The Absolute Best Margarita in Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

After tasting my way through 12 of the hottest spots in Indianapolis, I can confidently say that this city has some serious margarita magic. From the tangy twist of fresh lime to the perfect salt rim, each sip tells a story, and I’m here to spill the secrets.

You might be wondering why you should take my word for it. Well, let’s just say I’ve become a bit of a margarita connoisseur along the way, and my taste buds know exactly what to look for. So, whether you’re a casual drinker or a die-hard fan, get ready to discover where to find the most unforgettable margarita in Indy!

Mr Tequila's Cantina & Grill

Highlights
Fantastic bartender
Amazing margarita
Friendly service
Great food
Must-try tequila

After stepping into Mr Tequila's Cantina & Grill, I was immediately struck by the vibrant atmosphere and the friendly service that welcomed me like an old friend. As a passionate margarita enthusiast, I was eager to see if their famous margarita lived up to its reputation, and let me tell you—it certainly did!

The bartender, a true artisan in all things tequila, crafted the margarita with precision and flair. The balance of flavors was sheer perfection, striking a delightful harmony between tart and sweet that danced on my palate. Each sip felt like a sunny fiesta, transporting me straight to the heart of Mexico.

But it wasn't just the margarita that shone—the food was equally impressive, complementing my drink beautifully. I savored every bite, which only made the margarita taste even better. Mr Tequila's isn’t just a spot for a drink; it’s a full experience.

With their amazing margarita, vibrant ambiance, and welcoming vibe, I can confidently say that Mr Tequila's deserves a top spot in any margarita lover's journey across Indianapolis. If you’re looking for an unforgettable margarita experience, this is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Fernando’s Mexican & Brazilian Cuisine

Highlights
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Delicious and authentic food
Exceptional customer service
Owner personally engages guests
Great for first-time visitors

Fernando’s Mexican & Brazilian Cuisine is a gem that shines brightly in the bustling Indianapolis food scene, particularly when it comes to their margaritas. As soon as I stepped inside, the cozy and inviting atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm blanket, making it hard to leave. The owner, a gracious host, took time to engage with guests, adding a personal touch that truly enhances the dining experience.

Now, let's get to the star of the show—the margarita! Each sip of this refreshing concoction was an explosion of flavor. It perfectly balanced the tartness of lime with the sweetness of agave, leaving a lingering zest that tempted me to take another. This drink tasted remarkably authentic, showcasing the vibrant essence of Mexican culture.

Pairing the margarita with their delicious and authentic food created a symphony of flavors on my palate. The tacos were delectable, complementing the drink effortlessly. Admittedly, I walked in with high expectations, but Fernando’s managed to exceed them.

If you’re in search of the best margarita in Indianapolis, indulge yourself at Fernando’s—you won’t be disappointed! 🥂

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Los Arroyos Mexican Restaurant & Bar

Highlights
Relaxed dining atmosphere
Generous food portions
Fresh, high-quality ingredients
Excellent Tamarindo Margarita
Great for date nights

Los Arroyos Mexican Restaurant & Bar truly deserves a spotlight in the quest for the best margarita in Indianapolis. Upon stepping into this charming eatery, the relaxed atmosphere embraced me like a warm hug, creating an inviting vibe perfect for a leisurely outing. The generous portions of food only enhanced the experience, ensuring that every bite complemented the drinks I was eager to dive into.

Now, let’s talk about the Tamarindo Margarita! This vibrant cocktail was like a joyful celebration in a glass. Made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, it struck a perfect balance between sweet and tangy, delivering a refreshing twist that danced on my palate. The hint of tamarind brought a delightful nuance to the classic margarita, making it a standout choice.

I found myself savoring each sip while enjoying the lively backdrop, perfect for a date night or an evening with friends. Los Arroyos has redefined what a margarita should be, and for that, it holds a special place in my heart—an absolute must-visit for anyone searching for the ultimate margarita experience in Indy! Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Social Cantina

The margarita at Social Cantina is a vibrant celebration in a glass! Their handcrafted version combines fresh-squeezed lime juice with top-shelf tequila, creating a perfect balance of tart and sweet. The vibrant atmosphere enhances the experience, making each sip feel like a mini-vacation. I loved the option to add flavors like mango or jalapeño for a twist that tickles the taste buds. The salt rim is just the right amount of crunch, elevating the drink even further. If you’re on the hunt for a refreshing margarita, look no further than Social Cantina’s beloved concoction! 🍹

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Livery

At Livery, the ambiance is as vibrant as their margaritas. I sipped on the El Diablo, a daring blend of tequila and fresh fruit that danced on my palate with a hint of chili spice. Each sip felt like a fiesta—refreshing yet bold! The meticulously crafted drink was perfectly balanced, showcasing the artisanship that goes into every pour. The lively atmosphere made my experience even more delightful, as I savored this standout margarita. Whether you're looking for a classic or adventurous twist, Livery delivers an unforgettable experience that solidifies its place among the best in the Indy margarita scene!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Agave and Rye Indianapolis

At Agave and Rye, the margarita experience is nothing short of sublime. Their Classic Margarita is a symphony of flavors, blending fresh lime juice, top-shelf tequila, and just the right amount of agave nectar. Each sip dances on your palate, striking a perfect balance between sweet and tart. What sets this place apart is the vibrant atmosphere—think colorful décor and upbeat vibes that elevate your sipping experience. The staff is genuinely passionate about their craft, offering recommendations that make you feel like part of the family. If you’re seeking a refreshing twist on a timeless classic, this is the spot!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Bakersfield Mass Ave

At Bakersfield Mass Ave, the margarita was a delightful surprise. Their signature blend features fresh lime juice and a generous pour of tequila, delivering a perfect balance of tartness and warmth. The salted rim added a pleasing crunch that elevated each sip. The ambiance felt vibrant yet cozy, making it an ideal spot for both casual gatherings and lively celebrations. If you're hunting for the ultimate margarita, this gem definitely deserves a spot on your list. Cheers to the heart of Indianapolis, where Bakersfield serves up not just drinks but a taste of true Mexican spirit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Margaritas Mexican Restaurant

At Margaritas Mexican Restaurant, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere that was just as inviting as their signature margaritas. I opted for the classic Lime Margarita, and let me tell you, it was a masterpiece! The balance of fresh lime juice and just the right amount of sweetness left my taste buds dancing. The salt-rimmed glass added a delightful crunch, elevating every sip. Their generous pour of tequila truly set it apart, making it both refreshing and potent. If you’re hunting for a knockout margarita in Indianapolis, this spot is definitely worth a visit. 🌵✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

La Parada

At La Parada, the margarita experience was nothing short of delightful. With a punchy lime flavor and the perfect balance of sweetness, each sip danced on my palate. Their house-made mix showcases fresh ingredients that elevate this classic cocktail to new heights. What truly sets this gem apart is its creative twists—try the hibiscus margarita for a vibrant surprise! The ambiance is charming, creating a cozy oasis for relaxation. In a city brimming with options, La Parada stands out as a must-visit for margarita enthusiasts. Cheers to unforgettable flavors and good times! 🌵🍹

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Revolucion

At Revolucion, I discovered a margarita that truly stands out. The House Margarita is a refreshing blend of premium tequila, fresh lime juice, and agave nectar, striking the perfect balance between sweet and tangy. The vibrant presentation, complete with a salted rim, instantly elevates the experience. As I took my first sip, I was enveloped in a burst of flavors, making it clear that these bartenders know their craft. Add in a lively atmosphere and attentive service, and it’s easy to see why Revolucion is a local favorite. This margarita is not just a drink; it's an invitation to celebrate life!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Cinco de Mayo Cantina

At Cinco de Mayo Cantina, I discovered a zesty haven for margarita lovers. Their signature margarita, made with fresh lime juice and a hint of agave nectar, struck the perfect balance between tart and sweet. The salt rim added a delightful crunch, elevating the entire sip. I savored the refreshing coolness on a warm Indianapolis evening, making it feel like a mini-vacation in a glass. Nestled in a vibrant atmosphere, this cantina truly celebrates the spirit of the season. If you're hunting for a margarita that dances on your palate, look no further than Cinco de Mayo Cantina!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

La Eskina Indy

At La Eskina Indy, my taste buds danced with joy as I sipped their signature margarita. This refreshing concoction beautifully balances the tanginess of fresh lime with the warmth of top-shelf tequila. The perfect rim of salt added a delightful crunch, while the vibrant presentation made it as pleasing to the eye as it was to the palate. The atmosphere is as lively as their drinks, making it an ideal spot for unwinding with friends. If you're on the quest for the best margarita in Indianapolis, you won't want to miss this gem! Cheers to margarita bliss!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.