The Absolute Best Seafood Restaurant in Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

After diving into the vibrant culinary scene of our city and sampling the freshest catches from twelve incredible seafood spots, I’ve discovered some hidden gems and a few crowd favorites that truly stand out. As someone who loves nothing more than a plate piled high with oysters or a steaming bowl of clam chowder, I’ve made it my mission to explore every nook and cranny of Indianapolis’ seafood offerings.

You can trust my taste buds—I’ve savored the flavors, soaked in the atmospheres, and chatted with chefs and staff to bring you the most authentic and delicious recommendations. Whether you’re a lifelong seafood lover or just dipping your toes in, I promise you’ll find the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings right here in the heart of the Midwest!

Salt on Mass

Highlights
Exceptionally perfect food
Warm, genuine service
Consistently dependable service
Creative cocktail offerings
Delicious dessert options

Salt on Mass is truly a gem in the heart of Indianapolis, and I can confidently say that it stands out as one of the city’s finest seafood destinations. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm, genuine service that made me feel instantly at home. As I perused the menu, it became clear that the chefs here have mastered the art of seafood. Each dish was prepared with meticulous attention to detail, securing saltwater treasures that were exceptionally perfect.

What really delighted me were the creative cocktail offerings that perfectly complemented my meal. Each sip was a fantastic journey of flavors, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to my dining experience. It’s a haven for those who appreciate a well-crafted drink alongside their fresh catch.

To top it all off, I couldn’t resist indulging in one of their delightful dessert options. It was the cherry on top of an already delightful meal! Every visit to Salt on Mass has been consistently dependable, making it a reliable choice for anyone searching for great seafood in the area. If waterfront dining in the heart of the city appeals to you, I can’t recommend Salt on Mass highly enough!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Crab 99 Bar and Restaurant

Highlights
Best Cajun seafood boil
Customizable plate options
Quality seafood selection
Generous portion sizes
Friendly staff

Crab 99 Bar and Restaurant is truly a gem nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, and as soon as I stepped through the doors, I felt the vibrant energy that this place exudes. One of the highlights of my visit was their best-in-class Cajun seafood boil—a feast that is as customizable as it is delicious. With a variety of seafood options to choose from, I opted for a combination of shrimp and crab, which was cooked to perfection and generously spiced to create that unforgettable kick.

What impressed me the most were the portion sizes—definitely not for the faint of heart! It’s a comforting sight to see mounds of fresh seafood spilling over onto your plate. Plus, the staff is not only friendly but also knowledgeable, eager to guide you through their menu and ensure your experience is nothing short of exceptional.

With the quality seafood selection and a lively atmosphere, Crab 99 is undoubtedly a top contender for the best seafood restaurant in Indianapolis. For anyone yearning for a taste of the coast right here in the city, I wholeheartedly recommend diving into a seafood adventure at this delightful spot!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Kona Jack's Restaurant, Fish Market & Sushi Bar

Highlights
Quick seating at sushi counter
Friendly and attentive waiter
Disappointing food quality
Noisy dining experience
High price for poor experience

Kona Jack's Restaurant, Fish Market & Sushi Bar is a vibrant spot that promises a delightful seafood experience, and I couldn’t resist diving in! Upon arrival, I was pleased with the quick seating at their sushi counter, where I settled in for what I hoped would be a memorable meal. The atmosphere buzzed with energy, though I found the noisy dining experience a tad overwhelming at times.

My server was a standout—friendly and attentive, ensuring I felt welcomed and well taken care of throughout my visit. However, the excitement quickly waned once the food arrived. Unfortunately, I found the quality not quite up to par with what I had envisioned. It felt like a letdown, especially considering the high prices on the menu. This might explain why my expectations were somewhat dashed as I sampled the offerings.

While Kona Jack's has potential, between the disappointing food quality and the ambience that left a lot to be desired, it might not be the best choice for seafood lovers in Indy. Still, I appreciate the hustle and bustle of the place—it certainly has character!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Slapfish

Highlights
Incredible seafood variety
Friendly, attentive service
Delicious lobster rolls
Clean, inviting atmosphere
Reasonably priced beverages

Slapfish in Indianapolis is a seafood lover's paradise that struck a delightful chord with me during my recent visit. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a clean and inviting atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The vibrant essence of the restaurant set the tone for what would be a fantastic culinary adventure.

Now, let’s dive into the real star of the show: the food. Their incredible variety of seafood offerings had my mouth watering as I scanned the menu. However, the highlight of my meal was undoubtedly the lobster roll. It was succulent, generously filled, and bursting with flavor, truly a testament to what seafood should be.

Adding to the pleasure of dining here was the friendly and attentive service I received; the staff seemed genuinely invested in ensuring I had a top-notch experience. And if you’re like me and appreciate a good beverage, you’ll find some reasonably priced drinks to accompany your meal without breaking the bank.

In short, Slapfish has positioned itself as a standout seafood option in the city, and I can't wait to return for another delightful feast!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Pier 48 Fish House and Oyster Bar

Highlights
Lively atmosphere
Great for pre-game drinks
Delicious seafood options
Friendly and welcoming service
Creative cocktail menu

Pier 48 Fish House and Oyster Bar is a delightful treasure tucked away in the heart of Indianapolis. Upon entering, I was immediately greeted by a lively atmosphere that buzzed with energy — perfect for those pre-game drinks or a casual evening out. The restaurant exudes a vibrant yet relaxed vibe, making it an ideal spot for seafood lovers of all stripes.

Now let’s talk seafood: the options here are truly delicious. From their perfectly shucked oysters to their tantalizing fish tacos, every bite is a celebration of coastal culinary excellence. What caught my attention even more was the creative cocktail menu; the refreshing concoctions paired beautifully with the rich flavors of the dishes.

The service was notably friendly and welcoming, making me feel right at home. I always appreciate a staff that’s eager to share suggestions and their knowledge of the menu. If you’re on the hunt for an exceptional seafood spot in Indianapolis, look no further. Pier 48 not only satisfies your cravings but also ensures a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, this lively eatery deserves a spot on your must-try list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Rick's Café Boatyard

Rick's Café Boatyard is a delightful gem that captures the essence of coastal dining right in the heart of Indianapolis. From the moment I stepped in, the nautical decor and vibrant atmosphere whisked me away to a seaside retreat. The signature clam chowder was a creamy masterpiece, while the grilled swordfish stole the show with its exquisite flavors and perfect char. Friendly staff and a robust drink menu, including creative cocktails, made my experience even more enjoyable. If you're in search of fresh seafood served with a side of charm, Rick's is your destination. 🌊✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

The Oceanaire Seafood Room

From the moment I stepped into The Oceanaire Seafood Room, I was enveloped in a vibrant ambiance that exudes coastal charm. The menu is a treasure trove of fresh catches, showcasing everything from succulent scallops to daily specials that flirt with the palate. I indulged in the pan-seared halibut, which danced with flavor and texture. The service was impeccable, with staff eager to share their expertise. Each dish was a symphony of flavors, transporting me straight to the sea. If you’re seeking the best seafood experience in Indianapolis, look no further—this gem is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Beech Grove

On a delightful evening at The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar - Beech Grove, I was swept away by the flavorful aroma of their signature dishes. The cajun seafood boil stole the show—each bite bursting with freshness and spice. Their friendly staff exudes a warm, welcoming vibe, making you feel right at home. I couldn't resist indulging in the savory blue crab, which was cooked to perfection. The casual atmosphere paired with delectable offerings makes this spot a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts. If you're in Indianapolis and craving the ocean's bounty, don’t miss out on this treasure!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Caplingers Fresh Catch

Upon stepping into Caplingers Fresh Catch, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of the ocean. This charming establishment captures the essence of freshness with its locally sourced seafood. The standout dish, the crispy fish tacos, danced on my palate. Each bite was a delightful blend of flavors that left me longing for more. The staff exuded warmth and expertise, making the experience even more enjoyable. With its laid-back atmosphere and commitment to quality, Caplingers is a must-visit gem for seafood lovers in Indianapolis. If you’re seeking a culinary escape, look no further than Caplingers Fresh Catch!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Ocean Prime

Ocean Prime in Indianapolis is a sublime haven for seafood lovers. The moment I stepped in, the elegant ambiance set a sophisticated tone, perfect for a special night out. I dove into their signature lobster bisque, rich and velvety, followed by the melt-in-your-mouth sea bass that was both flaky and flavorful. The attentive staff added to the experience with their delightful recommendations. Don't miss their delectable dessert – the layered cake was the perfect sweet ending! Overall, Ocean Prime offers a uniquely refined dining experience that left me craving more. Definitely a must-visit for seafood aficionados!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Tiff's Love Butta & Soulfood Seafood

Tiff's Love Butta & Soulfood Seafood tantalized my taste buds with its vibrant atmosphere and mouthwatering dishes. The crab cakes were a standout — tender yet crispy, bursting with flavor. I also indulged in their shrimp po' boy, a delightful explosion of spices that left me wanting more. What truly sets Tiff's apart is the warm, welcoming service; I felt like family from the moment I walked in. Pair that with their cozy décor and you've got a gem in the heart of Indianapolis. If you're craving seafood with a soulful twist, Tiff's is a must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Bluebeard

At Bluebeard, I was immediately charmed by the inviting atmosphere and eclectic decor. The seafood was a delightful surprise, with the pan-seared scallops stealing the show—perfectly cooked and accompanied by vibrant seasonal vegetables. The raw bar selection was impressively fresh, showcasing the chef's commitment to quality. Each bite felt like a joyful celebration of the ocean’s flavors. The knowledgeable staff provided exceptional service, enhancing the overall experience. If you're seeking a place where culinary creativity meets classic seafood dishes, look no further than Bluebeard. It’s a treasure waiting to be discovered in the heart of Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.