The Absolute Best Mexican Restaurants in Downtown Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

Whether you’re a taco aficionado or just someone who loves a good guacamole, you’re in for a treat! After digging into the vibrant food scene here, I’ve rounded up 12 top-notch Mexican restaurants that truly capture the heart and soul of this cuisine.

With years of exploring every corner of downtown, I’ve tasted everything from street-style tacos to gourmet enchiladas, and I can confidently say these spots are the cream of the crop. Trust me, your taste buds are about to embark on a delicious journey through flavors that will make you feel like you’re right in the heart of Mexico!

Los Arroyos Mexican Restaurant & Bar

Highlights
Relaxed dining atmosphere
Generously portioned burritos
Fresh, high-quality ingredients
Friendly and efficient service
Fantastic Tamarindo Margarita

Los Arroyos Mexican Restaurant & Bar in Downtown Indianapolis is a delightful gem that captures the vibrant essence of Mexican cuisine. As I stepped through the doors, I was immediately enveloped by a relaxed dining atmosphere that felt warm and inviting. The vibrant décor set the stage for an exciting culinary adventure.

I decided to indulge in one of their generously portioned burritos, and let me tell you, it was a culinary masterpiece! Each bite was a harmonious symphony of fresh, high-quality ingredients that danced on my palate, making it impossible to stop at just one bite. The portions were so generous that I felt I could easily share—if I were willing to part with it, that is!

To wash it all down, I treated myself to a fantastic Tamarindo Margarita, which was refreshing and perfectly balanced, enhancing the dining experience. I must also commend the friendly and efficient service; the staff made me feel right at home while offering helpful recommendations.

In short, Los Arroyos is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Mexican food and an inviting atmosphere in Downtown Indianapolis. 😋 ¡Olé!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Bloomington.

Mr Tequila's Cantina & Grill

Highlights
Fantastic bartenders
Beyond expectations food
Amazing margaritas
Friendly service
Must-try tequila

Mr Tequila's Cantina & Grill has quickly captured my heart—and taste buds! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the inviting aroma of spices and a vibrant atmosphere that set the stage for a delightful meal. The fantastic bartenders really know their craft, mixing up some of the most amazing margaritas I've ever had. I opted for the house special, and let me tell you, it was a refreshing blend that perfectly complemented my meal.

Speaking of food, each dish was beyond expectations! I indulged in their signature tacos, which were filled to the brim with flavorful ingredients that danced on my palate. The emphasis on quality and authenticity really shines through.

To top it all off, the friendly service made the experience all the more enjoyable. The staff was incredibly attentive and genuinely seemed passionate about the menu. Plus, for all the tequila aficionados out there, don’t miss the chance to explore their extensive selection—it's definitely a must-try!

In short, Mr Tequila’s is a must-visit destination for anyone in search of authentic Mexican cuisine in Downtown Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in Evansville.

La Chinita Poblana

Highlights
Tasty shrimp tacos
Affordable drinks
Good black beans & rice
Warm tortilla chips
Expansive menu options

La Chinita Poblana is a delightful oasis of flavor nestled in the heart of Downtown Indianapolis. As I stepped inside, the vibrant ambiance set the tone for an exciting culinary adventure. I ordered the tasty shrimp tacos, and let me tell you, they were nothing short of sensational! Each bite was a heavenly blend of seasonings and freshness that sent my taste buds dancing.

The affordability of the drinks was another pleasant surprise. I enjoyed a refreshing beverage that perfectly complemented my meal without making my wallet weep. Speaking of perfection, the side of good black beans and rice was a highlight. The rich, savory flavors offered a delicious contrast to the tacos and added a touch of comfort to the meal.

If you’re a fan of warm tortilla chips, you’ll be thrilled with La Chinita's crispy, golden chips served with a vibrant salsa that made me crave more. With an expansive menu, La Chinita Poblana is a treasure trove for anyone seeking authentic Mexican flavors in a warm and inviting atmosphere. If you're in the downtown area, don’t miss out on this gem that promises a fiesta for your senses!

You might also want to check out the best romantic restaurants in Indianapolis.

Social Cantina

At Social Cantina, I found a vibrant atmosphere that buzzes with energy, perfect for casual hangouts. The tacos are a standout, bursting with flavor and creativity—don’t miss the carnitas or the zesty fish tacos. The margaritas? Simply divine! Each sip is a refreshing fiesta that complements the spicy notes of the dishes. The eclectic decor adds a fun twist, making it a visual treat as well. Whether you're looking to unwind after work or enjoy a lively evening with friends, Social Cantina delivers a memorable experience in the heart of Downtown Indianapolis.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Agave and Rye Indianapolis

Agave and Rye Indianapolis is an absolute gem nestled in Downtown Indianapolis! From the moment I stepped inside, the vibrant atmosphere and the tantalizing aroma of spices enveloped me. Their tacos are nothing short of extraordinary—each bite bursting with flavor and creativity. I highly recommend the brisket and the tequila-lime shrimp options for a delightful twist. Don’t skip the craft cocktails; the mezcal margarita was a standout! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, making the whole experience even more enjoyable. Whether you’re looking for a lively night out or a casual lunch, Agave and Rye is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best new restaurants in Valparaiso.

Bakersfield Mass Ave

During my recent visit to Bakersfield Mass Ave, I was greeted with a vibrant atmosphere that instantly transported me to a lively Mexican fiesta. The street-style tacos were the star of the show—each bite bursts with flavor, showcasing fresh ingredients. I also savored their house-made guacamole, which was creamy perfection alongside crispy tortilla chips. Their vast selection of tequilas invites exploration, making it the ideal spot for a festive evening. Overall, Bakersfield provides a delightful twist on classic Mexican fare, making it a must-visit destination for anyone craving an unforgettable culinary adventure in downtown Indy!

You might also want to check out the best new restaurants in Muncie.

Livery

Nestled within the vibrant heart of Downtown Indianapolis, Livery transports you straight to Mexico with its lively ambiance and tantalizing flavors. Upon entering, I was greeted by a blend of vibrant decor and a welcoming atmosphere that set the tone for an unforgettable meal. The Pork Carnitas are a must-try—juicy, flavorful, and perfectly complemented by house-made tortillas. I also recommend indulging in their Margaritas, which are both refreshing and delightfully potent. With every dish, Livery manages to strike a balance between authenticity and creativity, making it a standout destination for anyone craving Mexican cuisine in the city. 🍹🌮

You might also want to check out the best new restaurants in Greenwood.

El Toro Bravo Downtown

El Toro Bravo Downtown is a delightful gem in the heart of Indianapolis that captures the spirit of authentic Mexican cuisine. The vibrant atmosphere immediately puts you in a festive mood, complemented by their friendly staff who treat you like family. I indulged in their signature huevos rancheros, which boasted perfectly cooked eggs topped with a zesty salsa that danced on my palate. Don’t skip the fresh-made guacamole—it’s a creamy, avocado-laden masterpiece. The colorful decor adds an extra layer of charm. If you’re hunting for a lively spot with fantastic flavors, El Toro Bravo is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Julieta Taco Shop

During my recent visit to Julieta Taco Shop, I was instantly captivated by its vibrant atmosphere and mouthwatering aromas. The tacos—each a delectable masterpiece—boasted fresh ingredients and bold flavors, making every bite a treat. I particularly enjoyed the carnitas, which were tender and perfectly seasoned. The friendly staff added a sprinkle of warmth to the experience, making me feel right at home. Don’t forget to pair your meal with their refreshing house-made aguas frescas! If you're chasing authentic flavors in a lively setting, Julieta Taco Shop is a must-visit in Downtown Indianapolis. 🌮✨

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

La Eskina Indy

La Eskina Indy is a delightful gem in the heart of Downtown Indianapolis! The vibrant ambiance immediately draws you in, and the colorful murals add a touch of authenticity. I indulged in their street tacos, bursting with flavor and generously filled with fresh ingredients. The homemade salsas are a must-try, bringing just the right amount of heat to each bite. The staff is warm and welcoming, making you feel right at home. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, La Eskina Indy is sure to satisfy your cravings for delicious Mexican cuisine.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Condado Tacos

At Condado Tacos, I indulged in a vibrant atmosphere that perfectly complements their playful taco creations. The ability to customize each taco with fresh, bold ingredients is a delight for any foodie. I opted for the crispy shell filled with spicy chorizo and topped it with their zesty jalapeño sauce—absolutely divine! Their margaritas, crafted with care, are a refreshing accompaniment to each bite. The staff was warm and welcoming, adding to the overall charm of this gem. With its fun vibe and mouthwatering options, Condado Tacos is a must-visit for taco enthusiasts in the heart of the city!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Tlaolli

Tlaolli is a delightful gem hidden in the heart of Downtown Indianapolis. From the moment I stepped in, vibrant colors and lively music enveloped me, creating an inviting atmosphere. The menu is a fiesta of traditional Mexican flavors, and I couldn't resist their playful twist on tamales—each bite was a symphony of taste! The staff was warm and attentive, ensuring my experience was nothing short of excellent. With every dish, I felt as if I was transported to a cozy cantina in Mexico. If you're in search of authentic flavors and an upbeat ambiance, Tlaolli is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.