New Albany's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

Each slice tells a story, and I’ve just devoured a dozen of them across New Albany. From cozy corners to bustling hotspots, I’ve scouted 12 top pizzerias, savoring every bite along the way. My taste buds have become seasoned experts, and let me tell you, there’s a world of flavor waiting for you.

You can trust my recommendations because I didn’t just stop at the classics—I ventured into the hidden gems, sampling everything from traditional margheritas to creative toppings that push the boundaries of pizza perfection. So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, let’s find your next favorite slice together!

Arni's New Albany

Highlights
Great carry-out pizza
Quick preparation time
Consistent unique flavor
Busy even on weekdays
Exciting dining room updates

I recently had the pleasure of indulging in a delicious pizza from Arni's New Albany, and let me tell you, the experience was nothing short of delightful! As I walked into the bustling atmosphere, it was clear that this place has a well-deserved reputation—busy even on weekdays, a sure sign of its popularity.

I opted for their famed carry-out pizza, and I was thrilled by the quick preparation time—a mere 15 minutes! The crust was perfectly crisp, providing that delightful crunch I crave, while the toppings were a symphony of flavors that came together in harmony. What sets Arni's apart is their consistent unique flavor, which keeps you coming back for more with every slice.

The dining room updates are a breath of fresh air, providing a warm and inviting ambiance that makes you want to linger a little longer. Overall, I can confidently say that if you’re on the hunt for a standout pizza in New Albany, Arni's is a must-try. Get ready to savor every moment of that cheesy goodness!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Mimo's Pizzeria

Highlights
Amazing aroma of fresh dough
Perfect balance of crust
Rich and flavorful sauce
Generous and fresh toppings
Casual, clean, and cozy vibes

Mimo's Pizzeria is a delightful playground for pizza lovers in New Albany! As I stepped through the door, the amazing aroma of freshly baked dough instantly enveloped me, setting the stage for what would be an unforgettable meal. I dove right into their offerings and was immediately struck by the perfect balance of crust—crispy on the outside yet wonderfully chewy inside, it held the pizza together splendidly.

Moving on to the sauce, I must say, the rich and flavorful tomato base danced on my taste buds, providing a zesty kick that paired beautifully with every topping. Speaking of toppings, Mimo's doesn't shy away from generosity. Each slice was adorned with fresh ingredients that felt abundant and satisfying, making every bite a joy.

The atmosphere of the pizzeria is equally charming, with a casual, clean, and cozy vibe that invites you to linger a little longer. Whether you're dining solo or with friends, Mimo's truly makes for a comforting experience. In a town brimming with pizza options, Mimo's Pizzeria proudly stands out as one of the best, delivering not just great pizza but also a warm slice of community. Highly recommended!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Pizza King

Highlights
Great service and atmosphere
Impressive food quality
Unique smaller cut toppings
Family-friendly dining spot
Affordable prices

Pizza King: A Slice Above the Rest

When I stepped into Pizza King, the warmth of its inviting atmosphere greets you like an old friend. The staff is incredibly welcoming, ensuring your experience is delightful from the get-go. Their signature smaller cut toppings are an unexpected twist, offering an opportunity to savor each bite without overwhelming the palate. I opted for a classic pepperoni, and it did not disappoint! The freshness of the ingredients was palpable—each slice was a blend of crispy goodness on the edges and a perfectly chewy crust in the center.

What truly sets Pizza King apart is its family-friendly vibe. It's the kind of place where laughter mingles with the aroma of baking pizza, making it perfect for gatherings with loved ones. And let’s not forget the prices—they're downright wallet-friendly. You don’t need to break the bank to indulge in a fantastic meal here.

In the competitive world of pizza, it’s easy for flavors to blend into mediocrity, but Pizza King maintains its identity with impressive food quality and a vibrant ambiance. If you’re in New Albany and craving a pizza adventure, Pizza King should definitely be on your radar!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen

Highlights
Great service
Delicious food
Fun vibe
Immediate seating
Perfectly cooked steak

I recently had the pleasure of visiting The Exchange Pub + Kitchen in New Albany, and let me tell you, it was a delightful experience. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere that perfectly balances a playful vibe with a hint of sophistication. The immediate seating was a pleasant surprise, and the friendly staff made me feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the pizza. Their crust? Perfectly baked, with that wonderful crispy exterior and a chewy inside that sings with every bite. Topped with fresh ingredients and a sauce that balances tartness and sweetness, it’s truly a symphony of flavors.

But don't get me started on the steak! Cooked to perfection, it complements the pizza experience rather than overshadow it. The vibe of the pub is buzzing, making it a perfect spot for gathering with friends over great food and lively conversations.

In essence, if you're on the hunt for some of the best pizza in New Albany, The Exchange Pub + Kitchen is a must-visit. The delicious food and great service are just the cherry on top!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

The Spaghetti Junction Restaurant

Highlights
Quick online ordering
Generous portions
Delicious garlic bread
Baked spaghetti options
Family-friendly dining

As I stepped into The Spaghetti Junction Restaurant, the inviting aroma of fresh garlic bread instantly made my heart flutter. Their online ordering system is remarkably quick, ensuring you’re just a few clicks away from pizza bliss. Upon receiving my classic pie, I marveled at the generous portion size—definitely not for the faint of heart!

The crust was perfectly golden, with a delightful crunch that gave way to a soft, chewy center. I opted for the pepperoni and extra cheese, and oh, it was a match made in pizza heaven! Each bite was a harmony of flavors, complemented by their stellar baked spaghetti options for those who want a little adventure.

Not to be overlooked, the garlic bread deserves a mention for its buttery perfection—an ideal companion for any pizza feast! The atmosphere is family-friendly, making it a perfect spot for gatherings or cozy dinners alike.

In summary, if you’re on the quest for pizza perfection in New Albany, The Spaghetti Junction might just be the corner of paradise you’ve been searching for. Their attention to flavor and quality is sure to keep me coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Floyd County Brewing Company

Highlights
Monty Python theme
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Unique beer selections
Friendly and patient staff
Delicious food options

Floyd County Brewing Company offers a delightful pizza experience that is sure to make your taste buds dance! As I stepped inside, the cozy and inviting atmosphere instantly caught my attention. The décor, inspired by Monty Python, adds a playful twist that makes you feel right at home while you’re enjoying your meal.

I was greeted by the friendly and patient staff, eager to recommend their unique beer selections that pair perfectly with their pizzas. I opted for the margherita pizza, and let me tell you—it was a slice of heaven! The crust was impressively thin and crispy, allowing the fresh tomatoes and basil to take the spotlight. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors, proving that they truly know how to elevate a classic dish.

In addition to the delicious food, the overall vibe of the place makes it a fantastic spot for both family outings and casual meet-ups with friends. If you're looking for a spot that combines great pizza with a laid-back atmosphere, Floyd County Brewing Company should definitely be on your list! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Pizza Lupo

Highlights
Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizza
Awesome "Sting Like A Bee"
Great Date Night Spot
Fantastic Atmosphere
Reservations Recommended

Pizza Lupo is nothing short of a culinary gem nestled in New Albany. From the moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped by a fantastic atmosphere—an ideal blend of cozy and chic, perfect for a date night. The flickering flames from the wood-fired oven set the stage for what I hoped would be a pizza nirvana.

I was particularly excited to try their acclaimed "Sting Like A Bee" pizza. The moment it arrived, the aroma was intoxicating. Each bite delivered a delightful punch of flavor, the sweetness of the honey contrasting beautifully with the savory toppings. It was a symphony of ingredients that danced on my taste buds, leaving me craving just one more slice.

Additionally, the attention to detail in the cooking process was remarkable. The crust was perfectly charred, leaving a satisfying crunch that harmonized with the freshness of the toppings.

If you plan on visiting, I strongly recommend making reservations, as this hot spot tends to fill up fast. Pizza Lupo has firmly cemented itself as one of my top picks for the best pizza in New Albany! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Legacy Pizza & Bakery

Legacy Pizza & Bakery truly delivers a delightful experience that tantalizes the taste buds! The crust is perfectly crispy—a lovely canvas for their fresh, quality toppings. I opted for the classic Margherita, and the combination of vibrant tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil was heavenly. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, adding to the overall charm. Service was friendly, making me feel right at home. If you’re searching for a slice of perfection, look no further than Legacy. This gem in New Albany might just become your new pizza obsession! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

8th Street Pizza

Stepping into 8th Street Pizza felt like entering a pizza lover's paradise. The inviting aroma of freshly baked dough danced through the air, teasing my senses. I opted for their signature New Albany Delight—a masterful blend of tangy sauce, zesty pepperoni, and enchanting house-made mozzarella. Each bite was a celebration, with a perfectly crispy crust that had just the right amount of chew. The bustling atmosphere added to the charm, making it a perfect spot for friends and family to gather. If you're on the hunt for an unforgettable slice, 8th Street Pizza is a must-try destination that leaves you craving more!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

The New Albanian Brewing Company Pizzeria & Public House

I recently indulged in a pie at The New Albanian Brewing Company Pizzeria & Public House, and I must say, it was a delightful affair! The crust was perfectly crispy yet chewy, offering a beautiful canvas for the fresh toppings. I savored the Classic Margherita, with its vibrant basil and just the right amount of tangy sauce. The ambiance was lively, embodying a cozy, inviting charm that complements their craft beer selection beautifully. If you’re on the hunt for a slice of pizza bliss, this gem in New Albany is an absolute must-visit! 🍕 A slice of heaven awaits!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

PARLOUR

At PARLOUR, the moment I stepped in, the warm, inviting atmosphere set the stage for a delightful pizza adventure. Their signature Margherita pizza stole the show, featuring a perfectly thin crust that crackled with each bite. The blend of fresh basil and velvety mozzarella created a harmonious flavor explosion that danced on my palate. I also couldn't resist their intriguing Spicy Pepperoni; the kick was just right! The friendly staff adds to the charm, making you feel right at home. If you’re hunting for a slice of heaven, PARLOUR is a must-visit in New Albany! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

The Cloverleaf bar & grill

The Cloverleaf Bar & Grill is a hidden gem in New Albany, where bold flavors and a cozy atmosphere blend perfectly. As I took my first bite of their signature pizza, the crispy crust cradled a rich tomato sauce and a generous layer of gooey cheese that danced on my palate. The toppings were fresh and eclectic, adding a delightful twist to the classic experience. Each slice felt like a warm hug, inviting me to savor more. With its friendly vibe and delicious offerings, Cloverleaf is undoubtedly a top contender for the best pizza in town. Don’t miss it!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.