Lafayette's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

Trust me when I say, I’ve savored every cheesy slice and crispy crust that Lafayette has to offer. After reviewing 12 of the top pizza joints, I can assure you there’s a slice for every craving out there! Whether you’re in the mood for a classic pepperoni, a gourmet creation, or something uniquely local, I’ve got the inside scoop on where to find it.

My taste buds have become quite the connoisseurs through countless pizza nights with friends and family, so you can count on my recommendations to lead you to the pie of your dreams. Let’s dive into the delicious world of Lafayette pizza together!

Azzip Pizza

Highlights
Monthly special selections
Kid-friendly atmosphere
Tasty and creative pizzas
Professional and helpful staff
Clean and enjoyable environment

Review of Azzip Pizza in Lafayette

Upon stepping into Azzip Pizza, my senses were immediately tingled by the vibrant atmosphere – perfect for families and friends alike. The kid-friendly environment was evident, with laughter filling the air, creating a warm, inviting vibe.

Now, let's dig into the real star of the show: the pizza! What sets Azzip apart are their creative monthly specials. This charming approach keeps things fresh, and I couldn’t resist trying one of their creative concoctions. Each slice was a flavorful masterpiece, with the perfect balance of toppings that danced harmoniously on my palate.

Equally impressive was the professional and helpful staff, who guided me through the menu with a smile. Their enthusiasm for the pies was infectious, and it made my ordering experience delightful.

The environment was impeccably clean, with a modern yet cozy feel that made me want to linger. Overall, Azzip Pizza delivers not just a meal, but a memorable experience that satisfies both the taste buds and the spirit. If you're in Lafayette and craving pizza, this place is a must-visit for inventive flavors and welcoming vibes! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Arni's Lafayette Market Square

Highlights
Must-stop for pizza lovers
Consistently good crust
Generous toppings selection
Fun dining atmosphere
Delicious thin-crust pizza

Arni's Lafayette Market Square is a must-stop for any pizza lover wandering through Lafayette! From the moment I walked in, I was met with a welcoming atmosphere that sets the stage for a fun dining experience. The menu boasts a generous selection of toppings, allowing for endless combinations that cater to every palate.

I opted for their thin-crust pizza, and let me tell you, the crust was nothing short of spectacular—crispy yet perfectly chewy, complementing the flavor-packed toppings beautifully. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors, and I appreciated how consistently good the crust was—it's clear that they take pride in perfecting their pizza.

The vibe at Arni's is lively and inviting, making it a fantastic spot for both family gatherings and casual hangouts with friends. The energy in the room just adds to the overall enjoyment of the meal. If you’re in Lafayette and craving a slice or a whole pie, Arni's deserves a top spot on your pizza pilgrimage. You'll leave with a smile and a full belly, eager to return for more!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Mad Mushroom

Highlights
Great crust consistency
Fresh, quality toppings
New York style pizza
Good carry-out options
Casual college atmosphere

Mad Mushroom is an absolute gem in Lafayette’s pizza landscape that I think every pizza lover needs to experience. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by a playful, casual college atmosphere that immediately set the mood for a fun dining adventure.

What stood out the most was their incredible crust consistency. It strikes the perfect balance between crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. This New York-style pizza is a true delight, and the fresh, quality toppings elevate it to a whole new level. I indulged in their classic Margherita, and the flavor was simply divine—the tomatoes tasted like they were picked just moments before being added to my slice.

Mad Mushroom excels in offering great carry-out options, ideal for those nights when dining in isn't on the agenda. I found their service to be quick and efficient, making it easy to grab a delicious pizza to go.

In short, if you’re looking for a fun spot that delivers scrumptious pies with a smile, Mad Mushroom is definitely worth checking out. It’s a slice of Lafayette love that you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Arni’s Lafayette 350 South

Highlights
Delicious cheese pizza
Outstanding service
Best crust in town
Very clean establishment
Family favorite spot

When I stepped into Arni’s Lafayette 350 South, I was immediately struck by its welcoming atmosphere. This family favorite not only boasts a clean and inviting environment, but the smiling faces of the staff made me feel right at home. As a passionate pizza lover, I was itching to try their highly recommended cheese pizza, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint!

The crust is nothing short of spectacular—perfectly crispy on the outside while remaining delightfully chewy. Each bite revealed a melty, gooey cheese that danced joyfully with the rich tomato sauce underneath. It’s evident why locals rave about it—an absolute must-try for anyone in Lafayette.

Not only was the pizza outstanding, but the level of service was equally commendable. The attentive staff went above and beyond to ensure my experience was nothing short of delightful.

In my quest to find the best pizza in Lafayette, Arni’s has firmly secured a spot on my must-visit list. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this gem is definitely worth a stop! Don’t forget to indulge in their cheese pizza—you won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Cafe Literato

Highlights
Cozy atmosphere
Delicious food offerings
Great place for meetings
Fair prices and portions
Recommended by locals

Cafe Literato is a culinary gem tucked away in Lafayette, where pizza dreams come to life. The moment I walked in, I was wrapped in a cozy atmosphere, adorned with art and a bookshelf that practically begged for a good read. It felt like home but with a touch of charm that invites you to stay longer.

Now, let’s dive into their pizza offerings! I opted for their signature pie and was not disappointed. The crust was perfectly crisp, yet delightfully chewy, striking that ideal balance. Topped with a symphony of fresh ingredients, every bite was a celebration of flavors. It's easy to see why locals rave about this place.

I also appreciated that Cafe Literato offers generous portions at fair prices. Whether you're there for a casual meal or a meeting with friends, it’s the perfect spot to relax and indulge in delicious food. Their menu is more than just pizza, but let me tell you, their pies are the stars of the show.

If you’re searching for a pizza spot that brings warmth and flavor together in a delightful package, look no further than Cafe Literato!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

La Scala Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Authentic Italian Cuisine
Amazing Service
Beautifully Plated Dishes
Homemade Tasting Gnocchi
Outdoor Seating Available

Visiting La Scala Italian Restaurant in Lafayette was a delightful journey into the heart of authentic Italian cuisine. As soon as I stepped inside, the warm ambiance enveloped me, setting the stage for what would be a memorable meal. The amazing service from the staff made me feel right at home, and I was eager to try their pizza—an art form they’ve perfected.

I opted for their classic Margherita pizza, which arrived gracefully plated—cheese bubbling just enough to tease my senses. Each bite revealed a beautifully balanced harmony of flavors: the rich tomato sauce complemented by fresh basil, and the mozzarella was luscious without being overwhelming. It was clear that this wasn't just any pizza; it was crafted with passion and a respect for homemade traditions.

While savoring this delicious slice of heaven, I couldn't help but admire the option for outdoor seating, making it perfect for a warm evening. La Scala truly captured the essence of Italian dining, offering more than just a meal; it felt like a celebration of flavors. If you’re in Lafayette and in search of wonderful pizza, do yourself a favor and experience the joy of La Scala. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Parkway Pizza & Subs

Highlights
Variety of menu options
Solid pizza crust
Family-friendly atmosphere
Tasty Chicken Kebab
Pleasant interior design

Review of Parkway Pizza & Subs

If you’re on the quest for an excellent slice in Lafayette, look no further than Parkway Pizza & Subs. This delightful spot offers an impressive variety of menu options, ensuring that even the pickiest of eaters can find something to energize their taste buds. When I dug into their pizza, I was particularly pleased with the solid crust—perfectly baked, it provided that ideal blend of crunchy and chewy.

The atmosphere here is truly family-friendly, making it a great place for a casual meal with loved ones. I must mention the pleasant interior design, as it adds to the overall dining experience, making you feel right at home while you indulge in your favorite flavors.

While the pizza takes center stage, let’s not overlook the tasty Chicken Kebab; it’s a must-try if you’re feeling adventurous! All in all, Parkway Pizza & Subs has made its way to the top of my Lafayette pizza list, and I can't wait to return for another slice. If you’re in the area, stop by and treat yourself—you won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Arni's Columbian Park

Highlights
Delicious pepperoni pizza
Excellent training staff
Convenient pick-up location
Consistently hot food
Great overall atmosphere

Arni's Columbian Park truly delights pizza lovers with its killer pepperoni pizza that satisfies even the most discerning palates. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was electric, buzzing with laughter and conversations, making it clear that this spot is a local favorite.

What impressed me most was the consistently hot food emerging from their kitchen. You can taste the commitment to quality in each slice—perfectly crisp crust topped with just the right amount of cheese and spicy pepperoni that dances on your taste buds. The pick-up location is incredibly convenient, making it easy for both dine-in and take-out patrons to enjoy their meals without any hassle.

Moreover, the training staff at Arni's exhibits enthusiasm and efficiency, ensuring that each order is prepared with care. It’s clear that they take pride in their work, which elevates the dining experience. After devouring that pizza, I left with a full belly and a big smile. If you're in Lafayette and craving pizza, Arni's Columbian Park is a must-visit for a delicious slice of culinary joy!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Burt’s Place

Highlights
Flavorful deep dish pizza
Attentive and informative staff
Caramelized crust edges
Massive pizza portions
Good ambiance and spaciousness

Burt’s Place truly stands out as a treasure in the world of pizza! As I stepped inside, the vibrant ambiance instantly welcomed me. The spacious interior was perfect for families and gatherings, setting the stage for a great dining experience.

I opted for their signature deep dish pizza, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of a revelation! The pizza arrived, and I was greeted by a towering slice with caramelized crust edges that promised adventure in every bite. As I savored the first slice, the flavors exploded with a perfect symphony of rich tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of toppings. Truly, massive portions like this should come with a warning label—because it’s hard to resist overindulging!

What really elevated my visit was the attentive and informative staff. They guided me through the menu and were genuinely excited about the offerings, making me feel like part of the Burt's family.

In a city rich with pizza options, Burt’s Place wins the crown for its delicious deep dish, welcoming atmosphere, and excellent service. I can't wait to return for another round!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Pizza Uncommon

Pizza Uncommon is a delightful gem nestled in Lafayette that redefines pizza indulgence. From the moment I stepped in, the lively atmosphere and the aroma of fresh dough captivated me. Their crust is exquisitely chewy and perfectly charred, complementing an array of creative toppings. I opted for the signature Uncommon pie, which artfully balanced spicy pepperoni with a drizzle of honey—an unexpected yet harmonious duo. Each slice was a joyful burst of flavor that left me craving more. If you’re on a quest for something extraordinary, don’t miss this local treasure—Pizza Uncommon is truly a slice of heaven! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

The Pickle

The Pickle is a true gem in Lafayette’s pizza scene! With a quirky atmosphere that matches its name, I was immediately drawn in. Their artisan pizzas boast a delightful crunch with a perfectly charred crust that was both crisp and chewy. I savored the Margherita with a twist, showcasing fresh basil and a drizzle of balsamic glaze—heavenly! The staff is friendly and passionate, enhancing the overall experience. If you’re in the mood for something unique and delicious, The Pickle deserves a top spot on your pizza quest! 🍕 A must-try!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Bruno's Pizza

Tucked away on a bustling street, Bruno's Pizza is a delightful gem that captures the heart of pizza lovers. The moment I stepped in, the aroma of freshly baked dough and zesty marinara embraced me. Their signature Brooklyn-style pizza boasts a perfectly crispy crust, topped with a symphony of gooey mozzarella and vibrant toppings that dance on your palate. The blend of spices in the sauce is nothing short of magical, elevating each bite into a culinary experience. If you’re craving a slice of joy, Bruno’s is a must-visit—it’s truly where pizza dreams come alive! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.