Kokomo's Best Pizza Places [Updated 2026]

Whether you’re a longtime local or just passing through, there’s no denying that Kokomo has some seriously mouthwatering pizza options. After indulging in countless slices and exploring 12 of the top spots, I’m ready to spill the beans on where to find the perfect pie.

Trust me—I’ve tasted everything from classic pepperoni to the most adventurous toppings you can imagine. My mission? To help you skip the mediocre and dive straight into the delicious. So grab a fork (or just your hands, because let’s be honest) and get ready to embark on a tasty journey through Kokomo’s pizza paradise!

Harvey Hinklemeyers

Highlights
Fantastic Wait Staff
To Die For Bread Sticks
Kid Friendly Atmosphere
Delicious Dessert Pies
Sock Hop Vibe

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Harvey Hinklemeyers in Kokomo, and I must say, it was a delightful culinary adventure! The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a fantastic wait staff that instantly made me feel at home. Their enthusiasm was infectious, perfectly matching the sock hop vibe of this charming eatery.

Now, let's talk about the pizza. The crust was perfectly crispy with just the right amount of chewiness. Topped with an array of fresh ingredients, each bite was a celebration of flavor—surely one of the best in town! But the showstopper had to be the to die for bread sticks that accompanied my meal; they were heavenly and practically begging to be devoured.

The restaurant boasts a kid-friendly atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for families. To wrap up our meal, I couldn’t resist indulging in their delicious dessert pies, which were the cherry on top of an already stellar dining experience. For anyone seeking the perfect slice of heaven in Kokomo, Harvey Hinklemeyers is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best pizza places in Columbus.

Gabe's Pizza

Highlights
Thin Crust Perfection
Loaded With Toppings
Friendly Staff Service
Great Family Options
Quick and Easy Ordering

Gabe's Pizza in Kokomo is a delightful gem that has quickly stolen my heart—and taste buds—as one of the premier pizza spots in town. With its thin crust perfection, every slice boasts a delightful crunch that holds up beautifully against the generous loaded toppings. Seriously, you could play a game of “count the toppings” and still lose track!

As soon as I stepped through the door, I was greeted by the friendly staff, whose enthusiasm for pizza was palpable. They guided me through the menu with genuine passion, making the ordering process both smooth and enjoyable. Not only is the service top-notch, but the restaurant also offers fantastic family options, ensuring that everyone from the pickiest eaters to adventurous foodies can find something to enjoy.

What truly impressed me was the quick and easy ordering system that conforms to my busy schedule—perfect for those last-minute cravings. Gabe’s blends quality, convenience, and a warm atmosphere, making it an ideal place to gather with friends or family. Overall, it's a must-visit for anyone in search of delicious pizza in Kokomo, where every bite certainly calls for a second slice! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best pizza places in Carmel.

LIL CHICAGO-KOKOMO

Highlights
Unmatched garlic parm wings
Juicy and tender rib tips
Welcoming and helpful service
Reasonable prices
Delicious polish sausage

If you’re on the hunt for some delectable pizza in Kokomo, look no further than Lil Chicago-Kokomo! Nestled in a cozy corner, this gem offers a charming atmosphere that instantly makes you feel right at home. As I stepped inside, I was warmly welcomed by the friendly staff, always eager to ensure your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional.

Now, let’s talk pizza! The crust? Perfectly crispy on the outside while delightfully chewy within. Topped generously with an array of fresh ingredients, each bite was a mouthwatering harmony of flavors. I also couldn’t resist indulging in their unmatched garlic parm wings, which were simply irresistible. Juicy and tender, they were a perfect companion to my pizza.

To top it off, Lil Chicago-Kokomo boasts impressive rib tips and delicious Polish sausage on the menu, making it an ideal spot for those looking for variety. All of this at reasonable prices, ensuring you won’t break the bank while treating yourself. Overall, I left feeling satisfied, content, and eager to return for another slice of Kokomo’s pizza paradise. What more could you ask for?

You might also want to check out the best hiking in Indianapolis.

Country Squire Carry Out

Highlights
Best fried chicken in town
Exceptional pork chops
Friendly and accommodating staff
Family-owned since the '90s
Delicious take-out food

Country Squire Carry Out may not be the first name that pops into your head when you think of pizza, but let me take you on a delightful detour. This family-owned establishment has been serving the community since the '90s, and their commitment to quality is palpable. While their pizza is the star of the show, I must say that the real surprise is their exceptional fried chicken!

As I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly and accommodating staff who made me feel right at home. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for grabbing a meal on the go. I ordered their classic pizza, which boasted a deliciously crisp crust and toppings that balanced flavor and freshness beautifully.

What truly sets Country Squire apart, though, is their commitment to delivering wholesome, hearty food. Their famous pork chops are, dare I say, top-notch. It's a perfect spot for anyone looking for a great meal, whether it be pizza or something else entirely. If you're in Kokomo and want a slice of pizza alongside a taste of the town, Country Squire Carry Out is definitely a crowd-pleaser!

You might also want to check out the best places to live in Indianapolis.

Filling Station of Kokomo

Highlights
Worthwhile pizza experience
Amazing atmosphere
Wonderful service
Plenty of seating
Easy parking

When I stepped into Filling Station of Kokomo, I knew I was in for a treat. The ambiance exudes a charming warmth that makes you feel right at home. As I settled in, I was immediately struck by the wonderful service; the staff was attentive, friendly, and passionate about their craft—definitely a notch above the average pizza joint.

Now, let's talk about the main event: the pizza. Each slice is a testament to the love and care that goes into their cooking. The crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy, creating an irresistible base for the thoughtfully chosen toppings. The sauce is rich and bursting with flavor, elevating the pizza experience to new heights.

With ample seating, it’s easy to gather with friends or family, and the easy parking makes visiting hassle-free. Honestly, Filling Station of Kokomo does everything right. Whether you're just in the mood for a slice or planning a feast, this place should be at the top of your list. If you're searching for a noteworthy pizza experience, Filling Station might just be the star of Kokomo's pizza scene!

You might also want to check out the best lakes in Indianapolis.

Red Dog Saloon

Highlights
Excellent Pork Tenderloins
Crispy Tater Tots
Great Onion Rings
Friendly Service
Unique Atmosphere

Red Dog Saloon is a delightful gem in Kokomo that delights both the palate and the spirits. As I stepped through the doors, I was instantly drawn in by the unique atmosphere—a warm blend of rustic charm and lively energy that promises a good time.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. It's not just any pizza; it’s a culinary masterpiece that knows how to strike the perfect balance of crispy crust and rich toppings. The first bite is an experience, with flavors dancing on the tongue. But don’t stop there—make sure to pair your pizza with their excellent pork tenderloins, which are simply a must-try.

To accompany your meal, the crispy tater tots and great onion rings add a fun and satisfying crunch that elevates the dining experience. But what truly sets Red Dog apart is their friendly service; the staff is always eager to make recommendations and brighten your day.

Red Dog Saloon is not just a place to grab a slice; it’s a destination that combines great food, lively ambiance, and exceptional service. If you're in Kokomo, don't miss out on this dynamic hub of pizza goodness!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artists in Indianapolis.

Sycamore Stump & Old Ben

Highlights
Unique world record attractions
Scenic park with diverse sights
Iconic covered bridge
Great photo opportunities

Sycamore Stump & Old Ben is not just a pizza place; it's a delightful destination nestled within the rich backdrop of Kokomo. As soon as you step in, the casual, inviting atmosphere welcomes you, making it a perfect spot to catch up with friends or enjoy a family outing. The pizza here is truly remarkable. I was drawn in by their unique toppings that you won't find everywhere, blending familiar flavors with a dash of creativity.

During my visit, I savored a slice adorned with their signature house-made sauce and a delightful blend of cheeses that melted together beautifully. Each bite created a flavorful explosion, and the crust was the perfect balance of crispy and chewy. To elevate the experience, the restaurant's proximity to serene parks and a historic covered bridge makes it a perfect place for a slice before or after a leisurely stroll.

Overall, Sycamore Stump & Old Ben blends great pizza with a charming atmosphere and scenic views that truly elevate a simple meal into an experience. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in Kokomo; it's worth every delicious bite!

You might also want to check out the best florist in Indianapolis.

Gravity Trampoline Park

Highlights
Designated toddler zone available
Engaging staff during peak times
Quick food options for kids
Community-focused entertainment
Interactive play experiences

Gravity Trampoline Park Review

As a devoted pizza explorer in Kokomo, I found a delightful surprise at Gravity Trampoline Park! While this spot isn’t solely about pizza, it cleverly pairs an exhilarating trampoline experience with some quick food options that are perfect for those energized kids – and adults! Jumping around really works up an appetite, and I loved that they offered a fun menu to refuel.

The atmosphere is vibrant and welcoming, with an engaging staff who keep the energy high, even during peak times. This community-focused facility also caters to the little ones, boasting a designated toddler zone. Parents can rest easy knowing their tiny jumpers have a safe haven while they bounce their hearts out.

I appreciated the interactive play experiences that truly make Gravity stand out. After a session of leaping around, grabbing a quick bite is easy; it's the perfect blend of adventure and nourishment! If you're in Kokomo and looking for a unique outing that combines physical fun with tasty treats, Gravity Trampoline Park is worth a visit. Just remember, even if it’s not a pizza parlor, you’ll leave with smiles and satisfied appetites!

You might also want to check out the best bed and breakfast in Indianapolis.

Heritage Lanes

Highlights
Awesome bowling vibe
Great arcade and prize section
Friendly and clean environment
Tasty pizza options
Nice staff and service

Heritage Lanes isn’t just your average bowling alley; it's a vibrant hotspot where the delightful aroma of pizza wafts through the air, luring you in. I walked in, and the atmosphere instantly enveloped me – the lively sounds of bowling balls striking pins, the playful laughter from the arcade, and a friendly host at the front was all I needed to feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza! I ordered a classic pepperoni, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crispy, yet soft enough to have that delightful chew. Each slice was generously topped with cheese and loaded with savory pepperoni. As I savored each bite, I couldn't help but appreciate how the rich flavors paired so well with the fun ambiance around me.

The staff was incredibly welcoming, ensuring my experience was enjoyable from start to finish. With a clean environment and plenty of entertaining distractions, Heritage Lanes hits that sweet spot between casual dining and exciting fun. If you’re searching for delicious pizza amidst bowling and games, this is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best pumpkin patches in Indianapolis.

Hacienda Mexican Restaurants

Highlights
Classy and awesome atmosphere
Responsible and caring management
Family-friendly dining experience
Popular choice for special occasions

Hacienda Mexican Restaurants is a delightful gem tucked away in Kokomo, well-known for its charming ambiance and inviting atmosphere. Walking in, I was immediately struck by the classy decor that seamlessly blends traditional Mexican elements with modern flair. This place is not just about food; it's about creating a memorable dining experience.

I’ve found that the management here is both responsible and caring, ensuring that every detail is attended to—from the freshness of the ingredients to the warmth of the service. Speaking of service, I observed families gathering for special occasions, reflecting the restaurant's family-friendly vibe. It's the perfect spot for a celebration or a casual dinner.

Now, I’d be a bit remiss if I didn’t mention the pizza! While Hacienda specializes in Mexican cuisine, their twist on traditional pizza is impressive, featuring vibrant toppings and bold flavors that you won’t find anywhere else. It's an unexpected delight that brings a unique flair to the pizza scene in Kokomo. If you're up for a culinary adventure where tacos and pizza meet, Hacienda is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in Indianapolis.

Chili's Grill & Bar

Highlights
Friendly and fast service
Excellent salsa and chips
Good option for lighter meals
Mixed reviews on entrees

Chili's Grill & Bar in Kokomo is a delightful spot to unwind and indulge in some tasty bites. Although it's primarily known for its Tex-Mex and American fare, I couldn't resist trying their pizza. Upon entering, the atmosphere felt vibrant and inviting, thanks in part to the friendly and fast service I encountered. It’s always a treat when the staff makes you feel right at home!

I started with their excellent salsa and chips, which were fresh and flavorful—an ideal way to kick off my meal. When the pizza arrived, I had high hopes. While it was certainly decent, it didn’t wow me as much as their other offerings. The crust was nice, and the toppings were generous, but I feel they could amp up the seasoning a bit.

One of the highlights of Chili's is the option for lighter meals, perfect if you’re looking to keep things on the healthier side. However, it’s clear that the mixed reviews on their entrees suggest that the main attraction here isn’t strictly the pizza. Overall, while Chili's has its merits, I’d recommend sampling a variety of dishes to get the full experience!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Kokomo.

Tudor Apartments

Highlights
Excellent management
Prompt maintenance
Spacious, updated interiors
Prime downtown location
Enhanced security features

While scouting for the best pizza spots in town, I stumbled upon Tudor Apartments—and let me tell you, it’s more than just a convenient place to rest your head after a pizza feast! The excellent management there really catches your eye right away. They’re friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home, much like enjoying your favorite slice with family.

The spacious, updated interiors lend a welcoming vibe, perfect for unwinding after a day of indulging in cheesy goodness. Imagine coming back from a delightful pizza outing, perhaps from a nearby gem like Pizza King, and kicking back in a cozy environment. Plus, the enhanced security features ensure you can relax without a care in the world.

Located in a prime downtown area, you're just a stone’s throw away from enticing pizzerias, where the smell of fresh dough and savory toppings wafts through the air. So, if you’re looking for a great apartment from which to explore Kokomo’s vibrant pizza scene, Tudor Apartments should definitely be on your radar! After all, what could be better than living close to some of the best pizza places in town? 🍕

You might also want to check out the best rv parks in Indianapolis.