Pendleton's Best Restaurants [Updated 2025]

With a decade of indulging in Pendleton’s culinary scene under my belt, I’ve savored everything from cozy diners to upscale bistros. I’ve reviewed 12 top locations that not only showcase the town’s unique flavors but also capture the warmth of our community.

You can trust my expertise because I’ve explored every nook and cranny, delighting in hidden gems and beloved local hangouts alike. Whether you’re a local looking to rediscover your favorites or a visitor eager to taste the best of Pendleton, I promise you’ll find something that tickles your taste buds and makes your dining experience unforgettable!

Catello’s Italian Art Cuisine

Highlights
Cozy atmosphere
Delicious gorgonzola risotto
Excellent service
Great value for quality
Live piano music

Catello’s Italian Art Cuisine is an absolute gem in Pendleton that embodies the spirit of Italian hospitality with a cozy atmosphere that invites you to relax and indulge. Upon entering, I was greeted by the delightful sounds of live piano music, setting the perfect backdrop for a romantic dinner or a special night out with friends.

The menu is a treasure trove of traditional Italian dishes, and I couldn't resist the gorgonzola risotto. This dish was a revelation—each bite creamy and rich, perfectly balanced with just the right kick from the cheese. It was, without a doubt, the highlight of my meal and worth every penny.

What truly made my experience at Catello's exceptional was the excellent service. The staff members were gracious and attentive, ensuring I felt valued throughout the evening. Moreover, with the quality of food, the prices were surprisingly reasonable, allowing me to savor exquisite flavors without breaking the bank.

In summary, if you find yourself in Pendleton, Catello’s is a must-visit for an unforgettable culinary experience where great food and warm ambiance come together beautifully. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Invited To The Table

Highlights
Creative and delicious lattes
Homey and quaint atmosphere
Fast service with no wait issues
Plenty of seating options
Great for coffee dates

Invited To The Table Review

Nestled in the heart of Pendleton, Invited To The Table is a hidden gem that beckons coffee lovers and foodies alike. As soon as I stepped inside, the homey and quaint atmosphere enveloped me, making it the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy a bite. I was immediately drawn to their creative and delicious lattes, which promised an adventure for the taste buds. Let me tell you, they did not disappoint! Each sip was a symphony of flavors that brightened my day.

What truly stood out was the fast service—there were no wait issues here! The efficient staff ensured that my experience was seamless, giving me more time to indulge in delightful conversations. Plus, the plenty of seating options made it an excellent choice for coffee dates or catching up with friends.

Overall, my visit to Invited To The Table was a delightful affair. With its charming ambiance, remarkable coffee, and swift service, this café has earned its place as one of Pendleton's best dining spots. Don't miss the opportunity to be whisked away by its charm and flavor—you'll thank yourself for it!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

INItaly Pizzeria&Bar

Highlights
Authentic Italian pizza
Inviting and warm ambiance
Outstanding and friendly service
Fresh, high-quality ingredients
Creative twist on classics

I recently had the pleasure of dining at INItaly Pizzeria&Bar in Pendleton, and let me tell you, this place is a slice of heaven! The moment you walk in, you're greeted by a warm and inviting ambiance that instantly puts you at ease. It's the perfect spot for a casual night out or a special occasion.

But let’s get to the main event—the pizza! They offer an array of authentic Italian pizzas that are not only delicious but also crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. I savored the margherita pizza, which was a delightful dance of flavors, combining fresh basil and mozzarella atop a perfectly baked crust.

What truly sets INItaly apart is their creative twist on classics. They have various inventive options you won't find in your typical pizzeria. And the service? Absolutely outstanding and friendly. The staff treated me like family, ready to recommend pairing suggestions that perfectly matched my meal.

If you’re in Pendleton and looking for an exceptional dining experience that celebrates Italian cuisine, don’t pass up the chance to visit INItaly! It’s truly one of the best restaurants in town!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale

Highlights
Amazing food quality
Generous portion sizes
Exceptional service by Ben
Best bread and goat cheese dip
Cozy indoor heated patio

From the moment I stepped into FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale, I knew I was in for a treat. The cozy ambiance set the stage for a delightful evening, and the atmosphere made you feel right at home. I was eagerly greeted by Ben, whose exceptional service turned the evening into a special occasion. He had a genuine enthusiasm for the menu and expertly guided me through my choices.

And oh, the food! I started my meal with the best bread and goat cheese dip I’ve ever tasted—rich, creamy, and utterly addictive. It was the perfect start, but the real star of the show was the generous portion sizes that filled my plate. Whether you’re craving a delectable burger or a tantalizing seasonal dish, you won’t leave hungry.

Coupled with an impressive selection of beers, FoxGardin creates a harmonious dining experience that's hard to beat in Pendleton. From the friendly vibes to the mouthwatering dishes, I can confidently say this is a gem worth discovering. If you’re in the area, don’t miss out on this culinary gem—it will have you coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Taxman Fortville

Highlights
Amazing service
Upscale pub food
Delicious meatball sub
Great atmosphere
Tasty bacon smash

Taxman Fortville in Pendleton truly left a delightful mark on my culinary journey. From the moment I walked in, the great atmosphere enveloped me like a warm hug. The venue strikes that perfect balance between upscale and inviting, making it an excellent spot for both casual outings and special occasions.

Now, let’s talk about the amazing service I received. The staff were not only attentive but genuinely enthusiastic about the menu, ready to recommend their favorites. I couldn’t resist trying their standout feature: the delicious meatball sub. This delightful creation was bursting with flavor—each bite was an explosion of savory goodness that left me longing for more.

Oh, and I have to mention the tasty bacon smash! It was the ideal complement to my meal, showcasing their ability to elevate classic dishes with a gourmet twist. If you're seeking an elevated twist on pub favorites, Taxman Fortville is the place to be. With an inviting atmosphere and a focus on quality, I can confidently say it’s one of Pendleton's must-visit gems. Don’t miss out on this delightful experience!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Chesterton.

1925 PubHouse Grandview

Highlights
Attentive and friendly service
Delicious pork and steak meals
Great patio seating option
Informal yet welcoming atmosphere
Tasty Mexican street corn

At 1925 PubHouse Grandview, I was instantly charmed by the informal yet welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. The friendly staff go above and beyond, delivering service that feels genuinely attentive without being overbearing. As I settled in, I couldn’t resist the delightful Mexican street corn as an appetizer. It's a vibrant dish that dances on your palate—a true indication that this place knows its flavors!

For the main event, I opted for their famed pork dish, which was cooked to perfection. The rich flavors melded beautifully, reminding me of why I'm a fan of well-prepared steak and pork meals. If you’re a meat lover, this is definitely a slice of heaven.

What really makes 1925 stand out is the option for patio seating; it’s a lovely choice on a sunny day, allowing you to enjoy delicious food while soaking in the local scenery. If you’re looking for a blend of taste and comfort, you’ll find it in this gem of Pendleton. This place has a way of making dining feel like a celebration—each bite is a reason to smile!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Schererville.

Salt at Geist

Highlights
Creative and flavorful menu options
Attentive and knowledgeable service
Modern and sleek atmosphere
Beautiful outdoor seating area
Excellent for special occasions

My visit to Salt at Geist in Pendleton was nothing short of a delightful culinary adventure. Upon entering, I was immediately captivated by the modern and sleek atmosphere that sets the perfect backdrop for any meal. The outdoor seating area is particularly enchanting, making it an ideal spot for enjoying a fresh breeze.

The menu is a testament to creativity, featuring flavorful and unique options that cater to a variety of tastes. I couldn't resist the temptation of trying their signature dishes, and I must say, each bite was a delightful surprise! The balance of flavors showcased the chef's talent perfectly.

Adding to my overall enjoyment was the attentive and knowledgeable service I received. The staff was eager to share insights about the menu items, enhancing my dining experience. It's always refreshing to see a team that genuinely enjoys what they do.

Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a fantastic meal, Salt at Geist is undoubtedly one of Pendleton's best options. I left feeling satisfied and eager to return for another round of their delightful dishes!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Greenfield.

Wolfies Grill — Pendleton

Tucked away in Pendleton, Wolfies Grill is an absolute gem! The moment I stepped inside, the lively atmosphere and friendly staff welcomed me like an old friend. I savored their signature burger, which was juicy and bursting with flavor. The creative appetizers, especially the loaded nachos, were a perfect start to my meal. Don't forget to try their craft beer selection, which pairs beautifully with the food. Plus, the outdoor seating is a delightful spot to soak up the sun. If you're hunting for a casual yet vibrant dining experience, Wolfies Grill is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fountain Square Indianapolis.

Taylor's Bar & Table

At Taylor's Bar & Table, the atmosphere is as vibrant as the flavors! This charming spot combines rustic elegance with a friendly vibe, making it a perfect retreat. I was immediately drawn in by their creative cocktails—each sip was a delightful adventure. The menu features a mix of hearty American classics and unique twists that tantalize the taste buds. Don't miss the seasonal specials, which showcase local ingredients! The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, always ready to recommend their favorites. Whether you're in for a casual night out or a special occasion, Taylor's never disappoints. Highly recommended!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Seymour.

The Crossings Restaurant

Stepping into The Crossings Restaurant feels like embracing a warm hug from a dear friend. The ambiance strikes the perfect balance between cozy and chic, making it an ideal spot for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings. I savored their renowned grilled salmon, which was perfectly cooked and artfully plated. The seasonal vegetables danced on the palate, adding a delightful crunch. Don’t skip the desserts; the chocolate lava cake is a sweet symphony! With attentive staff and a menu that celebrates local flavors, The Crossings truly captures the essence of Pendleton dining. It's a must-visit gem!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Crawfordsville.

The Stable

Nestled in the heart of Pendleton, The Stable is a culinary gem that brings rustic charm and mouthwatering dishes together under one roof. As I entered, the warm ambiance welcomed me like an old friend. The menu showcases locally sourced ingredients, showcasing dishes that are as flavorful as they are beautifully presented. I highly recommend the braised short ribs—tender and rich, it’s a delightful adventure for the taste buds. The attentive staff added to the experience, making me feel right at home. If you're seeking a blend of comfort and exquisite dining, The Stable is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Shelbyville.

Bourbon on the Falls

Bourbon on the Falls is a delightful culinary gem nestled in Pendleton. The moment I stepped inside, the warm ambiance wrapped around me like a cozy blanket. Their signature cocktails set the stage for a wonderful meal, while the menu offers an enticing mix of classic and innovative dishes. I particularly enjoyed the bourbon-glazed ribs — they were sticky, sweet, and utterly satisfying! The staff exude a genuine passion for hospitality, enhancing the entire dining experience. If you're on the hunt for a place that beautifully balances flavor and atmosphere, look no further than this charming spot!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in French Lick.