Monticello's Best Restaurants [Updated 2025]

Whether you're a lifelong resident or just passing through, Monticello has a culinary scene that’s bursting with flavor and charm. After indulging my taste buds at 12 of the top restaurants, I’ve uncovered hidden gems and local favorites that truly represent the heart of our town.

You can trust my insights because I’ve savored every bite and soaked up the unique atmospheres that each place has to offer. From cozy diners to upscale eateries, there's something for everyone here. So grab your fork and let’s dive into the deliciousness that Monticello has to offer—your next favorite meal is just around the corner!

Riverside Restaurant & Lounge

Highlights
Excellent ribeye and seafood
Inviting atmosphere for adults only
Attentive and friendly service
Beautifully presented dishes
Worthwhile dining experience

Riverside Restaurant & Lounge truly captures the essence of sophisticated dining with a touch of local charm. As I stepped inside, I was immediately enveloped by an inviting atmosphere—perfect for enjoying an adults-only evening. The decor strikes a delightful balance between modern and cozy, making you feel right at home while you savor your meal.

I decided to indulge in their renowned ribeye and a selection of fresh seafood. Let me tell you, each dish was beautifully plated and bursting with flavor! The ribeye, perfectly cooked to my preference, was tender and juicy, while the seafood featured a delightful medley that transported my taste buds to coastal bliss.

In addition to the gourmet food, I was genuinely impressed with the attentive and friendly service. The staff seemed genuinely invested in ensuring my experience was top-notch, which made the evening even more enjoyable.

Overall, my time at Riverside was a truly worthwhile dining experience. If you find yourself in Monticello, I highly recommend visiting this gem. Your palate will thank you! ✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Arni's Monticello

Highlights
Delicious ground meat pizzas
Plentiful shareable salads
Casual dining atmosphere
Inconsistent service quality
Mixed food temperature

When I stepped into Arni's Monticello, I was immediately enveloped in a warm and casual dining atmosphere that felt welcoming. The star of the show? The delicious ground meat pizzas that grace their menu! Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavor, with a perfectly crispy crust that even the pickiest pizza lover would appreciate.

To complement my slice of heaven, I couldn't resist trying their plentiful shareable salads. The freshness of the ingredients blended harmoniously, making for a vibrant addition to my meal.

However, I must note that my experience was a bit of a rollercoaster. The service quality was somewhat inconsistent, fluctuating from attentive to a tad absent. This hiccup was a minor blot on an otherwise lovely experience. Additionally, a few items on my plate arrived at varying temperatures, although I was too busy savoring the flavors to let that bother me much.

Overall, Arni's Monticello is well worth a visit if you’re in the area. The delicious pizzas and healthy salads create a perfect pairing for a laid-back meal with friends or family. Don’t miss this delightful gem!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

The Oakdale Bar & Grill

Highlights
Great cheese curds
Exceptional service
Trip hazards during remodeling
Issues with food quality
Bottomless napkins

The Oakdale Bar & Grill in Monticello is a place that captures the essence of casual dining with a twist of delightful surprises. Upon entering, I was greeted with a warm atmosphere that instantly felt inviting. The exceptional service truly stood out; the staff was not only attentive but also knowledgeable about the menu. I could hardly resist ordering the great cheese curds, which turned out to be the highlight of my meal—crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside, they were a cheesy dream!

However, not all was perfect during my visit. I had to be cautious of some trip hazards due to ongoing remodeling, but it was clear that improvements were being made. The food quality, while generally good, had its off moments. Some dishes didn't quite hit the mark as expected.

Despite these minor setbacks, their bottomless napkins were a quirky touch that kept the meal from becoming too messy! Overall, The Oakdale Bar & Grill is a place where fun and flavor intersect, making it a worthy stop for anyone craving a lively dining experience in Monticello. Don't miss out on their cheese curds—they’re absolutely unforgettable!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

King Buffet

Highlights
Great Asian cuisine
All-you-can-eat option
Rude customer service
Inconsistent food quality
High prices for quality

King Buffet in Monticello is a symphony of flavors that invites you to indulge in an expansive selection of Asian cuisine. As a self-proclaimed buffet connoisseur, I felt right at home amidst the tempting layouts of sushi, stir-fries, and delectable desserts. The all-you-can-eat option was the crown jewel of my visit, offering endless possibilities to satisfy my cravings.

However, let’s not sugarcoat everything. The customer service left me slightly bemused. While the staff hustled to replenish the food, their demeanor danced on the edge of rudeness—definitely not the warm welcome I'd expected. On a brighter note, the food was a delightful mix, though its quality seemed inconsistent at times. Certain dishes sparked joy, while others felt like a lukewarm embrace.

Another point to consider is the pricing. In an era where value reigns supreme, I found myself wondering if the high prices matched the overall quality of the experience. Despite these quirks, King Buffet manages to provide a culinary adventure that keeps patrons returning for more. It’s a delightful spot for those willing to overlook a few bumps in service for an expansive buffet experience!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Oak & Barrel

During my delightful visit to Oak & Barrel, I was greeted by a warm atmosphere that perfectly complements their eclectic menu. The standout dish for me was the smoked brisket—each bite was a heavenly combination of tender meat and rich flavors. The craft beer selection tickles the palate, making it a perfect pairing. I adored the rustic decor; every detail adds to the charm of this spot. Don't miss their house-made desserts, which are a sweet way to conclude your meal. If you’re seeking a memorable dining experience in Monticello, Oak & Barrel is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Chesterton.

Whiskey & Wine Saloon

Nestled in the heart of Monticello, Whiskey & Wine Saloon is a delightful fusion of rustic charm and modern flair. The moment you step inside, the warm ambiance invites you to unwind. I was particularly impressed by their extensive whiskey selection—every sip felt like an exciting journey! The seasonal dishes on the menu are crafted with local ingredients, showcasing a blend of flavors that dance on your palate. Don't miss the signature cocktails either; they’re a playful twist on classic favorites. Whether you're in for a late-night gathering or a cozy dinner, this spot is a must-visit in Monticello!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Schererville.

USA Restaurant

From the moment I stepped into USA Restaurant, the warm and inviting atmosphere made me feel right at home. The menu boasts a delightful array of classic American dishes, each prepared with a distinctive twist. I savored the juicy homemade burger that practically melted in my mouth, paired with perfectly crispy fries. The staff was not only attentive but also exuded a genuine passion for their craft, elevating the entire dining experience. Whether you're in the mood for comfort food or a hearty breakfast, USA Restaurant is a delightful spot that captures the heart of Monticello’s culinary scene!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Greenfield.

Sportsman Inn

Tucked away in the heart of Monticello, Sportsman Inn is a delightful find for casual dining enthusiasts. From the moment I stepped in, the vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff set the tone for a great meal. I was particularly impressed by their signature burgers—juicy, flavorful, and crafted with care. The eclectic menu offers something for everyone, and the daily specials are worth a taste! Don't overlook their house-made fries; they’re the perfect accompaniment. Whether you're catching a game or just soaking in the local charm, Sportsman Inn delivers a memorable experience that keeps you coming back for more. 🍔🏈

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fountain Square Indianapolis.

Harvest Time Family Restaurant

Nestled in the heart of Monticello, Harvest Time Family Restaurant feels like a warm hug from grandma. The moment you step inside, the aroma of homemade comfort food wraps around you like a cozy blanket. I indulged in their famous meatloaf, which was rich and flavorful, complemented by creamy mashed potatoes that can only be described as a taste of heaven. The friendly staff adds to the charm, making you feel like a cherished guest. This gem is perfect for families and anyone craving a delightful meal with a personal touch. Don't miss out on the homemade pies—they're the cherry on top!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Seymour.

Le Petit Cafe Monticello

Le Petit Cafe Monticello is a delightful gem that transports you straight to a charming French bistro. As I stepped inside, I was greeted with a warm ambiance and aromatic scents wafting from the kitchen. The croissants were flaky perfection, while the quiche Lorraine was a rich, savory delight that danced on my palate. Their coffee is a must-try, strong yet smooth, making it the perfect companion to any dish. The service was friendly and attentive, adding to the overall experience. If you’re seeking a cozy spot to indulge in delectable bites, Le Petit Cafe will surely not disappoint!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Crawfordsville.

Esmeralda's Pancake House

Stepping into Esmeralda's Pancake House feels like a warm embrace from a cozy diner! The airy atmosphere and cheerful staff set the tone for a delightful dining experience. I indulged in their signature pancakes, which were light and fluffy, perfectly complemented by a drizzle of maple syrup. The unique toppings, from fresh berries to whipped cream, were a joyous explosion of flavor! The coffee was robust and paired beautifully with my breakfast feast. If you're seeking a charming spot to start your day, look no further—Esmeralda's is a true gem in Monticello that will leave you smiling!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Shelbyville.

Mt.Fuji Sushi & Hibachi

My recent visit to Mt. Fuji Sushi & Hibachi was a delightful culinary journey! Nestled in Monticello, this gem combines the artistry of sushi with the excitement of hibachi grilling. The sushi rolls burst with freshness, and I particularly loved the creative combinations that tantalized my taste buds. The hibachi show—an engaging performance by the skilled chefs—added an element of fun to the evening. The ambiance strikes a balance between lively and relaxing, making it perfect for both family dinners and date nights. If you're seeking an unforgettable dining experience, Mt. Fuji is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in French Lick.