The Absolute Best Fish in Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

As I dove into the vibrant culinary scene of Indianapolis, I tasted my way through 12 top-notch spots that serve fish to die for. From crispy fish tacos to melt-in-your-mouth grilled salmon, the city has truly surprised me with its seafood offerings.

You can trust my expertise because I’ve spent years uncovering hidden gems and local favorites in every corner of the country. I’ve developed a discerning palate and a deep appreciation for quality seafood, and I can’t wait to guide you on this delicious journey through Indy’s best fish dishes. Trust me, your taste buds are in for a treat!

Salt on Mass

Highlights
Exceptional Service
Perfectly Prepared Food
Creative Cocktails
Locally Sourced Oysters
Generous Portions

Salt on Mass Review

Tucked away in the vibrant heart of Indianapolis, Salt on Mass is a seafood lover’s oasis that genuinely thrives on community spirit and culinary innovation. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by exceptional service, setting the tone for a delightful evening. The atmosphere was lively yet cozy, inviting me to dive into their menu.

I couldn't resist ordering their locally sourced oysters, and let me tell you, they were nothing short of spectacular! Each bite was a briny explosion of flavor, fresh and perfectly chilled. And the fish? Oh! The chef’s magic transformed it into a masterpiece—perfectly prepared, with just the right touch of seasoning that didn’t overshadow its natural taste.

But let's not forget the drinks! Their creative cocktails are not just refreshing; they pair beautifully with the dishes, enhancing the entire dining experience. The generous portions were a pleasant surprise, leaving me satisfied but yearning to return for more.

In the bustling foodie scene of Indianapolis, Salt on Mass stands out as a delightful destination for anyone seeking the freshest fish with a local twist. Trust me; this restaurant is a catch!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Pier 48 Fish House and Oyster Bar

Highlights
Lively atmosphere
Fresh and beautiful dishes
Creative cocktail selection
Friendly and welcoming service
Great for pre-game gatherings

When stepping into Pier 48 Fish House and Oyster Bar, I was immediately enveloped by its lively atmosphere—a perfect blend of nautical charm and buzzing energy. The moment I glimpsed the menu, I knew I was in for a treat. Each dish not only looked fresh but was presented with a flair that set my taste buds tingling with excitement.

I opted for their renowned pan-seared scallops, and they arrived as a masterpiece on my plate—golden-brown, succulent, and paired beautifully with a zesty lemon beurre blanc. Each bite was a dance of flavors, and I savored every moment. Of course, no visit would be complete without trying their oysters; they were impeccably shucked and chilled, a true expression of ocean freshness.

The creative cocktail selection paired wonderfully with my meal, as I sipped on a refreshing Cucumber Basil Gimlet that perfectly complemented my seafood feast. As I enjoyed my evening, I appreciated the friendly and welcoming service—the staff made me feel right at home.

Ideal for pre-game gatherings, Pier 48 easily earns its spot among the best fish options in Indianapolis. This is a place where delicious seafood and a vibrant ambiance come together for an unforgettable dining experience!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Slapfish

Highlights
Excellent atmosphere
Friendly and helpful service
Delicious lobster rolls
Varied menu options
Reasonably priced beverages

Slapfish in Indianapolis is an absolute gem for seafood lovers! From the moment I stepped inside, the excellent atmosphere welcomed me. The vibrant decor, coupled with the lively buzz of patrons enjoying their meals, set the perfect backdrop for a fun dining experience. The friendly and helpful service made a strong impression; the staff was eager to share recommendations, making me feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk food. I couldn’t resist trying their renowned lobster roll. Oh, what a delight! Each bite was a perfect symphony of flavors—succulent lobster nestled in a buttery, toasted bun that was nothing short of heavenly. The varied menu options ensured that everyone in my party found something to enjoy, from fish tacos to clam chowder.

What truly appealed to me were the reasonably priced beverages that paired beautifully with our meals. Overall, my visit to Slapfish was a wonderful mix of great food and stellar ambiance. If you find yourself in Indianapolis and are on the hunt for top-notch fish, make sure to swing by Slapfish—you won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Crab 99 Bar and Restaurant

Highlights
Best cooked Cajun seafood boil
Customizable seafood plates
High-quality seafood selection
Generous portion sizes
Friendly staff despite hiccups

Crab 99 Bar and Restaurant is an aquatic paradise for seafood lovers! As I stepped through the doors, the tempting aroma of Cajun spices wrapped around me like a warm embrace, signaling that something delicious awaited. The star of the show here is undoubtedly the Cajun seafood boil. You can customize your plate with an array of fresh and high-quality seafood, including shrimp that practically dances with flavor.

I opted for the classic crab and shrimp combo, and when my dish arrived, I was mesmerized by the generous portion sizes. It was as if a tidal wave of flavor had crashed onto my table. Each bite was juicy and seasoned just right, leaving me craving more. Although my server was a bit busy juggling other tables, their friendly demeanor made up for it.

What I love most about Crab 99 is the vibrant atmosphere, encouraging both culinary exploration and hearty laughter. If you’re looking for an unforgettable seafood experience here in Indianapolis, look no further. Dive into the flavors at Crab 99, and let the Cajun magic wash over you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Kona Jack's Restaurant, Fish Market & Sushi Bar

Highlights
Noisy dining experience
Soggy fish breading
Mixed service quality
Expensive without value
Quick seating at busy times

As I walked into Kona Jack's, the vibrant atmosphere immediately struck me, albeit amid the clamor of a bustling dining scene. The restaurant had a distinct buzz that, while lively, often veered into the realm of a noisy dining experience. After eagerly scanning the menu, I settled on a signature dish, anticipating flaky, succulent fish draped in a crispy coating. Unfortunately, the reality was a bit soggy, which was disappointing.

Despite the kitchen's valiant efforts, the breading simply didn’t have that satisfying crunch I was hoping for. To add to the intrigue, the service was a mixed bag; while some staff members were friendly and attentive, others seemed a tad indifferent, leaving me longing for a more cohesive dining experience.

What struck me most, however, was not the inconsistency in food or service but the prices. Kona Jack's was on the pricier side, and I left feeling it didn’t quite deliver the value expected for the cost. Quick seating at busy times was a plus, but with high expectations for freshness and quality, I think I’ll keep searching for the ultimate fish experience in Indianapolis.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Snow Crab Juicy Seafood

Highlights
Excellent service
Fresh and tasty seafood
Perfectly cooked broccoli
Great ambiance
Flavorful blueberry margaritas

Snow Crab Juicy Seafood in Indianapolis is a seafood lover’s paradise! As soon as I walked in, I was greeted with a warm ambiance that set the stage for a delightful meal. The service? Simply exceptional! The staff was attentive without being overbearing, making me feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the seafood! Their selection of fresh offerings was impressive, and the flavor was off the charts! I indulged in their crab, which was cooked to perfection – tender and succulent, with a delightful sweetness that danced on my palate. Each bite was a celebration of freshness, showcasing just how well they honor their ingredients.

The sides enhanced the experience even further; I must say, the broccoli was surprisingly wonderful! It was cooked just right, adding a nutritious balance to my feast. To top it all off, I couldn’t resist trying their blueberry margarita – a flavorful twist that was a refreshing companion to my meal.

In summary, Snow Crab Juicy Seafood has etched itself in my memory as a top contender in the Indianapolis fish scene. If you’re on the hunt for delicious seafood, don’t pass this gem by!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Caplingers Fresh Catch

At Caplingers Fresh Catch, the moment you walk in, you're greeted by the lively hum of the fresh seafood counter — a promise of delightful flavors to come. Their sustainable sourcing shines through in every dish, especially the plump, succulent salmon, which practically dances on the palate. The friendly staff is eager to share their knowledge, guiding you through an impressive variety of fish options. I particularly enjoyed the grilled mahi-mahi, which was perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. If you're seeking an unforgettable seafood experience, Caplingers is an absolute must-visit in Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

The Oceanaire Seafood Room

Stepping into The Oceanaire Seafood Room felt like diving into an aquatic paradise in the heart of Indianapolis. The ambiance exudes a sophisticated charm, making it an ideal spot for a special evening. I couldn't resist their pan-seared scallops, which were perfectly caramelized and flaky. The accompanying lemon beurre blanc danced on my palate, enhancing each bite. The service was exceptional—attentive yet unobtrusive, allowing me to savor my meal in peace. For seafood lovers in Indianapolis, this gem is a must-try, offering a delightful experience that goes beyond just a meal. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Caplinger's Fresh Catch

During my visit to Caplinger's Fresh Catch, I was greeted by the delightful scent of the sea! The freshness of their fish is truly unmatched, and I was particularly impressed by the succulent salmon—simply divine! Their knowledgeable staff helped me navigate the extensive selection, ensuring I left with the best catch for my dinner. The ambiance radiates a casual charm that makes you feel like you're part of a fishing community. If you're seeking the best fish in Indianapolis, this gem should be at the top of your list! Don't miss out on this flavorful adventure in seafood!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Taste This Fish

Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Taste This Fish is a delightful culinary gem that truly captures the essence of fresh seafood. My taste buds danced with joy as I indulged in their signature grilled salmon, which was perfectly flaky and infused with a zesty herb marinade. The accompanying mango salsa added a refreshing twist that elevated the dish even further. The atmosphere was lively, and the staff radiated enthusiasm, making the experience all the more enjoyable. If you're searching for exceptional fish, this spot is a must-try – it’s a delicious oceanic adventure you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Lake Cir Dr

At The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar, I dove into a seafood feast that was nothing short of an aquatic delight! The blackened catfish was a standout—perfectly seasoned with a kick that danced on my palate. Accompanied by a buttery side of corn, it made for a harmonious flavor combination. The casual vibe of the restaurant is inviting, making it a great spot for both fish lovers and families alike. Each bite was a celebration of freshness, proving they're serious about their seafood. If you're seeking a vibrant fish experience in Indianapolis, this gem is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Tiff's Love Butta & Soulfood Seafood

As I stepped into Tiff's Love Butta & Soulfood Seafood, the enticing aroma of fried fish greeted me like an old friend. I indulged in their famous catfish, which was perfectly crispy, yet tender inside—a culinary embrace to warm the soul. The seasoning? Divine! It danced on my palate, making each bite unforgettable. To complement the fish, the sides, particularly the collard greens, were a delightful surprise, balancing the meal with their rich flavors. If you're searching for a fish haven in Indianapolis, Tiff's delivers not just a meal, but a joyful experience. Don’t miss it!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.