The Absolute Best Pizza in Highland [Updated 2025]

You know, there’s something magical about sinking your teeth into a slice of pizza that just hits the spot. As a Highland local, I’ve made it my mission to hunt down the absolute best pies this town has to offer. After sampling the offerings from 12 top locations, I can confidently say that there’s no shortage of mouthwatering options here.

Whether you crave a classic margherita or something a bit more adventurous, I’ve tasted it all and have some solid favorites to share. My taste buds have been on quite the journey, and I can’t wait for you to join me as we explore the ultimate pizza experience in Highland!

Arrenello's Pizza Highland

Highlights
Best pizza in NWI
Fresh ingredients every time
Sweet sauce is a standout
Excellent thin and deep crust
Popular, but slow delivery

Arrenello's Pizza in Highland is an absolute gem for pizza lovers like myself! From the moment I walked in, I could tell I was in for a treat. This place has built a reputation as the best pizza spot in NWI, and let me tell you, it does not disappoint.

What really sets Arrenello's apart is their commitment to fresh ingredients; every bite bursts with flavor. I was particularly enchanted by their sweet sauce, which strikes the perfect balance between tangy and sugary—a rare find that elevates the whole experience. Whether you're a fan of their thin crust or prefer a more indulgent deep dish, each style is crafted with care and precision, providing a delightful crunch and a satisfying chew.

Although they are undeniably popular, be prepared for a bit of a wait on delivery. Good things come to those who wait, right? Overall, Arrenello's offers pizza that is both enjoyable and memorable, making it a must-try for anyone looking to indulge in the finest slices Highland has to offer. If you're hunting for your new favorite pizza spot, look no further than this Highland hideaway! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best bars in Indianapolis.

Giuseppe's Pizza

Highlights
Incredible ricotta calzones
Delicious pasta dishes
Highly praised tiramisu
Fresh and flavorful pizza
Responsive customer service

Giuseppe's Pizza in Highland is a delightful gem that exceeded my expectations and had my taste buds dancing with joy. As I walked in, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza enveloped me, a prelude to the delicious journey ahead. I opted for their signature pizza, and I could immediately taste the quality of the ingredients. The crust was perfectly crisp, providing a delightful base to the explosion of flavors that followed.

One bite revealed a symphony of fresh and flavorful toppings, harmonizing into a mouthwatering experience. And let’s not forget their incredible ricotta calzones, which are an absolute must-try for any calzone aficionado! The rich, creamy ricotta filled the calzone to perfection, making it a comforting yet sophisticated choice.

To wrap up my meal, I indulged in their highly praised tiramisu. Rich and creamy, it was the ideal end to my feast. I also appreciated the responsive customer service; the staff were friendly and eager to ensure a fantastic dining experience. If you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Highland, look no further than Giuseppe's Pizza—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best clubs in Indianapolis.

Capri's Pizza

Highlights
Delicious and flavorful pizza
Perfectly cooked crust
Nostalgic Chicago experience
Frequent customer loyalty

Capri's Pizza Review

Walking into Capri's Pizza felt like stepping into a slice of nostalgia, where every corner whispers tales of hand-tossed dough and gooey cheese. As I perused the menu, I couldn’t resist the siren call of their signature pizza, known for its delicious and flavorful toppings.

When the pie arrived, I was immediately struck by the perfectly cooked crust—golden-brown with just the right amount of crunch. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors that danced on my palate. The fresh ingredients were evident; you could tell this wasn’t your run-of-the-mill pizza joint.

What really sets Capri's apart, though, is the sense of community. The friendly faces behind the counter seemed to know almost everyone who walked in, fostering an atmosphere of warmth and familiarity that is increasingly rare. It was no surprise to see repeat customers gleefully greeting the staff—there’s a reason why patrons return time and again.

If you're searching for that quintessential Chicago pizza experience in Highland, I wholeheartedly recommend Capri's. With every bite, you'll be transported to pizza paradise!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Indianapolis Downtown.

Fuzzyline Brewing Co.

At Fuzzyline Brewing Co., the vibrant atmosphere pairs beautifully with their delicious pizzas. I savored the Margherita, which boasted a perfect balance of fresh basil, mozzarella, and tangy sauce on a crispy crust. Each bite was nothing short of heavenly! The unique craft beers offered here complement the pizzas splendidly, making it a top-notch spot for casual hangouts. The staff was both friendly and attentive, adding to the enjoyable dining experience. If you're in Highland and in the mood for great pizza and craft brews, this cozy brewery should definitely be on your list! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bars in Fort Wayne.

Langel's Pizza

If you’re seeking the ultimate pizza experience, look no further than Langel's Pizza! The delightful aroma that greets you upon entering sets the stage for a pie that truly shines. The crispy, thin crust is perfectly baked, holding up beautifully against an indulgent layer of zesty tomato sauce and gooey cheese. My favorite was the House Special, loaded with fresh toppings that burst with flavor. The staff is as warm as the oven, adding a personal touch to your visit. For a slice that dances on your palate, Langel’s Pizza is a must-try in Highland! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bars in Carmel.

Amici Grill and Pizzeria

At Amici Grill and Pizzeria, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Their classic margherita pizza was a delightful revelation; the fresh basil perfectly complemented the rich tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella. I loved the crispy crust that held all the toppings beautifully. The friendly staff added to the communal vibe, making each bite even more enjoyable. If you’re in Highland and seeking a slice that balances tradition with taste, Amici should definitely be on your list. It’s a slice of pizza paradise that’s hard to forget! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best bars in Bloomington.

Romano's

Romano's in Highland is a hidden gem that truly knows how to craft a pie! From the moment I stepped in, the inviting aroma of fresh dough and zesty sauce enveloped me. I opted for their signature Margherita, and it didn’t disappoint—the thin crust was perfectly crisp, topped with vibrant basil and gooey mozzarella that danced on my palate. Each bite was a delightful celebration of flavor, and the friendly staff added to the warm atmosphere. If you’re searching for pizza that feels like a hug in a box, Romano’s might just be your new favorite stop!

You might also want to check out the best bars in South Bend.

King Dough

At King Dough, the artisan touch truly shines. Their crust? A delightful balance of crispiness and chewiness—a feat few can master. I sampled the Margherita, and the fresh basil and quality mozzarella danced atop the vibrant tomato sauce. Each bite whispered of honest ingredients and careful craftsmanship. The cozy atmosphere added to the charm, making it an ideal spot for a casual night out. If you're in Highland and craving pizza, King Dough is a worthy contender that promises to elevate your pizza game. Don't miss it! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Rochester.

Squigi's Pizza of Highland

At Squigi's Pizza of Highland, I was greeted with a cozy atmosphere and a tantalizing aroma that made my stomach rumble. Their signature Thin Crust Margherita was a masterpiece, balancing fresh basil, rich tomato sauce, and gooey mozzarella. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors! The friendly staff added to the charm, making me feel right at home. I highly recommend diving into their House Special, a savory medley of toppings that truly sets them apart. If you're seeking a slice of pizza perfection, Squigi's is a must-try in Highland—where every pizza is made with love and passion!

You might also want to check out the best dive bars in Indianapolis.

Dante's House of Pizza

Dante's House of Pizza is a delightful gem where the aroma of fresh-baked crust greets you at the door. Their classic marinara sauce adds a perfect tang, while the cheese is gloriously gooey—every bite feels like a warm embrace. I couldn’t resist the pepperoni extravaganza; each slice was a symphony of flavors, crispy yet satisfying. The ambiance is cozy, making it an ideal spot for a casual night out or a quick bite. If you’re in Highland and craving pizza perfection, don’t miss out on Dante’s—it's a slice of heaven that leaves you yearning for more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Whitestown.

Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery

Stepping into Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery, I was immediately greeted by the enticing aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese. Their signature Tomato Bar Style pizza features a crispy, golden crust that perfectly cradles a zesty marinara and a generous melt of mozzarella. The options are as vast as my appetite, boasting inventive toppings that dance on the palate. I particularly loved the Pesto Chicken, a delightful medley that had me savoring every bite. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a slice to go, this spot delivers a slice of heaven in every bite – a true gem in Highland’s pizza scene!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Evansville.

State Line Pizza Highland

Stepping into State Line Pizza Highland felt like entering a cozy haven for pizza lovers. The aroma of freshly baked dough danced in the air, instantly sparking my appetite. I opted for their signature State Line Special, a delightful medley of toppings that magically blended flavors in every bite. The crust was perfectly crispy yet chewy, hitting that sweet spot between classic and gourmet. I couldn’t resist pairing it with their tangy house-made marinara, which was a delightful companion. If you're hunting for exceptional pizza that ticks all the boxes—taste, quality, and vibe—State Line is a must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best date ideas in Indianapolis.