The Absolute Best Ice Cream in Evansville [Updated 2025]

Let me tell you, Evansville has some serious ice cream magic happening! I’ve scoured the city and indulged in every scoop, swirl, and sundae I could find, meticulously reviewing 12 top locations that promise to tickle your taste buds. With my travel blog dedicated to uncovering hidden gems and delectable delights, you can trust that I’ve tasted the best and the not-so-great, so you don’t have to!

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, I guarantee you’ll want to know where to find the creamiest, most inventive flavors that will make your summer (or any season, really) feel like a celebration. Get ready to dive into a world of sweet sensations that Evansville has to offer!

JB's Barnyard Ice Cream

Highlights
Quality products and service
Diverse flavor varieties
Friendly and welcoming owners
Enjoyable petting zoo experience
Complimentary treats available

When I stepped into JB's Barnyard Ice Cream, the cheerful atmosphere enveloped me like a warm hug. Not only does this gem boast quality products and service, but it also offers an extensive selection of flavor varieties that dazzle the taste buds. Choosing a scoop is delightfully challenging—should I go for the creamy Cookies and Cream or the refreshing Mint Chocolate Chip? The friendly and welcoming owners made the decision even harder as they offered samples with genuine enthusiasm.

Beyond the delicious ice cream, JB's stands out with its enjoyable petting zoo experience. As I savored my treat, surrounded by adorable goats and bunnies, I couldn’t help but smile at the joyful ambiance. It truly felt like a mini vacation—a perfect retreat for families and ice cream enthusiasts alike.

The experience gets even sweeter as they often have complimentary treats available, which is a charming touch that enhances the overall delight. In a city filled with ice cream shops, JB's Barnyard Ice Cream offers a unique blend of flavor, fun, and friendliness that makes it a must-visit destination in Evansville. You can't help but leave with a smile—and perhaps a new favorite flavor!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Pangea Kitchen

Highlights
Delicious gelato and sorbet
Friendly and helpful staff
Unique pizza concept
Great for a quick snack
Enjoyable dessert options

Pangea Kitchen: An Ice Cream Delight

Visiting Pangea Kitchen in Evansville was a delightful revelation! Known for their delicious gelato and sorbet, this place delivers a refreshing and flavorful experience that is hard to resist. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by the friendly and helpful staff who were eager to guide me through their unique offerings.

I decided to sample their gelato, and it was a creamy dream come true! The rich and vibrant flavors danced on my palate, making each spoonful feel like a celebration. Whether you're a fan of classic favorites or more adventurous combinations, there's something to tickle everyone's taste buds.

Pangea isn't just about ice cream, though. They also feature a unique pizza concept, making ita perfect spot for a quick snack before indulging in dessert. This blend of savory and sweet adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the experience.

If you're looking for one of the best ice creams in Evansville, I wholeheartedly recommend Pangea Kitchen. With enjoyable dessert options and a cozy atmosphere, you won't want to miss out on this gem! Treat yourself; you deserve it!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe

My visit to Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe was a delightful adventure for my taste buds! The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by the irresistible aroma of freshly made waffle cones. I indulged in a scoop of their signature Salted Caramel Pretzel, where sweet and salty tangoed in perfect harmony. The ice cream was luxuriously creamy, boasting a rich flavor with delightful crunchy bits. The friendly staff made sure I felt right at home, serving my treat with a generous smile. If you’re on a quest for ice cream that delights and surprises, Milk & Sugar should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Rivertown Ice Cream and Grill

Rivertown Ice Cream and Grill is a charming gem that elevates your classic ice cream outing. As I stepped inside, the nostalgic atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm hug. Their unique flavors like caramel pretzel crunch and lavender honey sparked my curiosity, and each scoop was a delightful surprise. The creamy texture had me savoring every bite, while the friendly staff added a sprinkle of joy to my visit. I left with a smile, already planning my next trip. For those seeking a delicious and fun experience, Rivertown is a must! 🍦 Indulge your sweet tooth!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Gerst Bavarian Haus

As I stepped into Gerst Bavarian Haus, the rich aroma of traditional Bavarian cuisine mingled with the sweet scent of ice cream. Their house-made flavors are a delightful surprise, particularly the German chocolate cake—a creamy, decadent treat that left me smiling. The balance of sweetness and texture was impeccable. I also savored their classic vanilla, which paired perfectly with a warm apple strudel from their kitchen. The ambiance of the restaurant made my ice cream experience even more delightful. If you find yourself in Evansville, be sure to indulge in this gem that beautifully marries tradition and taste!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Big Top Drive In

My visit to Big Top Drive In was nothing short of delightful! As I approached the vibrant, circus-themed exterior, I was instantly transported to a whimsical land of sweets. I opted for their creamy Dreamsicle Sundae, a delightful concoction of orange ice cream crowned with fluffy whipped cream and a cherry on top. Each spoonful was a nostalgic journey that evoked memories of summer days. The service was friendly and prompt, adding to the overall experience. If you're craving a playful treat that does not compromise on quality, Big Top Drive In is a must-visit destination for ice cream lovers in Evansville!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Zesto on Franklin

I recently indulged my sweet tooth at Zesto on Franklin, a delightful gem in Evansville's ice cream scene. The moment I walked in, the nostalgic charm enveloped me, and I was greeted by a mouthwatering array of flavors. I opted for their signature Scoop of the Day, a creamy concoction that perfectly balanced sweetness and richness. Each bite was a celebration, leaving me craving more. The staff was friendly and eager to help with flavor choices, enhancing the experience. Zesto's inviting atmosphere and delectable offerings make it a must-try for any ice cream lover in town!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Helados

Stepping into Helados is like entering a sweet wonderland! The moment I tasted their mango sorbet, I was transported to a tropical paradise. It's incredibly refreshing, bursting with authentic fruit flavor and just the right amount of sweetness. Their unique offering of tres leches ice cream stood out too, with its creamy texture and delightful hints of vanilla. The ambiance is vibrant and inviting, making it a perfect spot to indulge. If you're in Evansville and craving a delightful scoop (or two), Helados should be at the top of your list for a treat that delights the senses!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Honey Moon Coffee Weinbach

Stepping into Honey Moon Coffee Weinbach felt like a warm embrace on a sunny afternoon! Their ice cream selection is a delightful blend of classic and inventive flavors—did I mention the lavender honey? It sings summer in every scoop! The rich and creamy texture paired with the cozy café vibes makes this spot a must-visit. Their friendly staff offered samples, elevating the experience further. Overall, I left with a cone that felt like a mini celebration of flavor, making it a top contender in Evansville’s ice cream scene. Treat yourself—you won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Lic's Deli & Ice Cream

During my delightful visit to Lic's Deli & Ice Cream, I was greeted by an irresistible array of flavors that made my taste buds dance. The Mint Chocolate Chip was a standout—refreshing with just the right amount of chocolatey crunch. It felt like a cool breeze on a warm day! The cozy atmosphere of the deli, paired with friendly staff, truly enhances the experience. I loved the option to choose between a classic cone or a fun sundae. If you're craving a sweet escape in Evansville, Lic's is a must-visit for all ice cream enthusiasts! 🍦

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

G D Ritzy's

At G D Ritzy's, I was immediately greeted by a whimsical atmosphere that perfectly matches their vibrant flavors. I sampled their signature Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, which was a delightful blend of creamy vanilla and decadent chunks of cookie dough that felt like a hug in a cone. The heaping scoops were generously served, making each bite a joyful experience. I loved the playful vibe and friendly staff, who were more than happy to offer suggestions. If you're in Evansville and craving something sweet, don’t miss a trip to G D Ritzy's—it's a delightful stop for any ice cream lover!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

D-Ice cream & bubble tea boba drinks

At D-Ice, you're in for a treat that tickles your taste buds! Their creamy ice cream is a whirlwind of flavor, with options ranging from classic vanilla to adventurous taro and matcha. I couldn't resist trying the boba tea, and it was a delightful shock of texture and sweetness. The ambiance is vibrant, making it a perfect spot to unwind with friends. If you're on the hunt for a unique dessert experience, D-Ice is a must-try! Overall, it’s a fun destination that blends traditional ice cream with innovative twists. Don't miss it!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.