Seymour's Best Pizza

Seymour’s pizza game is a peculiar map of detours. One night you’re pulling up to Pizza Palace for a crisp, generous pie that locals swear by; the next you’re at a Mexican joint ordering salsa, not slices, because the pizza there is a placeholder.

We ate at a wood-fired place with a rustic interior, and we sat at a Chili’s. The brewing company tempted us with beer cheese, while a party spot kept the kids busy.

The truth about this town? It’s about knowing when a craving is a craving.

Here’s the list you follow.

Brooklyn Pizza Co

Highlights
Meat lover's pizza fantastic
Friendly staff, cool atmosphere
Small but solid beer selection
Attentive bartender service

Brooklyn Pizza Co. hits the spot when you want a straightforward slice without fuss. The meat lover's pizza is fantastic, loaded with toppings that actually taste fresh. Staff were friendly and the atmosphere felt relaxed, even during a busy evening. They have a small but solid beer selection, which pairs nicely with the pies. What stood out most was the bartender, who was attentive without hovering. If you're in the mood for a classic pizza experience with good service, this place works. It's not fancy, but it doesn't need to be. I'd come back for that meat lover's again.

You might also want to check out the best hiking in Indianapolis.

The Seymour Brewing Co.

Highlights
Delicious chocolate raspberry porter
Friendly and interactive owner
Highly recommended sweet chili wings
Best beer cheese with pretzel stix
Great spot for live music

The Seymour Brewing Co. surprised me in the best way. Their chocolate raspberry porter is delicious, with a rich, smooth flavor that doesn't overwhelm. The owner was friendly and interactive, even taking time to chat about the brewing process. I tried the sweet chili wings, which are highly recommended, and they didn't disappoint—crispy with a nice kick. The beer cheese with pretzel stix was the best I've had, creamy and tangy. Live music added a nice background vibe without being too loud. This is a place you linger, and I didn't want to leave.

You might also want to check out the best places to live in Indianapolis.

Brewskies Downtown

Highlights
Friendly service and drinks
Pizza quality varies recently
Affordable large pizza option
Convenient Seymour downtown stop

Brewskies Downtown is convenient if you're in Seymour, and the service is friendly. I stopped in for a drink and a bite, and the staff made me feel welcome. However, I noticed the pizza quality varies recently—one visit was great, another was just okay. The large pizza is affordable, so you get value for your money, but consistency is an issue. It's a good spot for a casual drink, and the downtown location makes it easy to pop in. If they can stabilize the pizza quality, it'd be a top pick. As is, it's fine for a quick meal, but don't expect perfection every time.

You might also want to check out the best lakes in Indianapolis.

Fun Blast

Highlights
Attentive, helpful party staff
Easy online booking process
Great food for events
Fun pool table for groups
Kids enjoy themselves thoroughly

Fun Blast is more about the atmosphere than the food, and that's fine if you know what you're getting. The staff are attentive and helpful, especially for parties—they really know how to handle a group. Booking online was easy, which saved time. The food is decent for event fare, nothing fancy but satisfying. The pool table is a fun addition, and kids genuinely enjoy themselves here. It's a good place for a birthday or casual gathering. If you're seeking a gourmet pizza, look elsewhere. But for a fun night out with friends or family, it works well. I'd come back for the vibe.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artists in Indianapolis.

Mi Casa Mexican Restaurant

Highlights
Amazing service and fresh flavors
Great value for the money
Friendly staff and tasty tortillas
White meat chicken done right
Salsa that steals the show

Mi Casa Mexican Restaurant brings a lively energy, but the pizza here is not the star. That said, their service is amazing, and the staff are incredibly friendly. The flavors are fresh, though I'd stick to their Mexican dishes rather than pizza. Value is great for the money, and the tortillas taste homemade. They use white meat chicken, which is a plus, cooked right. The salsa really steals the show—fresh, with a nice heat. If you're in the mood for something different, this place is worth a visit. Just don't expect a classic pizza experience. I left happy, but my pizza cravings weren't fully satisfied.

You might also want to check out the best companies to work for in Indianapolis.

El Nopal Mexican Cuisine

Highlights
Authentic Mexican food
High-quality, reliable dishes
Strong customer loyalty

El Nopal Mexican Cuisine serves authentic Mexican food, and that's its strength. The dishes are high-quality and reliable, with flavors that feel genuine. I didn't try the pizza here, but based on the rest of the menu, the kitchen knows what it's doing. There's strong customer loyalty, which tells you they do something right. The staff are welcoming and the portions are generous. If you want pizza, you might be disappointed, but if you're open to other options, this is a solid choice. I appreciated the consistent service and the care in preparation. It's a good addition to Seymour's dining options, even if it's not a pizza joint.

You might also want to check out the best florist in Indianapolis.

Chili's Grill & Bar

Highlights
Fast, friendly service
Flavorful Cajun pasta
Consistent quality yearly

Chili's Grill & Bar is a dependable stop, and this location holds up. The service is fast and friendly, which matters when you're hungry. Their Cajun pasta is flavorful, with just enough spice to keep it interesting. I've been here multiple times, and the quality is consistent year after year—you know what you're getting. It's not the place for artisan pizza, but they do have a decent flatbread if you're in the mood. The atmosphere is familiar and comfortable. If you're passing through and want a reliable meal, this works. I'd return for the pasta and the steady service.

You might also want to check out the best bed and breakfast in Indianapolis.

Pizzalicious

Highlights
Extensive menu board choices
Cool rustic wood interior
Great food for travelers
Highly recommended by patrons

Pizzalicious offers an extensive menu board, so you'll find plenty of options beyond basic cheese and pepperoni. The rustic wood interior gives it a cozy, warm feel that's different from typical pizzerias. Great for travelers, as the staff are welcoming and the service is quick. The food is solid, and I can see why patrons recommend it highly. The wood-fired style adds a nice char to the crust. It's a bit off the main drag, but worth the detour. If you're exploring Seymour, this is a good stop. I appreciated the variety and the inviting setup. I'd happily come back to try more of the menu.

You might also want to check out the best pumpkin patches in Indianapolis.

Pizza Palace, Inc.

Highlights
Freshly made pies every time
Best pizza for out-of-towners
Family favorite for busy days
Worth a repeat visit always

Pizza Palace, Inc. lives up to its name with freshly made pies every time. Each visit, the crust is crisp and the toppings are generous. It's the best pizza for out-of-towners who don't know where to go—locals send them here. A family favorite for busy days, the service is efficient without feeling rushed. I've been multiple times, and the quality never dips. It's a straightforward place, no gimmicks, just good pizza. The staff remember regulars, which is a nice touch. If you're in Seymour and want a reliable, tasty pie, this is my top pick. Worth a repeat visit, always.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in Indianapolis.

Chicago's Pizza

Highlights
Friendly staff, welcoming atmosphere
Fresh salad bar, many toppings
Great value at eleven dollars
Made-to-order authentic pizza
Plenty of easy parking

Chicago's Pizza brings a friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel at home. The fresh salad bar is a nice touch, with many toppings to choose from. For the price, it's great value—their pizzas are generous, and eleven dollars gets you a solid meal. Made-to-order authentic pizza means you wait a bit, but it's worth it for the fresh ingredients. Easy parking is a big plus in this area. The crust has a nice chew, and the sauce is well-balanced. It's a neighborhood spot that does things right. I left satisfied and plan to return. If you want a personal, quality pizza experience, this is it.

You might also want to check out the best festivals in Indianapolis.

Pizza Hut

Highlights
Quick, hot, fresh food
Helpful staff solo service
Neat tablecloths add charm
Great value for families

Pizza Hut is a reliable chain, and this location delivers exactly what you expect. The food came out quick, hot, and fresh, which is all you can ask for on a busy night. Staff were helpful, especially if you're dining solo—they made sure I had everything I needed. The neat tablecloths add a touch of charm you don't usually see in a fast-casual spot. For families, the value is great, with combos that don't break the bank. It's not a gourmet experience, but it's consistent and friendly. If you need a no-nonsense pizza fix, this does the job.

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Kokomo.

Rails Craft Brew & Eatery

Highlights
Burger was good
Server attentive
Salad liked
Fries fine
Worth revisiting

Rails Craft Brew & Eatery is a solid stop if you're in the area. The burger was good—juicy, well-seasoned, and cooked properly. My server was attentive, checking in just the right amount without hovering. I also liked the salad; it was fresh and not an afterthought. The fries were fine, crispy and salted well. It's worth revisiting, especially if you're looking for a casual meal with decent service. The vibe is relaxed, fitting for a craft brew place. Nothing groundbreaking, but everything done well. I'd return to try more of their menu.

You might also want to check out the best rv parks in Indianapolis.