The Absolute Best New York Style Pizza in Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

As someone who has spent countless afternoons indulging in the perfect slice, I’ve taken on the delicious challenge of reviewing 12 of the top New York style pizza joints in Indianapolis. Trust me, I know my thin crust from my deep dish, and there’s something magical about that foldable slice that just hits the spot.

With each visit, I savored the flavors, soaked in the ambiance, and chatted with the passionate chefs behind the pies. Whether you’re a die-hard pizza aficionado or just looking for a quick bite, I promise you’ll find a spot that speaks to your taste buds. Get ready to discover where to find the best of the Big Apple right here in the Circle City!

The NY Slice

Highlights
Perfectly thin and crispy crust
Flavorful cheese
Fresh toppings
Friendly owner, Dan
Highly recommended

The NY Slice in Indianapolis is a delightful homage to classic New York-style pizza that had my taste buds doing a happy dance. As soon as I stepped inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked crust enveloped me, and I knew I was in for something special.

The moment I took my first bite, I was greeted with a perfectly thin and crispy crust that rivaled the best of NYC. It was both lightweight and robust enough to hold a generous amount of flavorful cheese and toppings, which were impeccably fresh. Each slice was a careful balance of ingredients that paid tribute to the laid-back pizza joints I’ve cherished in New York.

What truly set my visit apart was Dan, the friendly owner, whose passion for pizza is palpable. He readily recommendations and shared stories about his craft, making the experience feel warm and personal.

If you’re on the hunt for the best New York-style pizza in Indianapolis, The NY Slice is a must-visit. This is a spot where each slice tells a story and every visit leaves you craving another. So grab a slice and indulge—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Last Chance Pizza

Highlights
Fluffy crust, crispy edges
Spiciness for adventurous eaters
Great non-pizza options
Friendly and lively atmosphere
Highly recommended by locals

Last Chance Pizza truly lives up to its name as a pizza haven in Indianapolis! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a lively atmosphere that simply buzzed with excitement. The friendly staff really highlights the charm of this local gem. As for the pizza itself, let me tell you about their crust—it’s the perfect blend of fluffy and crispy, striking that delightful balance that every pizza lover yearns for.

I decided to dig into their classic New York-style slice, and I was pleasantly surprised by a kick of spiciness that took my taste buds on an adventure! It’s not overly hot, but just enough to make each bite intriguing. Plus, if pizza is not your sole passion, their menu boasts solid non-pizza options—a nice touch for those dining with varied tastes.

With so many locals singing its praises, it’s no wonder this spot has become a beloved staple. So, whether you’re a connoisseur or just someone looking for a satisfying slice, Last Chance Pizza is definitely a stop you shouldn't miss!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Diavola

Highlights
Wood-fired pizza options
Accommodating to dietary needs
Lively and pleasant atmosphere
Friendly and attentive staff
Great service recovery

Diavola in Indianapolis: A Slice of Heaven

When you step into Diavola, the aroma of wood-fired pizza instantly transports you to a bustling pizzeria in the heart of New York City. My anticipation heightened as I settled in, eager to sample their offerings. The atmosphere buzzed with an exciting energy, and the friendly staff made me feel right at home—it's hard not to fall in love with a place where hospitality shines as brightly as the ovens.

What truly sets Diavola apart is their commitment to accommodating various dietary needs. Whether you're gluten-free or seeking something lighter, they cater to everyone without compromising that essential New York flair. My choice for the day: a classic Margherita. With its perfectly charred crust, vibrant tomato sauce, and generous mozzarella, each bite was a delightful dance of flavors.

However, what impressed me even more was the staff's remarkable service recovery. When a small hiccup occurred with my order, their prompt and genuine response turned a minor inconvenience into a testament to their dedication to customer satisfaction.

In conclusion, Diavola is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. For those seeking an authentic New York experience right here in Indianapolis, look no further!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Futuro

Highlights
Great customer appreciation
Creative flavor profiles
Crispy, crunchy crust
Must-try ricotta cheese
Nice ambiance

Futuro in Indianapolis is a must-visit slice of pizza heaven. From the moment I stepped inside, I felt the warm customer appreciation that permeates the air. The atmosphere strikes a lovely balance between playful and inviting, making it the perfect backdrop for a pizza pilgrimage.

Now let’s talk about the pizza itself. The crispy, crunchy crust is an absolute triumph—each bite perfectly balanced between chewiness and snapping sound. I couldn't resist diving into their signature slice topped with ricotta cheese. This isn't your standard cheese; the creamy, rich flavor adds a delightful twist that elevates each morsel to a new level of deliciousness.

But it's not just a one-trick pony! The creative flavor profiles found at Futuro are incredibly impressive. Each pie celebrates inventive toppings that will intrigue your taste buds while staying true to the essence of New York style pizza. Whether you’re a purist or an adventurous eater, there’s a slice here for you.

In a city often overshadowed by Chicago, Futuro stands tall as a contender for the best New York style pizza in Indianapolis—and it surely won’t disappoint!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mass Ave. offers a delightful slice of New York charm right in the heart of Indianapolis. As I stepped inside, the authentic ambiance whisked me away to Brooklyn. The crust? Perfectly crisp yet wonderfully chewy, with just the right amount of char adding that coveted flavor. I savored the classic Margherita, where the fresh mozzarella melted like a dream. The sauce gracefully balances sweetness with acidity; it’s a masterpiece! Each bite wrapped me in a symphony of flavors—definitely worth a return trip. If you're craving NY nostalgia in Indy, Goodfellas is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Manhattan Pizzeria

Manhattan Pizzeria is a delightful slice of NYC right in the heart of Indianapolis. As I stepped inside, the aroma of fresh dough and sizzling cheese enveloped me like a warm hug. The thin, crispy crust had the perfect balance of chewiness and crunch, while the tangy tomato sauce danced brilliantly beneath a generous layer of bubbling mozzarella. Each bite was a flavor explosion, transporting me straight to the streets of Manhattan. The friendly staff adds a touch of local charm to this gem, making it a must-visit for any pizza lover seeking that authentic New York experience.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Brozinni Pizzeria at Speedway

As I stepped into Brozinni Pizzeria, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough engulfed me. The New York-style slices here are a delightful homage to the classic. Each bite features a masterfully thin crust—crispy yet foldable—that cradles a savorous blend of tangy sauce and perfectly melted cheese. Toppings are abundant and fresh, each adding its own flavorful flair. The ambiance is casual, making it the perfect spot to unwind with a slice in hand. If you're on the hunt for a true taste of New York in Indy, Brozinni is a slice of pie that absolutely delivers. 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Brozinni Pizzeria

Stepping into Brozinni Pizzeria, I was instantly transported to the bustling streets of New York. Their thin-crust pizza was a delightful revelation; the crust was perfectly crispy yet pliable enough for a classic fold. I savored the rich tomato sauce, bursting with flavor, while the generous layer of melted mozzarella danced atop each slice. The "Brooklyn" specialty pie, with its savory toppings, was an absolute standout. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff only enhanced the experience, making it feel like a home away from home. For anyone searching for an authentic taste of New York, Brozinni is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Enzo Pizza

Enzo Pizza is a delightful gem tucked away in Indianapolis, offering a slice of authentic New York charm. From the moment I stepped in, the aroma of fresh dough and zesty sauce enveloped me. I savored their classic cheese pizza, boasting a perfectly thin crust with just the right amount of flop. The sauce was richly flavored, complementing the generous mozzarella blanket to perfection. Each bite transported me straight to the bustling streets of NYC. If you're seeking a taste of the Big Apple without leaving Indy, Enzo Pizza is a must-visit. You’ll find yourself craving more!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Broad Ripple

During my visit to Goodfellas Pizzeria - Broad Ripple, I was immediately struck by the inviting atmosphere and the aroma of freshly baked dough. Their New York-style pizza boasts an impressive crust—thin, yet perfectly crispy—and topped with a delightful balance of tangy sauce and generous cheese. I opted for the classic pepperoni, and each slice delighted my taste buds with a satisfying foldability reminiscent of NYC streets. The friendly staff added to the charm, making my meal even more enjoyable. If you're on the hunt for authentic New York-style pizza in Indianapolis, Goodfellas definitely deserves a spot on your list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Giorgio's Pizza

During my recent visit to Giorgio's Pizza, I was greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough and rich tomato sauce. The crust was the true star—thin and crispy, yet perfectly foldable, making it a quintessential New York experience. Topped with a generous layer of melted mozzarella and a hint of fresh basil, each bite was a delightful fusion of flavors. What truly set Giorgio's apart was the vibrant tang of their homemade sauce, which danced on my palate with just the right amount of zest. For anyone craving an authentic slice, Giorgio's is a delicious destination in the heart of Indy!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub

Stepping into Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub feels like a delightful escape to the streets of New York. Their thin, foldable slices boast a perfect balance of tangy tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and a hint of herbs that dances on the palate. The crust? A glorious blend of crunchy and chewy, inviting you to savor each bite. The bustling ambiance adds to the charm, making it a fantastic spot to enjoy a slice (or two). For true pizza aficionados, Pearl Street is a must-visit destination that captures the essence of NYC right here in Indianapolis. 🍕

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.