The Absolute Best Restaurants in Brookville [Updated 2025]

Each bite tells a story, and in Brookville, the flavors are as rich as the town’s history. After dining at 12 of the top spots, I can confidently say that this charming little town has a culinary scene that’s bursting with personality and creativity. Whether you're craving comfort food or a gourmet experience, there’s something here to satisfy every palate.

Having spent countless hours chatting with chefs and savoring dishes, I’ve uncovered hidden gems and local favorites that truly reflect the spirit of our community. Trust me, you won’t want to miss this delicious journey through Brookville’s best eateries!

Hilltop Restaurant and Sports Dining

Highlights
Great quality bar food
Chill atmosphere
Delicious appetizer options
Local craft beer on tap
Kind and timely service

Hilltop Restaurant and Sports Dining is a true gem tucked away in Brookville, offering the perfect blend of chill atmosphere and tasty indulgences. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a friendly staff whose kindness set the tone for a delightful dining experience.

The menu boasts an array of great quality bar food, and trust me, it did not disappoint! I dove into their delicious appetizer options—the loaded nachos are an absolute must-try. Layered with gooey cheese and fresh toppings, they are perfect for sharing or simply devouring all on your own. Pair that with a local craft beer on tap, and you've got the ultimate game day experience.

The ambiance strikes a balance between vibrant and relaxed, making it an ideal hangout for friends or families alike. I found the service to be timely, ensuring that my dining experience flowed smoothly without a hitch. Overall, Hilltop is not just another sports dining location; it stands out in Brookville's diverse culinary scene. If you’re searching for a place to unwind, eat, and enjoy a game, look no further than Hilltop!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Pioneer Restaurant & Lounge

Highlights
Old country charm
Fast and friendly service
Delicious fried chicken
Full service bar
Comfortable, casual dining

The moment I stepped into Pioneer Restaurant & Lounge, I was enveloped by its delightful old country charm. The rustic decor invites you to take a seat and stay a while, a perfect setting for both casual dining and cozy gatherings. I immediately noticed the fast and friendly service that truly sets this place apart. The staff seemed genuinely eager to ensure my meal was nothing short of fantastic.

Now, let’s talk about the food! I couldn’t resist trying their famous fried chicken, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The skin was perfectly crispy while the meat beneath was juicy and flavorful. Each bite was a comforting reminder of home-cooked goodness. For those who enjoy unwinding with a drink, the full-service bar offers a variety of options to complement your meal beautifully.

If you’re looking for a comfortable atmosphere combined with a delightful menu, the Pioneer Restaurant & Lounge is a must-visit. Whether you're a local or just passing through Brookville, this gem will leave you smiling and planning your next visit.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

La Calaca Mexican Bar & Grill

Highlights
Prompt and friendly service
Delicious Happy Pollo
Spot on Enchiladas Suprema
Beautifully decorated interior
Generous portion sizes

La Calaca Mexican Bar & Grill is a delightful gem in Brookville that truly delivers on flavor and ambiance. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a beautifully decorated interior that perfectly sets the stage for a vibrant dining experience. The warm, inviting atmosphere instantly made me feel at home.

One of the highlights of my meal was the Happy Pollo, which was nothing short of a fiesta on my plate. The tender chicken, marinated to perfection, was bursting with flavor that danced on my taste buds. I couldn't resist trying the Enchiladas Suprema, which were spot on – the enchiladas were generously stuffed and smothered in a rich, savory sauce that complemented the dish brilliantly.

Throughout my visit, the prompt and friendly service made my dining experience even more enjoyable. The staff’s enthusiasm for the menu was contagious, making recommendations that did not disappoint. As for portion sizes, La Calaca definitely knows how to satisfy! I left feeling happily full, which is always a sign of a great meal.

I wholeheartedly recommend dining at La Calaca Mexican Bar & Grill. It’s a delightful spot that captures the spirit of Mexico with every bite!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Third Place

Highlights
Friendly service
Cold beer
Country-style ambiance
Good music
Appealing food options

Third Place is a delightful gem in Brookville that really captures the essence of community, and I must say, it was a treat to discover. From the moment I walked in, the friendly service had me feeling right at home, as though I had just stepped into my favorite neighbor’s dining room.

The country-style ambiance is so inviting, with rustic decor that perfectly complements the lively chatter of patrons enjoying their meals and the good music playing softly in the background. It sets the stage for a relaxed yet vibrant atmosphere.

Now, let’s talk about the food. The appealing food options are sure to pique your palate; I savored every bite! And for those looking to unwind, the cold beer selection is nothing short of impressive, with local brews that perfectly pair with your meal.

Overall, my visit to Third Place was a delightful experience that left me eager to return. If you find yourself in Brookville craving good vibes and even better food, make sure to check this spot out; it’s a must-visit for anyone seeking a taste of local charm!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Ainsley’s Cafe

Ainsley’s Cafe is a delightful gem in Brookville that instantly feels like home! From the moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly brewed coffee and baked goods enveloped me in a warm embrace. Their hearty breakfast options are a must-try—especially the fluffy pancakes drizzled with real maple syrup. The relaxed atmosphere invites you to linger, and the friendly staff truly make you feel welcomed. Don’t skip their signature lattes, which are elegantly crafted and visually stunning! If you’re seeking a cozy spot with delicious food, Ainsley’s Cafe is a perfect choice for a cheerful meal that will leave you smiling.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Chesterton.

The Blue Umbrella Bistro & Bakery

Stepping into The Blue Umbrella Bistro & Bakery feels like entering a whimsical, culinary wonderland. The aroma of freshly baked pastries dances in the air, instantly beckoning you to indulge. I savored their signature quiche, which was a delightful harmony of flavors, perfectly paired with a side salad that burst with freshness.

The cozy atmosphere is complemented by charming decor, making it an ideal spot for a leisurely brunch or a quick coffee break. Don’t skip the dessert—each pastry is a little work of art! For a delightful experience, this bistro is a must-visit in Brookville.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Schererville.

El Reparo

El Reparo in Brookville is a hidden gem that bursts with authentic flavors and vibrant atmosphere. As I stepped inside, the cheerful decor and the tantalizing aroma of spices welcomed me warmly. I indulged in their mole enchiladas, which were a delightful symphony of rich flavors. The staff, with their friendly smiles, made me feel like part of the family. Don’t skip the homemade salsa—it’s the perfect kick to elevate your meal. Whether you crave a hearty feast or a casual bite, El Reparo is a must-visit spot that brilliantly showcases the spirit of Mexican cuisine.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Greenfield.

Nixie's Burgers

Stepping into Nixie's Burgers felt like a delightful trip to burger paradise! The aroma of grilled patties filled the air as I scanned the funky, retro decor. I opted for the classic cheeseburger, and oh, it was a masterpiece — juicy, with a perfectly melted cheese blanket and fresh toppings that danced in flavor. The fries? Crisp and golden, served with a side of zesty dipping sauce that kept me reaching for more. Friendly staff added to the inviting vibe. If you’re in Brookville and craving a burger that’s both delicious and fun, Nixie’s is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fountain Square Indianapolis.

Hav-A-Bite Restaurant

From the moment I stepped into Hav-A-Bite Restaurant, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere that felt like home. The menu is a delightful blend of comfort food and creative twists, with their signature burgers stealing the spotlight. Each bite was a savory explosion of flavors! The staff was equally charming, offering attentive service with a smile. Don't miss their handcrafted milkshakes—they're a perfect indulgence. If you're looking for a relaxed spot to enjoy hearty food with a dash of whimsy, Hav-A-Bite truly delivers. It's a dining experience that leaves you craving more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Seymour.

The Martindale House

Nestled in the heart of Brookville, The Martindale House is a delightful gem that combines rustic charm with exceptional culinary flair. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by warm smiles and an inviting atmosphere that set the stage for a memorable meal. The seasonal menu showcases locally sourced ingredients, and each dish is a masterpiece bursting with flavor. I savored the signature mushroom risotto—creamy, rich, and utterly decadent. The attentive staff ensured my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional. If you’re searching for an unforgettable meal, this charming spot is a must-visit! 🍴✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Crawfordsville.

Pizza Pete

Pizza Pete dazzles with its laid-back vibe and mouthwatering pies that dance on your taste buds! Upon stepping in, the inviting aroma of fresh dough and zesty tomato sauce sets the stage for a delightful meal. I indulged in their signature Pete’s Special, a symphony of toppings that perfectly balanced flavors. The crust was brilliantly crispy, offering a satisfying crunch with each bite. Friendly staff and a cozy atmosphere make it the perfect spot for families or a casual night out. In a world full of options, Pizza Pete is a must-visit—where pizza dreams come true!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Shelbyville.

Dairy Cottage

Dairy Cottage is a delightful gem nestled in Brookville, where nostalgia meets flavor in every scoop. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by the sweet scent of homemade waffle cones that instantly transported me back to childhood. Their ice cream is nothing short of a culinary delight, with a rich, creamy texture and a variety of flavors that cater to every palate. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff add to the charm, making it the perfect spot for families or anyone with a sweet tooth. For a delicious escape, Dairy Cottage is truly a must-visit destination!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in French Lick.