The Absolute Best Philly Cheesesteak in Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

When it comes to finding the perfect Philly cheesesteak, my taste buds have been on quite the adventure, and Indianapolis has proven to be a hidden gem in the cheesesteak landscape! After diving into a mouthwatering mission that took me to 12 of the city’s top spots, I can confidently say that there’s more to Indy than meets the eye—especially when it comes to this iconic sandwich.

You see, I’ve navigated through gooey cheese, tender steak, and those essential toppings that make or break the experience. With my passion for food and a palate honed by countless bites, I’m here to guide you through the best of the best in Indy, ensuring you won’t miss out on the ultimate cheesesteak experience!

Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington

Highlights
Cooper Sharp cheese option
Atmosphere feels like Philly
Delicious Bacon Cheese Fries
Friendly and engaging staff
Mixed experiences on cheesesteaks

Review of Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington

As I strolled into Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington, the atmosphere instantly transported me to the streets of Philadelphia. The vibrant decor and friendly staff felt like a warm embrace, making me excited for the cheesesteak adventure ahead. I opted for their classic cheesesteak, featuring Cooper Sharp cheese—and let me tell you, it was a game-changer!

The flavor profile was rich, and the steak was grilled to perfection; however, the texture was a tad inconsistent, leaving me craving that glorious, satisfying bite. But fear not! The star of my meal was undeniably the Bacon Cheese Fries. Crispy, cheesy, and topped with perfectly cooked bacon, they made my taste buds dance with joy.

The staff was engaging and attentive, adding to the laid-back ambiance that felt oh-so-Philly. While I left with mixed feelings about the cheesesteak itself, the overall experience was delightful. If you’re in search of a place that serves up both classic cheesesteaks and a genuine Philly vibe, Hoagies and Hops is definitely worth a visit. Just be sure to order those fries—thank me later!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Checkered Flag Tavern

Highlights
Exceptional Chef-Prepared Food
Top Tier Bartending Service
Hidden Gem Dive Bar
Amazing Pork Belly Burnt Ends
Great Live Music Experience

Checkered Flag Tavern: A Hidden Gem for Philly Cheesesteak Lovers

Tucked away in Indianapolis, Checkered Flag Tavern is truly a diamond in the rough. I was welcomed by a vibrant atmosphere and a dive bar vibe that felt inviting. As I sat down, the aroma of sizzling meat and fresh rolls lured me in. I ordered their philly cheesesteak, and I must say it exceeded my expectations.

The sandwich was a masterpiece – the chef took great care in preparing it with perfectly seasoned steak, melty cheese, and a gently toasted hoagie roll. Each bite was a delightful combination of juicy flavors and textures. Not to mention, the bartending service was top-tier; they made sure my glass was never empty while I savored my meal.

During my visit, I was lucky enough to catch some lively live music that added to the vibe, making the experience even more memorable. And while the final star of the show was undoubtedly the cheesesteak, I couldn’t help but notice the mouthwatering pork belly burnt ends on the neighboring tables.

If you're searching for a playful culinary adventure, Checkered Flag Tavern deserves a pit stop on your cheesesteak journey!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Chicago fish and chicken

Highlights
Great food, always fresh
Incredible taste and quality
Diverse menu options
Piping hot meals
Sketchy neighborhood area

Chicago Fish and Chicken isn’t just about fish and chicken; it’s a hidden gem where I discovered a surprisingly stellar Philly cheesesteak! Nestled in a sketchy neighborhood, you might have your doubts upon arrival, but trust me, the deliciousness that awaits inside is worth the trek.

As I stepped in, the aroma of newly cooked food enveloped me, hinting at the fresh quality of the ingredients. The cheesesteak I had was a delightful surprise—loaded with tender steak, perfectly sautéed peppers, and generously drizzled with gooey cheese. Each bite was piping hot, a testament to the kitchen’s commitment to serving only the best!

While the menu is diverse, highlighting a lovely mix of fried favorites, it’s the cheesesteak that stole the show during my visit. It was a perfect reminder that sometimes the riches are found in the unlikeliest of places. So, if you find yourself in Indy with a craving for a satisfying cheesesteak, make a quick pit stop at this lively spot. Just don’t judge a book by its cover—get ready to be pleasantly surprised!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Steak & Lemonade

Highlights
Kind and fast service
Recommended cheesesteak
Excellent frozen lemonade
Heavy on onions and peppers
Rough neighborhood

Steak & Lemonade in Indianapolis captures the heart of the classic Philly cheesesteak experience with a delightful twist. Upon arrival, I was greeted by kind and fast service, which set a positive tone for my visit. With recommendations whispering in my ear like foodie fairy dust, I knew I had to try their signature cheesesteak.

As I took my first bite, the richness of the savory steak melded perfectly with the melty cheese, while heavy on onions and peppers added a satisfying crunch. The balance was impeccable; you could really taste the care they put into crafting this dish. Each mouthful transported me back to the streets of Philadelphia—if only briefly!

But let’s not forget about the excellent frozen lemonade that perfectly complemented the meal. Its refreshing tartness cut through the richness of the cheesesteak, making it a refreshing sidekick that you wouldn’t want to miss.

Now, I must mention the rough neighborhood surrounding the eatery. While it may not be the picture-perfect location, don’t let that deter you! It’s proof that great flavors often reside in the most unexpected places. If you're in search of a divine cheesesteak experience, look no further than Steak & Lemonade—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Rock-Cola 50's Cafe

Highlights
Great food, cooked fresh
Friendly and nice staff
Welcoming small atmosphere
Character-filled surroundings
Unpretentious dining experience

Upon stepping into Rock-Cola 50's Cafe, I was instantly transported to a lively, retro diner. The character-filled surroundings and unpretentious ambiance set the tone for an enjoyable meal. The staff here are incredibly welcoming, adding to the charm of this quaint spot.

Now, let's talk about the philly cheesesteak itself. Cooked fresh to perfection, each bite of the sandwich was a delightful explosion of flavors. They skillfully blend just the right amount of juicy beef with perfectly melted cheese—each component playing its role beautifully. No soggy bread here; it was a solid foundation that held this delight together.

The cafe’s friendly atmosphere only enhances the dining experience, making you feel right at home. I couldn’t help but smile as I savored each bite, surrounded by the cheerful clatter of plates and laughter. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy great food, and leave with a happy belly.

If you're on the hunt for a philly cheesesteak that embodies the essence of both flavor and comfort, Rock-Cola 50's Cafe is an excellent choice. It's a slice of culinary nostalgia that deserves a spot on your dining list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

Highlights
Delicious, fresh ingredients
Great food and service
High-quality subs
Memorable dining experience
Worth the price

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop Review

When it comes to philly cheesesteaks, Capriotti's Sandwich Shop delivers a mouthwatering experience that tantalizes the taste buds. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the aroma of fresh ingredients that promised something special.

I ordered their signature cheesesteak, and let me tell you, it was a revelation! The quality was evident; the steak was tender and perfectly seasoned, while the melted cheese enveloped it like a warm hug. They take pride in sourcing their ingredients sustainably, and it truly shines through.

The service was as delightful as the food. The staff was attentive and enthusiastic, which made my visit all the more enjoyable. As I savored each bite, I couldn’t help but notice that this wasn’t just a meal; it was a memorable dining experience. I found the price reasonable considering the quality of the subs they offer.

In a city overflowing with options, Capriotti's stands out as a must-visit for anyone seeking the ultimate philly cheesesteak experience in Indianapolis. If you’re in the mood for something unforgettable, I wholeheartedly recommend you give it a try!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Philadelphia Steak & Fries

Upon entering Philadelphia Steak & Fries, I was greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of grilled meat and sautéed onions. The cheesesteak I ordered was a delightful creation—tender steak, generously smothered in gooey cheese, all nestled in a perfectly toasted roll. The balance between the seasoning and toppings was spot-on, bringing a taste of the East Coast to the Midwest. The crispy fries on the side were a nice touch, too. Overall, it's a solid choice for anyone craving an authentic philly cheesesteak experience right here in Indianapolis. I’ll definitely be back for more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Big City Grill & Lemonade

Tucked away in a bustling corner of Indy, Big City Grill & Lemonade delivers a delightful twist on the classic philly cheesesteak. The moment I took a bite, the juicy, perfectly seasoned steak mingled beautifully with melted cheese on a soft, fresh hoagie roll. What sets this gem apart is their house-made lemonades, which offer the perfect refreshing counterpoint to the savory richness of the sandwich. Attentive staff and a cozy atmosphere topped off the visit, making it a truly enjoyable experience. If you're on the hunt for a delicious philly cheesesteak, don’t miss this local treasure!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

The Good Spot

When I wandered into The Good Spot, I was greeted by the enticing aroma of sizzling, freshly grilled meats. The philly cheesesteak I ordered was a delightful masterpiece: tender beef, perfectly melted provolone, and a generous helping of sautéed onions, all nestled in a toasty roll that balanced the flavors beautifully. Each bite transported me to the streets of Philly—well, almost! The warm atmosphere and friendly staff added to the charm, making it a must-visit for anyone craving this iconic sandwich. If you’re on the hunt for a solid cheesesteak in Indy, The Good Spot is definitely worth your time!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Steak Escape Sandwich Grill - Indianapolis

At Steak Escape Sandwich Grill, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of sizzling beef and melted cheese that immediately set the mood for a memorable meal. The steak was tender, generously portioned, and cooked to perfection, while the cheese oozed with flavor, creating a mouthwatering combination. The fresh toppings and toasted hoagie roll added that perfect crunch, making each bite a little piece of heaven. Although the ambiance was casual, the experience more than made up for it. For anyone craving a flavorful philly, this spot is a must-visit in Indianapolis! 🍽️

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Mambo's at The Amp

Mambo's at The Amp is a vibrant hotspot for anyone seeking a taste of the authentic Philly cheesesteak. The moment I took my first bite, the tender, juicy steak paired with the melt-in-your-mouth cheese was a delight. The bread? Perfectly toasted—crispy on the outside, yet soft enough to hold its delicious filling. I appreciated the optional toppings, which add a fun twist to a classic dish. The lively atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for both lunch and dinner. If you’re on a quest for the best cheesesteak in Indy, don’t skip Mambo’s—it’s a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

New York Gourmet deli

Stepping into New York Gourmet Deli felt like a delightful trip back to the streets of Philly. Their cheesesteak, packed with tender sliced ribeye and topped with gooey provolone, was a true standout. The bread, fresh and crusty, held it all together beautifully, while the sautéed onions added a sweet complexity that elevated each bite. I adored the generous portion size, leaving me satisfied but still dreaming of that first mouthful. If you’re hunting for a slice of authentic NYC flavor right in the heart of Indy, this deli deserves a top spot on your must-visit list! 🍽️

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.