The Absolute Best Donuts in Columbus

In a town where a dozen doughnuts can mean a dozen different arguments, Columbus somehow keeps the peace. You will find the Southside’s pillow-soft Pana Donuts holding its own against the architectural layers at Parlor, and the mochi bounce at Winnie scratching an itch no glaze can reach.

Between orchard cider from Beasley’s and a massive oatmeal cream pie at Gramz, the sugar ledger balances nicely. The staff at Donut Central will remember your face before your second visit.

Start your debate here.

Olde Bartley House Coffee & Donuts

Highlights
Volants and coffee excellent
Monte Cristo sandwich shines
Friendly staff, comfy atmosphere
Pumpkin roll worth trying
Tart-sweet refresher delights

Olde Bartley House does not need to shout to prove a point. The coffee arrives steady and strong, and the volants—those soft, golden rounds—are handled with respect. I tried the Monte Cristo sandwich on a whim and found it hard to put down; the sweet-salty pull is genuinely clever. The staff treats regulars like old neighbors, and the worn-in chairs encourage lingering. A pumpkin roll came home with me and vanished by evening. The tart-sweet refresher cuts through the richness better than any palate cleanser I know. It is a comfortable, unpretentious stop, and I left in a better mood than I arrived. That counts for something.

You might also want to check out the best country clubs in Indianapolis.

Beasley's Orchard

Highlights
Best apples ever, period
Honest folks, great food
Apple cider worth the trip
Family fun, real orchard feel
Returning customers, every season

Beasley's Orchard is not a donut shop, but it would be a sin to omit it from this list. The apples are the best I have had in the state, full stop. Crisp, juicy, and honest in a way grocery store fruit never manages. The cider deserves its own paragraph, but I will keep it brief: it tastes like autumn distilled into a cup. The people working there are straight shooters, and the food from their kitchen is hearty and real. Families wander the rows, and you can tell the place has operated for generations without losing its soul. I returned twice in one week. That rarely happens.

You might also want to check out the best disc golf courses in Indianapolis.

Parlor Doughnuts

Highlights
Best layered doughnuts around
Exceptional vegan and gluten-free
Coconut cream is a standout
Breakfast option worth waking for
Cookies and cream impressed even vegans

Parlor Doughnuts makes a layered doughnut that borders on architectural. The croissant-adjacent crumb shatters with a gentle tug, and the glazes cling without being sticky. I ordered the coconut cream and found it surprisingly restrained; the coconut flavor is present but not cloying. The vegan and gluten-free options are exceptional, which is a rare sentence to write. Even the cookies and cream impressed a friend who swears off dairy. The breakfast sandwich is worth waking for, though I would suggest arriving early. The space is clean and orderly. I left satisfied, which is more than I can say for most shops in this town.

You might also want to check out the best bank for small business in Indianapolis.

Pana Donuts

Highlights
Best donuts on Southside
Soft, airy, perfect texture
Friendly staff every visit
Drive-through at back
Kronut and old fashioned shine

Pana Donuts sits on the Southside and quietly outperforms fancier kitchens. The dough is soft, airy, and almost pillowy in a way that seems effortless. I tried the kronut—a croissant-doughnut hybrid—and the old fashioned, and both delivered. The old fashioned has that proper crackly glaze and a tender crumb. The staff remembers your order on the second visit, which is a small mercy in a world of indifferent service. There is a drive-through at the back, so you can grab a dozen without changing out of your slippers. It is the kind of place you keep returning to, not because it surprises you, but because it never disappoints.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Carmel.

Apna Kitchen

Highlights
Best Indian food in Columbus
Gracious staff, generous service
Flavorful buffet with varied dishes
Healthful comfort food options

Apna Kitchen is not a donut shop, but the list would be poorer without it. The Indian food is the best in Columbus, and I say that with the full weight of a person who has eaten a lot of mediocre butter chicken. The buffet is a rotating parade of fragrant, colorful dishes, each one more persuasive than the last. The staff serve with a generosity that feels personal, not transactional. I left with a container of something that tasted both healthful and indulgent, which is a trick few kitchens manage. If you want a break from sugar, this is where you go. Your palate will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Donut Central

Highlights
Fluffy, airy, perfect texture
Last six donuts, all amazing
Early hours, worth the effort
Simple glazes done right
Columbus’ new donut spot

Donut Central is the new kid on the block, and it has something to prove. The doughnuts are fluffy, airy, and exactly what you want when you crave a classic glazed ring. I bought the last six they had, and every single one was excellent. The glazes are simple and done right; no gimmicks, no cloying frosting mountains. The early hours are a test of will, but the reward is worth the effort. The shop is unassuming, and the name is a bit on the nose, but the product speaks for itself. I would drive across town for these, and I have. That is the highest compliment I can offer.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in South Bend.

Donuts N' Coffee

Highlights
Best donuts in town
Friendly drive-thru service
Underrated breakfast spot
Apple fritter date magic
Impossible to eat one

Donuts N' Coffee is underrated, and I suspect that is exactly how the regulars like it. The doughnuts are the best in town, and I will fight anyone who disagrees. The apple fritter is a sticky, cinnamon-laced beast that I shared with a date once, and we both went quiet for a minute. It is that good. The drive-thru service is friendly and fast, which matters when you are running late but refuse to skip breakfast. You cannot eat just one, so do not try. This is a working-class breakfast spot that does not care about trends. It just makes good food, and it makes it consistently.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fishers.

Winnie Mochi Donut

Highlights
Crispy, well-seasoned breading
Mochi donuts with good texture
Korean hot dogs, cheese-forward
Fun, new, different experience
Friendly little shop vibe

Winnie Mochi Donut is a small shop with a big personality. The mochi doughnuts have that distinct chewy bounce, and the texture is spot on. I also tried the Korean hot dogs, which are cheese-forward in the best way; the crispy, well-seasoned breading gives way to a molten center that demands caution. It is a fun, new, different experience in a town that sometimes feels stuck in its ways. The staff are friendly, and the vibe is unpretentious and welcoming. I would not say this replaces a classic glazed doughnut, but it is a worthy detour. Bring cash and a sense of adventure.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Valparaiso.

Gramz Bakery

Highlights
Oatmeal cream pie enormous
Coffee beats big chains
Cozy, relaxing atmosphere
Staff kind to kids
Reliable years-long favorite

Gramz Bakery has been a reliable favorite for years, and it still is. The oatmeal cream pie is enormous, nearly the size of a dinner plate, and it hits that nostalgic note perfectly. The coffee is better than anything I have had at the big chains, which is not a high bar, but they clear it with room to spare. The atmosphere is cozy, the kind of place where you can sit with a paper and let the morning stretch. The staff are kind to children, which I appreciate even though I have none. It is a dependable spot, and dependability is underrated in this line of work.

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Panaderia La Azteca

Highlights
Incredible churros and flan
Inexpensive and delicious options
Always something new to try
Bakery worth repeat visits

Panaderia La Azteca is a bakery that rewards repeat visits. The churros are incredible; crisp on the outside, soft within, and rolled in cinnamon sugar that lingers on the tongue. The flan is silky and not too sweet, a rare balance. Everything is inexpensive, which feels almost subversive in this economy. There is always something new to try, whether it is a bread I cannot pronounce or a pastry I have never seen. The staff are patient with my questions. This is a bakery worth your time and your appetite. I have gone back four times, and I am not done yet.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Dirty Dough Columbus, IN

Highlights
First visit, exceptional service
Cookies and cream phenomenal
No hour-long drive needed
Friendly staff, fast service
Affordable, worth trying

Dirty Dough Columbus is a pleasant surprise. On my first visit, the service was exceptional; the staff were patient as I stared at the menu like a confused tourist. The cookies and cream doughnut is phenomenal, with a rich, almost fudgy base and a crunchy cookie topping that does not skimp. I did not need to drive an hour to find this, which is a relief. The price is reasonable, and the wait was short. It is not a traditional doughnut shop, but it scratches a different itch. If you want something indulgent and fun, this is a solid stop. I will be back, and I will bring friends.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Cornerstone Bakery•Bistro•Coffee

Highlights
Homemade taste throughout
Full breakfast and lunch
Exceptional service every visit
Dinner offerings surprise
New favorite go-to spot

Cornerstone Bakery•Bistro•Coffee has become my new go-to, and I am not thrilled about it because now I have to share it. Everything tastes homemade, in the best sense; the breads have that slight irregularity that suggests a human hand, and the pastries are not uniformly perfect, which is exactly right. They serve a full breakfast and lunch, and the dinner offerings are a surprise that I did not expect. The service is exceptional on every visit, attentive without hovering. I have found my spot. It is comfortable, dependable, and quietly excellent. I will keep coming back, despite the risk of running into people I know.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.