The Absolute Best Restaurants in Bluffton [Updated 2025]

Whether you're a local looking for your next favorite spot or a visitor eager to taste the heart of this charming town, I've got you covered. After diving into the culinary scene and savoring mouthwatering dishes at 12 top restaurants, I can confidently say Bluffton is a hidden gem just waiting to be discovered.

My palate has taken me from cozy diners to upscale eateries, and each bite has revealed a unique story about the people and flavors that make this place special. You can trust my insights, as I’ve wandered through the streets, chatted with passionate chefs, and soaked in the vibrant atmosphere. Get ready to find your new go-to dining destination!

Unique Blue Bar and Grill

Highlights
Excellent old fashioned
Delicious cheese curds
Non-smoking for a better experience
Great food cooked to perfection
Fun atmosphere with pool

Unique Blue Bar and Grill is a delightful gem that perfectly blends casual dining with a vibrant atmosphere. Upon arrival, I was immediately enchanted by the non-smoking environment, which created a refreshing space to enjoy my meal. As a fan of classic cocktails, I couldn't resist trying their excellent old fashioned—it was simply superb, striking just the right balance between smooth and robust.

But let's talk about the food! I started with their delicious cheese curds—a delightful appetizer that set high expectations for the meal to come. Each bite was a heavenly combination of crispy and gooey, making it nearly impossible to stop at just one. The main course was cooked to perfection, showcasing the chef's attention to detail and skill in flavor combinations.

The fun atmosphere, complete with pool tables and friendly chatter, made for an enjoyable dining experience. With every visit, Unique Blue Bar and Grill proves that you don't need fancy decor to serve fantastic food. It's the kind of place that draws you in with great tastes and keeps you coming back for more. If you’re seeking a memorable meal in Bluffton, this spot is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

The Hoosier House

Highlights
Fresh soup and salad bar
Mix of positive and negative reviews
Issues with takeout orders
A popular spot for seniors
Service quality varies

The Hoosier House in Bluffton presents a culinary experience that clearly appeals to many locals, especially the senior community. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by a friendly warm vibe, which is likely why the restaurant attracts a steady stream of patrons. One of the highlights is the fresh soup and salad bar, where I found a delightful variety of options that managed to impress on a rainy day.

However, my visit wasn’t without its bumps. While the atmosphere was charming, the service quality varied during my experience. Some waitstaff were eager and attentive, making me feel right at home, while others seemed to be caught in a whirlwind. I overheard some mixed reviews from fellow diners about the takeout orders, which showcased that consistency could be improved.

Despite these hiccups, The Hoosier House offers a comforting escape for a hearty meal, perfect for those relaxed afternoons. I left with a satisfied palate and a feeling that this restaurant has the potential for greatness. With a little fine-tuning, it could easily become a must-visit gem in Bluffton. If you’re nearby, it might just be worth the stop!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Parlor City Brewing Company

Highlights
Eclectic beer menu
Friendly and prompt service
Vintage decor and classy atmosphere
Diverse menu options
Unique pizza with peppadew

Parlor City Brewing Company is a delightful gem in Bluffton that truly captures the spirit of community and craft. Upon entering, I was greeted by a charming ambiance filled with vintage decor, which perfectly complements the classy yet relaxed atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where you can comfortably linger with friends or enjoy a cozy date night.

The eclectic beer menu is nothing short of impressive, featuring an array of local brews that cater to every palate. I couldn't resist trying their signature pizza topped with peppadew — a delicious twist that ignited my taste buds with a lovely hint of sweetness. The combination of flavors was masterfully executed, making it a standout dish.

What really sets Parlor City Brewing apart, however, is the friendly and prompt service. Staff members are eager to recommend beer pairings that elevate your meal even further. With diverse menu options ranging from hearty appetizers to mouthwatering entrees, there’s something for everyone.

Whether you’re a beer enthusiast or simply looking for a great night out, Parlor City Brewing Company is definitely worth a visit. It’s a fantastic addition to the Bluffton dining scene, and I look forward to returning for another round!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Pitties Dog House

Highlights
Chicago Dogs are exceptional
Friendly bar staff
Decent prices
Calm atmosphere
Non-smoking dining area

Upon stepping into Pitties Dog House, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of food wafting through the air, instantly setting the stage for a fabulous meal. What truly won me over, however, was their unbelievably tasty Chicago Dogs—a must-try that turned out to be nothing short of exceptional!

The ambiance was surprisingly calm for a hot spot like this, providing a delightful backdrop for enjoying great food. It’s a rarity to find a non-smoking dining area that feels inviting, and this establishment nailed it. The friendly bar staff added to the charm, offering their recommendations with a smile that made me feel right at home.

As I indulged in my delicious dog, I couldn’t help but appreciate the reasonable prices, reminding us all that quality food doesn’t have to break the bank. The whole experience was akin to a casual backyard barbecue—relaxed and fun! If you're ever in Bluffton craving a meal that combines quality and a congenial atmosphere, Pitties Dog House is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Billy Ann's Supper Pub

Billy Ann's Supper Pub is a delightful gem in Bluffton, brimming with charm and an inviting atmosphere. From the moment I stepped in, the warm, rustic decor set the perfect backdrop for an enjoyable evening. The menu offers a fantastic array of comfort food, and I couldn’t resist the mouthwatering burger topped with house-made pickle relish. Service was prompt and personable, enhancing the overall dining experience. Plus, their selection of craft beers is impressive and sure to please any enthusiast. If you're seeking a cozy spot to unwind with friends and indulge in delicious fare, Billy Ann’s is the perfect choice!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Chesterton.

Milli's Restaurant

Milli's Restaurant in Bluffton is a delightful gem that truly captures the essence of Southern hospitality. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm atmosphere and a friendly smile. The menu is a playful dance of flavors, with the shrimp and grits stealing the show—rich, creamy, and utterly satisfying. Each bite felt like a comforting hug! The attentive staff ensures that every guest feels special, adding to the charm of this establishment. If you're in Bluffton and seeking an unforgettable meal, Milli's is a must-visit for culinary bliss that will leave you craving more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Schererville.

Yergy's State Road BBQ

Yergy's State Road BBQ is an absolute gem nestled in Bluffton! From the moment I walked in, the intoxicating aroma of smoked meats had my mouth watering. I savored the pulled pork sandwich, which was tender, juicy, and bursting with flavor. The house-made BBQ sauce added a delightful kick. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly staff made me feel right at home. Don’t miss the smoked wings—they're simply addictive! If you’re searching for genuine BBQ that warms the heart, Yergy's is a must-visit. This spot is a testament to the love of smoked perfection. Finger-licking good!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Greenfield.

Indiana Pancake House

Indiana Pancake House is a delightful find in Bluffton, where breakfast dreams come true. From fluffy pancakes that practically melt in your mouth to the aromatic coffee that fuels your morning, every bite is pure bliss. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot to savor a leisurely brunch. I couldn’t resist the creative toppings on their signature pancakes, each more delightful than the last. The friendly staff adds a personal touch that makes you feel right at home. If you’re searching for a breakfast haven, Indiana Pancake House should definitely be on your radar!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fountain Square Indianapolis.

El Camino Real

Stepping into El Camino Real felt like a delightful journey south of the border! The vibrant décor sets the perfect backdrop for their tantalizing tacos and zesty enchiladas, bursting with flavor. I opted for the shrimp fajitas, served sizzling and seasoned to perfection. The attentive staff made me feel right at home, ensuring my glass was never empty. To top it off, their margaritas are an absolute must—refreshingly tangy and just the right kick. If you're craving authentic Mexican cuisine, El Camino Real is the place to be. It’s a culinary gem in Bluffton that keeps you coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Seymour.

The Corner Depot Family Dining Restaurant

Tucked away in Bluffton, The Corner Depot Family Dining Restaurant is a charming spot that feels like home. From the moment you step in, the cozy ambiance envelops you, accented by friendly faces eager to serve. The menu is a delightful medley of classic comfort foods, with standout options like their homemade meatloaf and mouthwatering pies that are simply to die for. The atmosphere is lively, making it perfect for families and friends alike. Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast or dinner, you'll leave with a satisfied palate and a smile—this gem is truly a Bluffton treasure!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Crawfordsville.

Bummie's Drive-In

At Bummie's Drive-In, nostalgia meets flavor in a delightful fusion you won't soon forget. This charming spot is a celebration of classic American fare, featuring mouthwatering burgers that sizzle with every bite. I particularly enjoyed their crispy fries, which are perfectly seasoned and downright addictive. The retro vibe, complete with friendly service, makes you feel right at home. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or indulging in a late-night snack, Bummie's delivers an experience that's both casual and comforting. If you're in Bluffton, don’t miss the chance to treat yourself to this beloved local gem!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Shelbyville.

Mariachi Loco Mexican Grill & Bar

At Mariachi Loco Mexican Grill & Bar, I was immediately captivated by the vibrant decor and the enticing aroma of sizzling fajitas. The friendly staff made me feel right at home, ensuring my dining experience was both enjoyable and memorable. I savored their signature margaritas, which were refreshingly bold, and the guacamole was nothing short of divine—fresh, creamy, and perfectly seasoned. The highlight, however, was the taco trio, bursting with flavors that danced on my palate. If you're seeking a lively atmosphere with delicious, authentic cuisine, Mariachi Loco is a definite must-visit. 🌮✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in French Lick.