Southern's Best Pizza

Each bite of pizza tells a story, and I’ve savored countless delicious chapters throughout Southern Indiana. After reviewing 12 top locations, I can confidently say that this region has some hidden gems just waiting to be discovered. From the crispy crusts to the mouthwatering toppings, I’ve tasted my way through it all, and believe me, my taste buds are ready to share the highlights.

You might be wondering why you should trust my pizza prowess. Well, let’s just say I’ve spent years exploring local favorites, chatting with chefs, and even trying my hand at homemade recipes. So, grab a slice and settle in—your ultimate pizza adventure in Southern Indiana is about to begin!

Futuro

Highlights
Friendly and appreciative staff
Excellent tavern-style pizza
Delicious Detroit-style option
Creative flavor profiles
Unique whipped ricotta topping

Futuro in Southern left me utterly delighted with its tavern-style pizza that perfectly balances flavor and fun. As I stepped into the restaurant, I was greeted by warm smiles from the friendly staff, whose enthusiasm set a welcoming tone for my dining adventure.

One standout offering is their Detroit-style pizza, a captivating twist that boasts a perfectly crispy crust and a robust, savory sauce. Every bite was a celebration of rich flavors and textures, which truly exemplifies what great pizza should be. I also appreciated the restaurant's commitment to creativity, as reflected in their innovative flavor profiles.

Not to be overlooked was the unique whipped ricotta topping that elevated each slice into something extraordinary. It provided a creamy contrast to the rich toppings, inviting me to savor each bite more deliberately.

In a vibrant atmosphere that's both cozy and inviting, Futuro brilliantly combines quality ingredients with friendly service. If you're on a quest for pizza that not only satisfies your cravings but also makes you smile, do yourself a favor and visit Futuro. You won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurant in Indianapolis.

Diavola

Highlights
Wood fired pizza options
Great accommodating staff
Lively atmosphere
Excellent service experience
Tasty meatballs and pasta

At Diavola, I was met with a delightful blend of the familiar and the remarkable. The wood-fired pizza options showcased a symphony of flavors—each bite beautifully charred yet moist, setting a high bar for any pizza purveyor. The atmosphere was lively, buzzing with laughter and the unmistakable aroma of freshly baked crust. It felt as though I had stumbled into a gathering of friends, and it was easy to see why.

The staff were nothing short of accommodating, ensuring that my experience was as enjoyable as the food. Their enthusiasm for the menu was infectious, and I found myself drawn to try some of their tasty meatballs and pasta alongside my pizza—a decision I do not regret!

Each dish arrived promptly, showcasing a remarkable service experience that left me feeling truly satisfied. If you're in the mood for exceptional pizza in a welcoming environment, Diavola is the place to be. I left wanting more, already dreaming of my next visit. This spot is a delightful gem in the Southern pizza scene, and I can't recommend it enough!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Carmel.

Mimo's Pizzeria

Highlights
Freshly baked pizza aroma
Friendly and fast service
Crispy and chewy crust
Generous fresh toppings
Casual and cozy vibes

Mimo's Pizzeria is a delightful hideaway that captures the essence of what pizza should truly be. From the moment I stepped in, the freshly baked pizza aroma enveloped me, setting my taste buds tingling with anticipation. The decor embodies a casual and cozy vibe, perfect for a laid-back dinner or a cheerful gathering with friends.

What struck me most was the crispy and chewy crust, a perfect balance that held up firmly against a generous array of fresh toppings. I sampled their signature margherita, and let me tell you—it was a symphony of flavors. The vibrant tomato sauce mingled beautifully with fragrant basil and creamy mozzarella, a timeless classic executed with finesse.

The service was both friendly and fast, making my visit all the more enjoyable. The staff clearly take pride in their craft, and their enthusiasm only heightened my excitement. Every bite was a little piece of heaven. If you find yourself in Southern and have a craving for pizza, I highly recommend making a beeline for Mimo's. It’s a culinary adventure you won’t want to miss! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Magoo's California Pizza

Highlights
Amazing white sauce
Friendly owner and staff
Light and fluffy crust
Personalized pizza recommendations
Clean and welcoming atmosphere

At Magoo’s California Pizza, I found myself on a delightful adventure that went far beyond the average pizza experience. The moment I stepped inside, I was welcomed by the friendly staff and the charming owner, who eagerly offered personalized recommendations to satisfy my palate. I decided to try their signature pie, featuring an incredible white sauce that danced beautifully on my taste buds—a bold choice that truly paid off!

What struck me next was the light and fluffy crust; it was like a cloud of doughy goodness that cradled all the toppings effortlessly. Each bite was a lovely combination of textures and flavors, making it hard to resist going back for more. Beyond just the pizza, the atmosphere was clean and welcoming, inviting you to linger a little longer—perfect for savoring every moment of your meal.

If you’re looking for a slice of happiness in Southern, look no further than Magoo’s. They prove that California-style pizza can be a genuine culinary delight. With personalized service and a menu that encourages exploration, I left feeling like I'd discovered a hidden gem. Grab a slice, and I promise you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in South Bend.

Speakeasy Pizza

Highlights
Amazing wood-fired pizza
Perfect cheese and sauce ratio
Highly recommended by foodies
Delicious Knuckleheads pizza
Worth the trip to Orleans

Speakeasy Pizza in Southern is an adventure for the taste buds that I absolutely had to experience. As I stepped into this quaint eatery, I was greeted with the intoxicating aroma of wood-fired pizza. I knew I was in for a treat! The first bite of their signature Knuckleheads pizza took me over the moon—perfectly balanced cheese and sauce ratio that makes even the most discerning pizza lover swoon.

What sets Speakeasy apart is its quirky ambiance and dedication to quality, making it a must-visit for anyone looking for a slice of joy. Local foodies rave about this gem, and it’s easy to see why! Each pizza is crafted with care, allowing the rich flavors to shine through.

I can confidently say that this pizza is worth the trip to Orleans. The blend of toppings and the signature smokiness from their wood-fired oven will keep you coming back for more. If you find yourself wandering through Southern, don’t miss the chance to indulge in Speakeasy's delicious offerings. It truly stands out as one of the best pizza spots in the area!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fishers.

Legacy Pizza & Bakery

Walking into Legacy Pizza & Bakery is like stepping into a cozy haven where the aroma of freshly baked bread envelops you. Their crust? A delightful balance of chewy and crispy, perfectly golden and ready to cradle a generous layer of toppings. I sampled the Margherita pizza, and the rich tomato sauce paired with fresh basil and mozzarella was nothing short of divine. Each bite transported me to Italy! The warm, welcoming staff added to the overall charm, making it more than just a meal—it was an experience. If you're in Southern, this pizza spot is a must-try! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Valparaiso.

8th Street Pizza

At 8th Street Pizza, every slice tells a story! The crust is perfectly crispy, providing an ideal base for their rich, tangy sauce that dances with the cheese. Topped with fresh ingredients, each bite is a delightful explosion of flavor. I couldn't resist their signature Southern Delight—a mouthwatering blend of spices, pepperoni, and veggies that hit all the right notes. The atmosphere is inviting, making it a perfect spot for friends and family. Whether you're a local or just passing through, I highly recommend diving into a pie from 8th Street for an unforgettable treat! 🍕 Simply delectable!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

New Bethel Ordinary

Nestled in the heart of Southern, New Bethel Ordinary serves up a slice of culinary heaven that had my taste buds singing. The crust? A delightful balance of crispy and chewy, perfectly holding up under generous toppings. Their signature pizza—topped with zesty house-made sauce and a symphony of fresh ingredients—was nothing short of a masterpiece. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a perfect spot for casual gatherings. If you’re seeking a pizza experience that marries tradition with a playful twist, look no further. New Bethel Ordinary is undoubtedly a must-try for all pizza enthusiasts! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Mazerella's Upper Crust Pizza and Pasta

After indulging in a slice at Mazerella's Upper Crust Pizza, I was utterly enchanted. The crust? Perfectly thin and crispy, it provided the ideal foundation for their rich, house-made marinara sauce, which danced delightfully on my palate. Topped with generous chunks of fresh mozzarella and fresh basil, each bite was a harmonious blend of flavors. The ambiance felt cozy and inviting, with a charming local vibe that made my visit even more enjoyable. If you’re on the hunt for an unforgettable pizza experience in Southern, don’t miss out on Mazerella’s incredible offerings—it's a slice of heaven! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

King Dough

King Dough is a delightful gem in Southern that truly redefines pizza perfection. From the moment I stepped inside, the aroma of fresh dough and rich toppings enveloped me. Their signature wood-fired pies boast a crispy, airy crust that’s simply irresistible. I savored the Truffle Shuffle; the earthy truffle oil paired exquisitely with creamy mushrooms. The balance of flavors was nothing short of a culinary symphony! The vibrant ambiance and friendly staff added to the charm, making it a perfect spot for pizza lovers. If you're seeking an extraordinary pizza experience, King Dough is undoubtedly a must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Big Woods Pizza - Nashville

At Big Woods Pizza, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of fresh dough and savory toppings. Their signature pie, the “Woodsman,” is a delightful medley of smoky bacon, rich mushrooms, and a perfectly tangy sauce that dances on your palate. Each bite is a celebration of flavors, showcasing their commitment to quality ingredients. The crust is golden and crispy, striking the perfect balance between chewy and crunchy. Cozy vibes enhance the experience as you indulge in their craft beers. If you're searching for a pizza adventure in Southern, Big Woods is an absolute must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Enzo Pizza

Stepping into Enzo Pizza felt like stumbling upon a hidden gem in Southern. The aroma of freshly baked dough and zesty tomato sauce welcomed me like an old friend. I ordered the Margherita, and each bite was a delightful dance of flavors—the mozzarella was so creamy, it practically sang harmonies. The crust struck the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, kissed by just the right amount of char. I couldn’t resist finishing the whole pie! If you’re on the hunt for a slice that embodies passion and authenticity, Enzo is an absolute must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Broad Ripple Indianapolis.