The Absolute Best Desserts in Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

As I dove into the sweet, sugary labyrinth of Indianapolis, I made it my mission to uncover the city’s most decadent treats. After countless taste tests and sugar-fueled adventures, I’ve gathered my top 12 dessert destinations that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.

You can trust my palate; I’ve savored everything from artisanal pastries to mouthwatering cakes, all while navigating the vibrant flavors our city has to offer. Whether you’re a lifelong resident or just passing through, prepare to indulge in some of the most delightful desserts that will leave you dreaming of your next bite!

LiftOff Creamery

Highlights
Rich, flavorful ice cream
Variety of ice cream options
Cute neighborhood spot
Decent topping selection
Average experience overall

LiftOff Creamery is a delightful gem nestled in a charming neighborhood, and during my visit, I was eager to take off on a flavor adventure. The rich, flavorful ice cream they serve is nothing short of a delight; you can taste the passion infused in each scoop. With a variety of ice cream options that cater to both traditional and adventurous palates, there’s something for everyone—whether you're a chocolate lover or someone who craves fruity delights.

The charming décor and friendly atmosphere make it an inviting stop, perfect for families or anyone looking to satisfy their sweet tooth. I appreciated the decent topping selection that allowed for customization, enhancing the overall experience. However, while the ice cream was undeniably delicious, I would say the overall experience felt slightly average—perhaps it’s the ambiance or the speed of service.

I left LiftOff Creamery with a satisfied smile, thrilled to add one of Indianapolis' best dessert spots to my list. If you find yourself in the area, I highly recommend taking a moment to indulge; your taste buds will thank you later!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Leviathan Bakehouse

Highlights
Always busy with sold-out pastries
Incredible biscuits and gravy
Best Pain Au Chocolat in town
Flakey and decadent layers
Perfect brunch spot indoors/outdoors

When I strolled into Leviathan Bakehouse, the buzz of excitement was palpable—a sure sign of a beloved local spot. Everywhere I looked, I saw pastries that were nearly sold out, which only heightened my anticipation. I was particularly thrilled to try their renowned Pain Au Chocolat, which locals claim is the best in town, and they weren't exaggerating! Each bite was a delightful exploration of flakiness and rich chocolate that left me yearning for more.

Aside from the indulgent pastries, I was pleasantly surprised by their savory offerings. The biscuits and gravy—oh, where do I even begin? They managed to strike a perfect balance between comfort and sophistication, making it an exquisite brunch option.

Whether enjoying a leisurely day indoors or soaking in the sun outdoors, Leviathan Bakehouse proves to be the ideal setting for a sweet escape. The layers of flavor and textures showcased in their desserts reflect a genuine passion for baking. If you're seeking a place that beautifully marries tradition with inventive flair, look no further. This bakery is an absolute must-visit on your dessert adventures in Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

BRICS

Highlights
Neat ice cream shop
Large outdoor seating area
Good flavor selection
Fast and friendly service
Great atmosphere

BRICS: A Sweet Escape in Indianapolis

Nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, BRICS is an ice cream lover's paradise that seamlessly blends a fun atmosphere with delectable treats. Walking into this neat little shop, I was welcomed by the vibrant colors and the tantalizing scent of freshly made waffle cones. With a large outdoor seating area, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy your dessert on a sunny day.

What truly impressed me was the bountiful selection of flavors. Whether you're craving classic vanilla or something a bit more adventurous, there’s a scoop to satisfy every palate. The staff was not only fast but also incredibly friendly, making the entire experience feel inviting and warm.

As I savored my scoop, I noticed the delightful camaraderie between patrons—there's something about ice cream that brings people together! So, if you’re looking for a fantastic way to sweeten your day, I wholeheartedly recommend visiting BRICS. With a mix of enticing flavors and a welcoming vibe, it's a standout in the Indianapolis dessert scene. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Dolce Vita

Highlights
Baklava pistachio crepe
Freshly prepared desserts
Friendly and polite staff
Beautifully presented items

Dolce Vita Review

Stepping into Dolce Vita felt like entering a sweet paradise, each corner whispering promises of delightful desserts. With their freshly prepared treats, I was immediately drawn to the baklava pistachio crepe—a harmonious blend of flaky layers and nutty goodness that danced on my palate.

The crepe was beautifully presented, drizzled with the perfect amount of syrup, making it not just a feast for my taste buds but also for the eyes. As I took my first bite, I was amazed at how the rich, textured flavors melded together, leaving a lingering sweetness that was nothing short of enchanting.

What truly stood out, though, was the atmosphere. The friendly and polite staff treated each customer like family, enhancing the overall experience with their warm smiles and enthusiastic recommendations.

If you’re on the hunt for the best desserts in Indianapolis, Dolce Vita surely has something to satisfy every sweet tooth. Between the exquisite flavors and welcoming vibe, this gem is a slice of heaven in our bustling city. Don’t miss the chance to indulge—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Circle City Sweets

Highlights
Amazing Hummingbird Cake
Consistently Delicious Sweets
Must-Try Almond Croissant
Great Bakery Experience
Unique Flavor Every Bite

Circle City Sweets is a true gem nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, and let me tell you, their offerings are nothing short of delightful! I wandered in, excited to try the famed Hummingbird Cake, and it did not disappoint—each bite is a perfect harmony of flavors, blending banana, pineapple, and pecans in a way that feels both nostalgic and innovative.

But that’s just the tip of the sugary iceberg! The almond croissant is a must-try; its flaky pastry offers a delightful crunch—a perfect contrast to the sumptuous almond filling that practically sings with flavor. And every other sweet I sampled was consistently delicious, showcasing the bakery's dedication to quality and creativity.

The atmosphere at Circle City Sweets enhances the experience, making it more than just a stop to satisfy a sweet tooth—it’s a wonderful bakery adventure. I left with a smile on my face and the warm taste of indulgence lingering on my palate. If you’re seeking a memorable dessert experience in Indy, look no further! Make Circle City Sweets your next destination for an explosion of flavors in every tier of delight!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Sweet Escape Cake Company

Highlights
Intricate and detailed designs
Custom flavors available
Excellent customer service
Beautiful cake presentations
Perfect for special occasions

Sweet Escape Cake Company is an absolute gem in the heart of Indianapolis, a place where cake dreams come true! As I stepped inside, I was immediately captivated by the intricate and detailed designs of the cakes on display. Each was a stunning work of art that tempts the senses.

What truly sets them apart is their commitment to offering custom flavors. I opted for the lavender lemon cake—a bold yet refreshing choice that perfectly danced on my palate. With every bite, I savored the seamless balance of sweetness and zest.

To add to the sweetness of the experience, the staff provided excellent customer service, guiding me through the various options with genuine enthusiasm. They clearly take pride in their creations, and it shows!

Whether you’re planning a grand celebration or simply indulging in a personal treat, Sweet Escape’s beautiful cake presentations make every dessert an occasion. I left feeling overjoyed, and I can't recommend this charming bakery enough. If you find yourself in Indianapolis, be sure to pay them a visit and treat yourself to their delightful offerings—it’s the perfect escape for anyone with a sweet tooth!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Lick Ice Cream Indy

Highlights
Unique and creative flavors
Patient and friendly staff
Creamy, subdued flavor profiles
Must-try seasonal flavors
Located at Indianapolis Garage Food Hall

Lick Ice Cream Indy has quickly become one of my absolute favorite spots for a sweet escape. Located in the vibrant Indianapolis Garage Food Hall, this ice cream shop offers a delightful array of unique and creative flavors that will delight anyone seeking to indulge their taste buds. As I approached the counter, the patient and friendly staff greeted me with genuine enthusiasm, making the whole experience feel like a playful adventure.

I couldn't resist sampling their must-try seasonal flavors, which showcased the inventive spirit of the team. Each scoop was incredibly creamy, boasting subdued flavor profiles that managed to be both refreshing and rich at the same time. They perfectly balance sweetness with a touch of intrigue—just the right amount to keep you coming back for more.

From classic favorites to bold combinations, Lick Ice Cream Indy invites you to explore the delicious possibilities with every visit. If you're in Indianapolis and looking for something to satisfy your sweet tooth, I wholeheartedly recommend stopping by Lick. You might just stumble upon your new favorite flavor, and trust me, one scoop won’t be enough!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Artisan Bakery and Pastries

Stepping into Artisan Bakery and Pastries is like entering a haven for dessert lovers! The scent of freshly baked goods envelops you, igniting a delightful anticipation. I indulged in their signature flaky croissants—golden, buttery layers that practically melt in your mouth. What truly stole the show, however, was the chocolate tart, with its rich, velvety ganache and a hint of sea salt that danced on my palate. Each bite was a blissful revelation! The ambiance is cozy, making it the perfect spot for a sweet escape. Artisan is undoubtedly a must-visit for anyone craving indulgence in Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Cookie Plug

My recent visit to Cookie Plug in Indianapolis was a delightful journey into the world of decadent sweets. This whimsical spot offers a mouthwatering selection of oversized cookies, each more inviting than the last. I indulged in their signature “Cookie Monster,” a heavenly blend of blue cookie dough and classic chocolate chips. The texture was perfectly chewy, while the flavors danced on my palate like a sweet symphony! The vibrant decor and welcoming ambiance made my experience even more enjoyable. If you're a dessert lover, Cookie Plug is an absolute must-visit for an unforgettable treat! 🍪✨

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Long's Bakery

Long's Bakery is a delightful gem that has stolen my heart (and taste buds)! Their iconic glazed donuts are simply a must-try—each bite is a cloud of sweetness, perfectly airy and oh-so-satisfying. I couldn't resist the cream-filled delights either; they’re decadently rich without overwhelming the palate. The nostalgic atmosphere welcomes you in, making it a perfect spot for indulging your sweet tooth. The staff is friendly, adding a sprinkle of warmth to the overall experience. If you’re in Indianapolis, treat yourself to Long’s—it’s a sweet stop that captures the essence of local charm and deliciousness! 🍩✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Boyden's Southside Bakery

Stepping into Boyden's Southside Bakery is like entering a warm embrace of nostalgia! Their red velvet cupcakes are an absolute dream—moist, fluffy, and topped with a generous swirl of cream cheese frosting that is simply divine. Don't miss the buttercream-topped cookies, which are so colorful and indulgent; they practically sing with flavor. The charming atmosphere and friendly staff make each visit feel special, ensuring you leave with a smile and a sugary treat in hand. If you're on a quest for delightful desserts, Boyden's should definitely be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Rene's Bakery Inc

Stepping into Rene's Bakery Inc felt like a delightful embrace from a warm hug of sugar and flour. The intoxicating aroma of freshly baked treats wafted through the air, luring me towards an enticing display of pastries. I couldn’t resist indulging in their signature cannoli, which boasted a perfectly crisp shell filled with creamy ricotta—pure bliss! Each bite was a symphony of flavor and texture. Rene's is a treasure trove for any dessert lover; their creativity and passion shine through every scrumptious creation. If you're searching for a sweet escape in Indianapolis, this bakery is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.