The Absolute Best Pizza in Columbus [Updated 2025]

Each slice tells a story, and I’ve tasted them all. After reviewing 12 of the top locations in Columbus, I can confidently say that this city is a hidden gem for pizza lovers. Whether you’re craving a classic pepperoni or something more adventurous, I’ve got the inside scoop on where to find the perfect pie.

You can trust my recommendations because I’ve spent countless hours, and probably a few too many calories, exploring every corner of our pizza scene. So, grab a napkin and get ready to discover your new favorite spot—your taste buds will thank you!

Carlos Pizza

Highlights
Amazing food
Friendly staff
Great for lunch dates
Good pizza, fair price
Recommended cheese pizza

Carlos Pizza in Columbus is a gem that deserves a spotlight! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a smile from the friendly staff, setting the perfect tone for my lunchtime adventure. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a cozy date or a casual meal with friends.

Now, let's talk about the pizza! I sampled their recommended cheese pizza, and wow! It was sheer perfection. The crust was wonderfully crispy yet delightfully chewy, providing a solid foundation for the generous layer of tangy sauce and gooey cheese. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors that left me wanting more. What pleased me even more was the price – it felt like a steal for such amazing food!

If you're on the hunt for great pizza without breaking the bank, Carlos Pizza should definitely be on your list. With its perfect balance of quality and value, this place serves up a slice of joy that’s hard to resist. Do yourself a favor and indulge. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Henry Social Club

Highlights
Amazing food quality
Spectacular service
Great downtown atmosphere
Fresh and beautifully presented
Highly recommended for all

Henry Social Club: A Slice of Bliss in Downtown Columbus

Stepping into Henry Social Club felt like arriving at a friend’s stylish backyard gathering, but with way better pizza! The moment I walked through the doors, I was greeted by spectacular service that made me feel right at home. The ambiance is a delightful blend of cozy and modern, perfectly complementing their impressive menu.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the pizza. Each pie I tried was a masterpiece, showcasing amazing food quality that left my taste buds dancing. The crust was perfectly crispy, yet light—just the right balance to carry the abundance of fresh toppings. It’s clear that this place takes pride in its ingredients, which are not only fresh but also beautifully presented, making each dish a visual delight.

With such a vibrant downtown atmosphere, I found Henry Social Club to be a fantastic spot for both casual pizza nights and special outings. If you're in search of a pizzeria that checks all the boxes, this place comes highly recommended. You won’t just leave full; you’ll leave happy. Don’t miss out on this pizza gem in Columbus!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Eddie's Lakeview Pizza

Highlights
Thin and dry crust
Under-cooked pizza
Rude customer service
Order preparation issues

Eddie's Lakeview Pizza sounded promising, but alas, my visit felt like a pizza rollercoaster. As I walked in, the atmosphere was inviting, yet I quickly noticed the thin and dry crust of my choice. It lacked the satisfying bite I usually crave. Upon taking the first slice, I discovered it was frustratingly under-cooked—definitely not the crispy delight I was hoping for.

What really left a sour taste in my mouth, however, was the customer service. The staff felt more like bouncers than pizza artisans, with a distinctly rude demeanor that made me hesitant to ask for adjustments. I was met with a sympathetic shrug when I brought up my concerns about the order preparation issues; it was as if they were saying, "Oh well, that’s just how we roll here!"

Despite my high hopes for a memorable meal, Eddie's Lakeview Pizza fell short. While the lakeside view might lure you in, I'm afraid it left me longing for a more authentic pizza experience. If you're out for an adventure, they might just serve as a cautionary tale in an otherwise delicious Columbus pizza scene. 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Angottis Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Hidden gem in downtown
Intimate and charming atmosphere
Exceptional food quality
Friendly and helpful staff
Reservation recommended

Angottis Italian Restaurant is truly a hidden gem nestled in the heart of downtown Columbus. Upon stepping inside, I was immediately swept away by the intimate and charming atmosphere—the warm lighting and rustic decor set the perfect stage for a cozy dining experience.

Now, let's talk about the pizza! The moment I took my first bite, I was captivated by the exceptional food quality. The crust was delightfully crispy yet tender, providing the ideal canvas for the rich, flavorful toppings. Every element felt carefully curated, echoing the restaurant's dedication to authentic Italian cuisine.

Adding to the pleasant experience was the staff, who provided attentive and genuinely friendly service. They were not just helpful but also enthusiastic about recommending their favorites. I must say, a reservation is recommended here, as it quickly attracts local pizza aficionados like myself.

In a city bursting with pizza options, Angottis certainly stands out. If you're on a quest for remarkable pizza in Columbus, look no further—this place is a must-visit! Each bite transports you to a culinary paradise, making for an unforgettable dining adventure. 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

ZwanzigZ Pizza

From the moment I stepped into ZwanzigZ Pizza, the aroma captivated my senses, promising a delightful feast. Their signature thin crust was perfectly crispy, providing a satisfying crunch with every bite. I tried the "The Columbus Combo," generously topped with fresh ingredients that exploded with flavor. Each slice was a harmonious blend of cheesy goodness and zesty sauce. The atmosphere was vibrant, making it a perfect spot for casual dining with friends. If you're craving a pizza that’s both inventive and comforting, ZwanzigZ should be at the top of your list for the best pizza in Columbus! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Chicago's Pizza Columbus

At Chicago's Pizza Columbus, I dove into a slice of pure heaven. Their deep-dish pizza is a true testament to the Windy City’s culinary legacy, with a flaky crust that cradles layers of gooey cheese and robust tomato sauce. The toppings blend harmoniously, creating a flavorful explosion in every bite. I must say, the balance of spice and heat in their pepperoni is simply perfection. The cozy atmosphere, paired with friendly staff, elevates the overall experience, making it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. If you’re craving a slice of Chicago magic in Columbus, this place is absolutely worth it! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Noble Roman's

Noble Roman's is a delightful trip down memory lane, blending nostalgia with a modern twist. The moment I took a bite of their crispy, golden crust, I was transported to my youth, where every slice promised a new adventure. Their unique toppings, from zesty pepperoni to a rich veggie medley, danced together in harmony. The sauce burst with flavor, perfectly complementing the gooey cheese that blanketed each slice. While it may not be your typical artisanal pie, it’s a comforting slice of Columbus that hits all the right notes. If you’re in the area, Noble Roman’s is worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Columbus Greek's Pizzeria

If you're craving a slice with a twist, Columbus Greek's Pizzeria is a delightful gem! Their Mediterranean-style pizzas burst with freshness, featuring toppings like tangy feta and vibrant Kalamata olives. I indulged in the Greek Delight, where the crispy crust met a harmonious blend of spices that danced on my palate. The welcoming atmosphere added to the experience, making it perfect for a cozy gathering. Don't overlook their tzatziki sauce—it’s the perfect dip to elevate your pizza game. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this spot deserves a place on your pizza journey!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

BlackSheep Pizza & Cocktails

At BlackSheep Pizza & Cocktails, flavor takes center stage! This vibrant spot boasts an impressive menu, showcasing its artisan pizzas with a creative twist. I savored the Pesto Chicken, a delightful medley of basil pesto, succulent chicken, and tangy mozzarella that danced on my palate. The crust? Simply divine—crispy yet chewy, a perfect cradle for the toppings. Paired with a refreshing cocktail, it felt like a culinary embrace. The ambiance buzzed with energy, making it a great hangout. If you’re on the hunt for something special, BlackSheep will certainly whet your appetite for Columbus pizza perfection!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

HotBox Pizza

During my recent visit to HotBox Pizza in Columbus, I was instantly charmed by the vibrant atmosphere and welcoming staff. I dove into their signature "Bacon Me Crazy" pizza, and let me tell you, the layers of crispy bacon combined with a savory blend of cheeses sent my taste buds on a delightful journey! Each slice was a perfect balance of crispy crust and tantalizing toppings. The playful names of the pies added a fun twist to my meal. If you're searching for a unique pizza experience, HotBox is definitely worth a visit—it's a slice of happiness! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

The Original Chicago's Pizza & Curry - Edinburgh IN

Stepping into The Original Chicago's Pizza & Curry - Edinburgh IN was like entering a warm, inviting culinary haven. The deep-dish pizza stole the show with its buttery crust, layered with gooey cheese and a tangy sauce that danced on my taste buds. Each slice felt like a delightful hug! The added twist of curry-infused dishes was an unexpected surprise, appealing not just to pizza lovers but also to those craving something unique. If you're in Columbus, this spot deserves a top place on your pizza bucket list. Honestly, it’s a slice of heaven you won't want to miss! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders is a delightful gem in Columbus that truly left me smiling. The pepperoni pizza, with its perfectly crispy crust and gooey cheese, was a slice of heaven—each bite bursting with flavor! I also couldn’t resist their grinders, which are a must-try for any sandwich lover. The atmosphere offers a cozy charm, making it a perfect spot for a casual meal. If you’re on the hunt for satisfying pizza that combines quality with a welcoming vibe, Mancino’s is a place you won't want to miss! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.