The Absolute Best Private Elementary Schools in Indianapolis [Updated 2025]

As I dove into the heart of Indianapolis, I found myself captivated not just by the city's vibrant culture, but by the incredible educational opportunities it offers. After reviewing 12 top-notch private elementary schools, I've uncovered some hidden gems that truly stand out.

With years of experience navigating the education landscape, I know what to look for in a school that nurtures young minds. So if you’re on the hunt for a place where your child can thrive, let me guide you through the best options that the Circle City has to offer. Trust me; you’re going to love what you discover!

Calvary Christian School

Calvary Christian School in Indianapolis radiates a warm, inviting atmosphere that truly feels like a second home for students. From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I was greeted by enthusiastic teachers who are dedicated to nurturing each child's potential. The curriculum is both rigorous and enriching, balancing academics with spiritual growth. Small class sizes allow for personalized attention, fostering a strong sense of community among both students and parents. What truly impressed me was the school's commitment to character development, instilling values that extend beyond the classroom. In a word, Calvary is a delightful choice for families seeking quality education!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in Fort Wayne.

Trinity Christian School

Trinity Christian School is a delightful gem tucked away in Indianapolis! The moment I stepped onto the campus, I felt a warm, welcoming vibe among the playful young learners and dedicated educators. The curriculum, infused with faith-based values, encourages not only academic excellence but also character development. What truly stood out were the small class sizes, allowing for personalized attention and fostering strong relationships between students and teachers. The vibrant community and engaging activities spark creativity and joy in learning. If you're searching for an institution that nurtures both mind and spirit, Trinity Christian School might just be your perfect match!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in Evansville.

St. Monica School

St. Monica School is a hidden gem in Indianapolis that dazzles with its warm community spirit and nurturing environment. From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I felt the vibrant energy radiating from both the students and faculty. The dedicated teachers cultivate a love for learning through innovative approaches, making education feel like an adventure. Not only does the school excel academically, but it also emphasizes character development and spiritual growth. With a beautiful campus and a strong sense of belonging, St. Monica School is truly a standout choice for families seeking a holistic educational experience.

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in South Bend.

St. Richard's Episcopal School

St. Richard's Episcopal School truly stands out as a gem in Indianapolis! With its nurturing environment and a robust academic curriculum, the school fosters a love for learning that feels almost magical. The teachers are exceptionally dedicated—you can sense their passion. Not only does the school emphasize academic excellence, but it also cultivates values of kindness and community. Additionally, the diverse extracurricular programs, from arts to athletics, provide students with a well-rounded experience. If you’re looking for a place where children can grow intellectually and emotionally, St. Richard’s strikes just the right chord!

You might also want to check out the best elementary schools in Northwest.

Chapel Hill Christian School

Chapel Hill Christian School truly embodies a nurturing environment where education meets faith. From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I was greeted by warm smiles and a palpable sense of community. Their dedicated teachers foster a passion for learning, making subjects come alive in engaging ways. The school’s focus on both academic excellence and spiritual growth sets it apart, ensuring students thrive in all aspects of life. With a variety of extracurricular activities, children are encouraged to explore their interests. For families seeking a well-rounded education infused with values, Chapel Hill is undoubtedly a top choice in Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Indianapolis.

Suburban Christian School

During my enchanting visit to Suburban Christian School, I was immediately struck by the sense of community that envelops this delightful institution. The staff exudes passion, and their commitment to fostering both academic excellence and spiritual growth is evident. The classrooms buzz with curious minds, and the gorgeous campus invites outdoor learning. I was particularly impressed by their innovative curriculum, designed to ignite a love for learning in every child. Suburban Christian balances rigorous education with heartfelt values, creating a nurturing environment where children thrive. If you're seeking a place where faith and learning intertwine harmoniously, this school is truly a gem!

You might also want to check out the best private high schools in Indianapolis.

Horizon Christian School

At Horizon Christian School, I was immediately struck by the vibrant community and its nurturing environment. The dedicated faculty foster a sense of belonging while inspiring curiosity in young minds. Their emphasis on academic excellence is beautifully complemented by strong Christian values. I loved how the curriculum balances rigorous learning with creative expression, encouraging students to explore their unique talents. Plus, the joyful atmosphere radiates from every corner—making it a delightful place for children to thrive. Overall, Horizon stands out as a top choice for families seeking a well-rounded education infused with compassion and character development.

You might also want to check out the best high schools in Indianapolis.

The Oaks Academy - Brookside

The Oaks Academy - Brookside is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Indianapolis. From the moment I stepped onto the campus, I was enchanted by the vibrant community and the jubilant spirit of the students. This school beautifully combines academic rigor with a strong emphasis on character development, creating a nurturing and stimulating environment. The dedicated faculty fosters a collaborative and engaging atmosphere where creativity flourishes. I was especially impressed by their commitment to service and community involvement, encouraging students to be kind and culturally aware. If you're seeking a school that champions both excellence and compassion, look no further!

You might also want to check out the best nail salon in Fort Wayne.

The Oaks Academy - Fall Creek

Stepping into The Oaks Academy - Fall Creek felt like entering a vibrant learning community where curiosity reigns supreme! This school blends academic rigor with a heartwarming sense of community. I was especially impressed by their commitment to character development and civic responsibility. The dedicated teachers create an environment that encourages children to explore and express their unique talents. The spacious campus, adorned with bright artwork, fosters creativity and collaboration. Overall, The Oaks truly cultivates a nurturing atmosphere that prepares students for both academic success and lifelong learning. Truly, this is a gem in the heart of Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best private schools in Indianapolis.

Eman Schools

Eman Schools in Indianapolis truly stands out as a delightful educational haven! Nestled in a vibrant community, the school offers a rich curriculum infused with academic rigor and moral development. I was particularly impressed by the dedicated faculty, who foster a nurturing environment that encourages curiosity and creativity. The campus is vibrant, bursting with learning opportunities and enrichment activities that cater to diverse interests. Most notably, Eman excels in cultivating a strong sense of community, making every student feel valued. If you’re seeking a place where children flourish both academically and personally, Eman Schools is definitely worth considering!

You might also want to check out the best high schools in Indiana Private.

The Orchard School

Nestled amid lush greenery, The Orchard School radiates a vibrant and nurturing atmosphere. I was immediately struck by the emphasis on experiential learning—students engage in hands-on projects that spark curiosity and creativity. The dedicated faculty fosters a sense of community, ensuring each child feels valued and heard. Their commitment to environmental stewardship and social responsibility shines through every lesson. I found the balance between academic rigor and playful exploration refreshing. Overall, The Orchard School is a delightful gem, perfectly blending inquiry-based learning with a warm, supportive environment—making it a top choice for families in Indianapolis!

You might also want to check out the best middle schools in Indianapolis.

International School of Indiana

Stepping into the International School of Indiana is like opening the door to a world of culture and creativity! The vibrant language immersion programs instantly caught my attention—students learning not just through textbooks but through engaging, hands-on experiences. The dedicated teachers foster a warm, inclusive environment that makes education feel like a delightful adventure. I was particularly impressed by their commitment to global citizenship, preparing kids to thrive in an interconnected world. For families seeking a unique blend of academic excellence and cultural awareness, this school truly shines. It’s a gem where curiosity is the compass guiding young minds!

You might also want to check out the best nail salons in Greenwood.