confidently say that these aren’t just delis—they’re culinary experiences that will make your taste buds sing.

Trust me, I’ve tasted the offerings, chatted with the owners, and soaked in the atmosphere of each spot. Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, my journey through the heart of Indianapolis delis is designed to help you find your new favorite lunchtime oasis. Let’s dig in and discover what makes these delis stand out!

Shapiro's Delicatessen

Highlights
Authentic deli experience
Outstanding corned beef
Friendly and efficient service
Nostalgic charm
Great breakfast options

Shapiro's Delicatessen is an experience in itself—affirming that the classic deli is alive and well in Indianapolis. As soon as I walked in, I was enveloped by a wave of nostalgia, reminiscent of old-world delis where community and good food intermingle seamlessly.

The star of the show? The outstanding corned beef. Easily the best I've had in the city, each bite was a delightful mix of tenderness and rich flavor that danced on my palate. The generous portions left me pondering if I could even finish the whole sandwich, but I decided not to back down—and I absolutely did not regret it!

Service here is not only friendly but also refreshingly efficient. Despite my busy surroundings filled with happy diners, the staff made me feel like I was the only customer in the room. And let’s not forget their great breakfast options. Whether you're after a hearty meal to jumpstart your day or a classic deli sandwich, Shapiro's has you covered.

In a city filled with dining choices, Shapiro's Delicatessen stands out as a beacon for those in search of authentic deli charm and flavor. If you haven't been, you're definitely missing out!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Shapiro's Delicatessen at IND Airport

Highlights
Prompt and considerate service
Well-made chicken salad sandwich
Good taste despite high prices
Limited bread options offered
Common airport food experience

Visiting Shapiro's Delicatessen at IND Airport was a delightful detour during my travels. As I stepped into this bustling space, I was immediately greeted by prompt and considerate service, a welcome touch amidst the usual airport chaos. I decided to try their well-made chicken salad sandwich—and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! Each bite delivered a harmonious blend of flavors that was both satisfying and refreshing.

However, I must mention that the prices were on the higher side, which can be expected in airport eateries. Still, the quality of the food made it a worthwhile splurge. The bread options were somewhat limited, a minor inconvenience for an ardent sandwich lover like myself. That said, the overall experience was quite enjoyable, despite the typical airport food ambiance.

In a city renowned for its diverse culinary landscape, Shapiro's stands out not just as an airport deli, but as a testament to quality and flavor. If you find yourself rushing through IND, make sure to carve out a moment for this gem—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Yamallama Delicatessen

Highlights
Tasty and fresh protein salad
Great food and great people
Quality ingredients used
Divine and varied menu
Made with loads of love

Yamallama Delicatessen is a vibrant gem in Indianapolis, and I simply couldn’t resist the allure of its charm. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere filled with the delightful aroma of fresh ingredients. I went straight for their tasty and fresh protein salad, and let me tell you, it was a flavor explosion that put a smile on my face!

What truly sets Yamallama apart are the quality ingredients they use. Each bite is a testament to their commitment to freshness and flavor—it's as if the dishes are made with loads of love. The menu is divine and varied, offering something for everyone, from hearty sandwiches to delightful sides. You’ll discover a tasteful twist that keeps you coming back for more.

And the people? Well, they are just as wonderful as the food. It’s hard not to feel at home when you're surrounded by such friendly faces. If you’re in search of a deli that brings together great food and great people, look no further. Yamallama Delicatessen has solidified its place as one of the best delis in Indianapolis, and I can’t wait to return for more tasty adventures!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Turchetti’s Salumeria

Highlights
Amazing food and staff
Diverse drink selections
Beautiful grocery market
Fantastic brunch options
Great value for money

Turchetti's Salumeria is a hidden gem that captivates the senses the moment you step inside. The aroma of cured meats and freshly baked bread envelops you, immediately announcing that you’re in for something special. The atmosphere here feels both vibrant and welcoming, thanks to the amazing staff who are not only knowledgeable but also genuinely passionate about their craft.

As I explored the menu, it became clear that diversity is the name of the game. From artisanal sandwiches featuring their house-made charcuterie to a stunning selection of pickled goods, every bite is a celebration of flavor. And let's talk about their brunch options! It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience that leaves your taste buds dancing.

What really sets Turchetti's apart is their unique grocery market—a delightful surprise for your pantry or next meal prep. You can grab a few of their exceptional meats and cheeses to recreate that deli magic at home. Moreover, the great value for money ensures that you’ll get quality without breaking the bank.

If you're ready for a sensory adventure that tantalizes your palate, make sure to visit Turchetti's Salumeria—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Illinois Street Food Emporium

Highlights
Great sandwich options
Excellent customer service
Delicious dessert selection
Fresh and tasty ingredients
Take and bake items available

Illinois Street Food Emporium is truly a gem in the heart of Indianapolis! As I stepped inside, I was greeted with an aroma that immediately made my stomach rumble in anticipation. Their sandwich options are nothing short of spectacular—each creation is loaded with fresh and tasty ingredients that dance harmoniously together. I tried the classic pastrami on rye, and let me tell you, it was love at first bite!

What really sets this deli apart is the excellent customer service. The staff is not only friendly but genuinely passionate about what they serve. They were eager to recommend the best picks and I could tell they take pride in their food.

After indulging in their delightful sandwiches, I couldn’t resist checking out the delicious dessert selection. A slice of their homemade cheesecake was the perfect end to my meal, and I regret not having room for more!

To make things even more convenient, they offer take and bake items for those busy days. If you’re on the hunt for the best deli in Indianapolis, Illinois Street Food Emporium should definitely be on your radar. It’s a place where deliciousness meets dedication!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington

Highlights
Delicious cheesesteaks
Friendly atmosphere
Cooper Sharp Cheddar
Great fries
Charming decor

Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington has quickly become one of my go-to spots for a delightful deli experience in Indianapolis. As soon as I stepped through the door, the friendly atmosphere engulfed me like a warm hug. The charming decor adds character to the space, setting an inviting tone for a casual lunch or a quick snack.

Now, let’s talk about the real star of the show: the delicious cheesesteaks! I opted for the classic, and oh my, it was a savory symphony of flavors, featuring melt-in-your-mouth meat topped with Cooper Sharp Cheddar. Every bite is an adventure, transporting you to the streets of Philadelphia, while still feeling like a cherished local spot.

And let’s not overlook the sides—those great fries are the perfect accompaniment, crisp and lightly seasoned, making it hard to keep my hands off the extra serving. I can wholeheartedly say that Hoagies and Hops has mastered the art of deli fare, and it's hard not to leave with a smile. If you’re on the hunt for a spot that radiates charm and delivers flavor, this deli is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

New York Gourmet deli

Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, New York Gourmet Deli is a delightful oasis for sandwich lovers. From the moment I stepped inside, the aroma of fresh pastrami enveloped me, promising a taste of the Big Apple. I opted for the classic Reuben, piled high with tender corned beef and tangy sauerkraut, all nestled between perfectly toasted rye. Each bite was a symphony of flavors that danced on my palate. The friendly staff added a layer of warmth to the experience, making me feel right at home. If you’re searching for a bite that’s truly a New York experience, this deli is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

New York Gourmet Deli

Tucked into a cozy corner of Indianapolis, New York Gourmet Deli feels like a slice of the Big Apple. The moment I stepped in, the heavenly aroma of fresh bagels and savory pastrami enveloped me. The signature Reuben, piled high with tender meat and tangy sauerkraut, was nothing short of a masterpiece. The service radiated warmth, making me feel right at home. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors, perfectly crafted and unapologetically bold. For anyone seeking an authentic deli experience, New York Gourmet Deli truly stands out as a top contender in the Indianapolis deli scene.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Plainfield.

Goose The Market

Upon stepping into Goose The Market, I was instantly charmed by the vibrant atmosphere and the delightful aromas wafting through the air. The selection of housemade charcuterie and artisan cheeses is nothing short of impressive. I opted for the smoked pastrami sandwich, bursting with flavor and served on freshly baked bread. Every bite was a celebration of textures and tastes! The friendly staff added to the overall experience, making me feel right at home. If you’re searching for a deli that embodies quality and creativity, then Goose The Market is a culinary gem you must explore!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Subito

Subito is a delightful gem in the heart of Indianapolis that truly elevates the deli experience. The moment I stepped in, the aroma of fresh bread and savory meats enveloped me, promising culinary magic. I savored their signature sandwich, layered with tender pastrami and house-made pickles, which was a harmonious symphony of flavors. The staff welcomed me with genuine warmth, enhancing the inviting atmosphere. I appreciated the artisanal touches and attention to detail in every bite. If you're searching for a deli that balances tradition and innovation, Subito is an absolute MUST-TRY. Foodie paradise awaits!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Fat Dan's Deli

Stepping into Fat Dan's Deli, I was immediately enveloped by the rich aroma of freshly baked bread and zesty deli meats. I couldn’t resist trying the signature Fat Dan’s Pastrami sandwich, which was piled high with perfectly seasoned meat that practically danced on my palate. The tangy house-made sauces added an exquisite kick, truly elevating the experience. The playful atmosphere, gleaming with quirky decor, made each bite even more enjoyable. With a friendly staff eager to help, this deli is undoubtedly a gem in Indianapolis. For anyone craving a delightful sandwich, look no further—Fat Dan’s has you covered!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Cafe Olivia, IL Paninoteca, the Sandwich shop

Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Cafe Olivia, IL Paninoteca, the Sandwich shop is a delightful gem that offers a whimsical twist on classic deli fare. My taste buds danced as I savored their signature panini, perfectly pressed to golden perfection. The balance of fresh ingredients and bold flavors left me wanting more. The quirky decor and friendly staff created an inviting atmosphere that felt like a warm hug. Don't miss their house-made sauces; they elevate each bite to new heights! For anyone seeking a memorable sandwich experience, this spot is a must-visit. You won't regret indulging here!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Franklin.