The Absolute Best Pie in Evansville [Updated 2026]

You know that feeling when you take your first bite of pie, and it’s like the world fades away for just a moment? That’s what I chase every time I step into a local bakery. After countless tastings and a few too many sugar highs, I’ve zeroed in on one top spot that truly stands out.

With my years of indulging in Evansville’s dessert delights, I’ve developed a keen palate for what makes a pie extraordinary. Whether it’s the flaky crust or the perfectly balanced filling, I know the good stuff when I taste it. So, if you’re ready to elevate your pie game, let’s dive into the sweetest slice of Evansville you won’t want to miss!

Be Happy Pie Company

Stepping into Be Happy Pie Company is like entering a slice of heaven! Their signature peach cobbler pie is a delightful dance of sweet and tangy flavors, nestled in a perfectly flaky crust that crumbles just right. The care and passion in every pie is evident, making each bite a joyful celebration. I was particularly impressed by their creative flavor combinations, like the lavender blueberry—a refreshing twist that ignites the taste buds. If you’re seeking a slice of happiness, Be Happy is the place to indulge. Overall, a delightful destination for pie lovers in Evansville!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.