The Absolute Best Private High Schools in Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

As I dove into the vibrant world of education in Indianapolis, I made it my mission to sift through the many options and discover what truly sets these institutions apart. I’ve reviewed 12 of the top private high schools, each with its own unique flair, commitment to excellence, and a community that can really make a difference in a student’s life.

You can trust my insights because I’ve not only visited these schools but also connected with educators, parents, and students to get the real scoop on what it’s like to learn and grow within their walls. Whether you’re a local seeking the perfect fit for your student or just curious about the landscape of education in this dynamic city, I’ve got the inside track for you!

Covenant Christian High School

Covenant Christian High School truly embodies the spirit of education infused with faith. Nestled in a vibrant campus, the school offers a supportive community where students flourish both academically and personally. The dedicated faculty are not just educators but mentors, fostering critical thinking and character development. Extracurricular programs abound, from arts to athletics, ensuring every student can find their niche. The sense of camaraderie is palpable, making it a second home for many. Covenant isn’t just about textbooks; it’s about shaping future leaders. If you’re looking for a nurturing environment that balances faith and scholarship, this school is definitely worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Indianapolis.

Roncalli High School

Roncalli High School is a vibrant community where faith and education go hand in hand. As I wandered the halls, the sense of camaraderie among students was palpable, complemented by passionate faculty who truly care. The school’s commitment to academic excellence shines through with a wide range of rigorous AP courses and exceptional extracurricular offerings. I was particularly impressed by the nurturing environment, which allows students to thrive not just academically but also personally. With a strong focus on values, Roncalli prepares its students not only for college but for life. A gem in the heart of Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best high schools in Indianapolis.

Calvary Christian School

Calvary Christian School is a delightful gem nestled in Indianapolis! With a strong emphasis on academic excellence, the school fosters a nurturing environment where students thrive both in and out of the classroom. The dedicated faculty engages with students on a personal level, promoting intellectual curiosity and spiritual growth. Extracurricular activities abound, enriching the student experience and creating a vibrant community. The beautiful campus provides plenty of space for exploration and creativity. If you're seeking a school that combines faith and learning in an inspiring setting, Calvary Christian is certainly worth considering for your child’s high school journey!

You might also want to check out the best nail salon in Fort Wayne.

Scecina Memorial High School

My visit to Scecina Memorial High School was nothing short of delightful. Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, this school boasts an inclusive community that genuinely cares for its students. The Christ-centered approach fosters both academic and personal growth, creating a nurturing environment. I was particularly impressed by their robust extracurricular programs, giving students ample opportunities to shine. The dedicated faculty, always ready to lend a helping hand, truly elevates the educational experience. With a harmonious blend of tradition and innovation, Scecina stands out as a top choice for families seeking quality education in a supportive atmosphere.

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Indianapolis.

Cardinal Ritter High School

Cardinal Ritter High School truly embraces the spirit of community and faith. From the moment I stepped through the doors, I felt the vibrant energy of students engaged in learning. The curriculum is rigorous, emphasizing academic excellence alongside character development, which is a refreshing focus. The faculty radiates passion, genuinely dedicated to their students' success. Extracurricular activities, from athletics to arts, are abundant, promoting a well-rounded experience. With its welcoming atmosphere and strong values, Cardinal Ritter is a fantastic choice for families seeking a nurturing environment that fosters both growth and achievement. A delightful gem in Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best high schools in Indiana Private.

Horizon Christian School

Horizon Christian School is a gem in the heart of Indianapolis! With a focus on faith-based education, it provides a nurturing environment where students can thrive academically and spiritually. The dedicated faculty truly invest in each student's growth, fostering a strong sense of community. I was particularly impressed by their engaging curriculum that combines rigor with creativity. The extracurricular activities are vibrant, giving students ample opportunities to shine outside the classroom. If you're looking for a school that emphasizes values and excellence, Horizon is definitely worth considering on your educational journey!

You might also want to check out the best middle schools in Indianapolis.

University High School

Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, University High School is a gem of academic excellence. With its commitment to fostering critical thinking and encouraging a love for learning, this school truly stands out. The vibrant community is both inviting and supportive, allowing students to thrive in an engaging environment. From their innovative curriculum to a wide array of extracurricular activities, there’s something for everyone. The passionate faculty members are dedicated to inspiring each student to reach their potential. If you're seeking a school that balances challenge and support, University High School is definitely worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best nail salons in Greenwood.

Eman Schools

Eman Schools truly impressed me with their dedicated approach to education and a warm sense of community. The small class sizes allow for personalized attention, fostering strong relationships between students and teachers. I was particularly struck by their commitment to integrating core values with academic rigor, creating well-rounded individuals. The variety of extracurricular activities encourages students to explore their interests outside the classroom. With its inviting atmosphere and focus on holistic development, Eman Schools stands out as a wonderful choice for families seeking a supportive and enriching environment. Definitely a contender among the best in Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best nail salons in Bloomington.

The Oaks Academy - Brookside

During my visit to The Oaks Academy - Brookside, I was immediately struck by its warm and inviting atmosphere. The school’s commitment to holistic education shines through its diverse curriculum, emphasizing both academics and character development. Engaging teachers foster a sense of curiosity and creativity in students, making learning a joyful adventure. The vibrant community encourages strong friendships and collaboration. Plus, I was impressed by their innovative approach to arts and sciences. If you’re seeking a nurturing environment that promotes growth, The Oaks Academy stands out among the best private high schools in Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best schools in Bloomington.

Bishop Chatard High School

I had the delightful opportunity to explore Bishop Chatard High School, a gem nestled in Indianapolis. The school's vibrant community radiates a sense of belonging, where every student is encouraged to shine academically and socially. I was impressed by the seamless blend of rigorous academics and heartfelt extracurricular options, from athletics to arts, fostering well-rounded individuals. The faculty, genuinely invested in student success, adds a personal touch that makes learning less daunting and more exciting. If you’re searching for a nurturing environment that balances tradition with innovation, Bishop Chatard is definitely a standout choice!

You might also want to check out the best massage in Evansville.

Cathedral High School

Cathedral High School is truly a gem in the heart of Indianapolis. With its vibrant atmosphere and a focus on academic excellence, this school inspires students to reach their full potential. The dedicated faculty fosters not just scholarly pursuits, but also a strong sense of community and service. I was especially impressed by their extensive extracurricular programs that cater to diverse interests, from arts to athletics. Walking the halls, you can feel the buzz of enthusiasm and collaboration. If you're seeking a well-rounded education wrapped in tradition and innovation, Cathedral is a top contender.

Providence Cristo Rey High School

Providence Cristo Rey High School is a delightful gem in the heart of Indianapolis! With its unique blend of academic rigor and innovative work-study program, students not only excel in the classroom but also gain real-world experience. The supportive community fosters personal growth, and the vibrant extracurriculars enhance the overall student experience. I was particularly impressed by the dedication of the faculty, who genuinely care about students' success. If you’re seeking a nurturing environment that prepares students for the future while promoting values and leadership, look no further than Providence Cristo Rey—it truly stands out among the best!