The Absolute Best Pizza in Avon [Updated 2025]

As someone who’s spent countless hours sampling slices and chatting with local pizza aficionados, I’ve delved into 12 of the top spots in Avon to uncover which pizzerias truly stand out. Each bite tells a story, and trust me, I’ve savored every cheesy moment along the way.

You might wonder why you should trust my taste buds. Well, let’s just say I’ve got a knack for sniffing out the perfect crust and the ideal sauce-to-cheese ratio. Whether you’re a die-hard pepperoni fan or someone who loves to venture into gourmet territory, I’ve got the scoop on where to find the most mouthwatering pies in town. Get ready to find your next favorite pizza joint!

Magoo's California Pizza

Highlights
Amazing white sauce
Friendly owner, Aladdin
Fast and attentive service
Light and fluffy crust
Delicious create-your-own options

My recent visit to Magoo's California Pizza was nothing short of delightful! As I stepped inside, I was greeted by the warm and welcoming presence of Aladdin, the owner, whose friendly demeanor instantly made me feel at home. The service here is impressively fast and attentive, making it a perfect spot for both casual diners and hurried pizza enthusiasts.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show—the pizza! I decided to go for a create-your-own option and was pleasantly surprised to discover their amazing white sauce as a base. It added a creamy richness that was simply divine! The crust was light and fluffy, perfectly balancing the toppings without overwhelming them.

What I really appreciated was the variety of options available for customization. There's something for everyone, and you can let your imagination run wild with toppings. My pizza was a delicious masterpiece that I can’t wait to recreate!

If you're looking for pizza that combines quality with a fun atmosphere and personal touch, look no further than Magoo's! Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Pizzaville

Highlights
Delicious pizza options
Polite and friendly staff
Clean restaurant environment
Great value for prices
Highly recommended takeout

Pizzaville certainly stands out as a delightful oasis for pizza lovers in Avon! From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was inviting, underscored by a clean and organized environment that reflects their commitment to quality. The polite and friendly staff welcomed me like an old friend, making the experience all the more enjoyable.

But let’s get to the heart of the matter—the pizza! The options available are simply delicious. I tried their signature pepperoni and a custom veggie, both bursting with fresh flavors. The crust had just the right amount of crispness, and each bite felt like a celebration of perfectly melded ingredients.

One aspect that truly impressed me was the value for prices. It’s rare to find such excellent quality at such reasonable rates, leaving you feeling like you’ve struck gold. Whether you choose to dine in or opt for their highly recommended takeout, Pizzaville delivers a pizza experience that is hard to forget.

In a town filled with choices, Pizzaville emerges as a standout, making it a must-try for anyone craving a fantastic pizza in Avon!

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Pizza King | Avon, IN

Highlights
Toy train delivers drinks
Fast and helpful service
Arcade games available
Bright and re-decorated atmosphere
Expensive pizzas with mixed quality

When I walked into Pizza King in Avon, I was immediately charmed by the bright and re-decorated atmosphere—it felt welcoming and vibrant. But the real showstopper? The toy train delivering drinks to tables, which added a playful touch to my dining experience. I found the service to be fast and helpful, always ready to assist with a smile.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the pizza. While their toppings are generous and the crust is satisfyingly crisp, I noted that the quality wasn’t consistent across the menu. Some pies really shined, bursting with flavor, while others left me wishing for a bit more seasoning. And fair warning—the prices tend to be on the higher side, which might not sit well if you're just looking for a casual slice.

Dare I say, the arcade games in the back added a nostalgic ambiance that makes it a great hangout spot—but in the battle for the best pizza in Avon, I felt Pizza King has some catching up to do. So, while it’s fun and quirky, it may not quite take home the gold in the pizza race.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Charbonos

Highlights
Delicious antipasto appetizer
Freshly baked house bread
Friendly service
Good variety of menu options
Spacious seating needed

Charbonos in Avon is a delightful jewel when it comes to pizza. As I settled into the spacious seating, I couldn’t help but feel the warm and inviting ambiance. Right from the start, the friendly service made me feel at home, as though I was sharing a meal with friends. To kick off my culinary adventure, I tried their delicious antipasto appetizer—a perfect start that set high expectations for what was to follow.

The real star of the show was their pizza. Each bite of their doughy, freshly baked crust sang with flavor, making it clear that they take great pride in their craft. With a good variety of menu options, there's something for every palate. Whether you prefer classic toppings or you're on the hunt for something adventurous, Charbonos has you covered.

Finally, their house bread is not to be overlooked—soft and warm, it pairs beautifully with the zesty sauce they put on their pizzas. I can't emphasize this enough: Charbonos is a fantastic choice for anyone trying to find the best pizza in Avon. Each slice is a testament to their dedication, and I’m already looking forward to my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

Pizza Twist

Highlights
Unique and diverse menu
Excellent vegan options
Attentive and friendly staff
Delicious chicken alternatives
Great wings and Indian flavors

Pizza Twist in Avon is an exciting culinary experience that redefines what a pizza joint can be. Right from stepping in, I was greeted by the attentive and friendly staff who made me feel right at home. Their menu is a delightful tapestry of flavors, showcasing a unique blend of classic Italian and Indian cuisine, which is truly a breath of fresh air in the local pizza scene.

As someone who appreciates variety, I was thrilled by their diverse menu that also caters to plant-based diets with some fantastic vegan options. I decided to indulge in their signature chicken pizza, which was a revelation. Each bite was a perfect harmony of spices and savory goodness. And let’s not forget their amazing wings—crunchy and bursting with flavor!

What sets Pizza Twist apart is its ability to celebrate tradition while daringly experimenting with bold flavors. If you are a pizza enthusiast or just in the mood for something different, this place should be at the top of your list. In my eyes, it’s not just pizza; it’s an adventurous feast. Don't miss the chance to experience it for yourself!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Chicago's Pizza Plainfield

Highlights
Delicious deep-dish pizza
Friendly and quick service
Clean and cozy atmosphere
Great lunch buffet offered
Ample parking availability

Stepping into Chicago's Pizza Plainfield in Avon, I was instantly greeted by the inviting aroma of cheesy goodness and homemade marinara. The cozy atmosphere made it the perfect spot to unwind as I prepared to indulge in their famed deep-dish pizza.

Let me tell you, this was no ordinary pizza! The crust was perfectly baked, golden brown, and loaded with a generous layering of gooey cheese and fresh toppings. Each slice was a delightful masterpiece that transported me straight to the Windy City. The service was impressively quick and friendly, which added to the overall enjoyable dining experience.

I also took advantage of their great lunch buffet, which offers a fantastic variety without the guilt of overindulgence (or so I told myself!). With plenty of options to satisfy even the pickiest eater, it’s a hidden gem for those lunchtime cravings.

Plus, the ample parking availability made my visit completely stress-free. For anyone on the hunt for exceptional pizza in Avon, I wholeheartedly recommend Chicago's Pizza Plainfield—a true slice of heaven! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Piezanos Pizza - Plainfield

Highlights
Quick service
Family size pizza
Raw crust concern
Disappointing taste
Better options available

Upon stepping into Piezanos Pizza - Plainfield, I was greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough, setting the stage for what I hoped would be a delightful culinary adventure. Their quick service is commendable; I barely had time to peruse the menu before my order was taken and on its way.

However, when my family-size pizza arrived, I couldn’t help but notice a concerning trend—an unusually raw crust that made me feel like I had entered the world of half-baked ideas. While the toppings were generous, the overall taste left me feeling a tad disappointed. It seems that they might have focused more on quantity than quality in this instance, which is a shame given the endless possibilities that pizza can offer.

Unfortunately, my taste buds were left yearning for something more. Having visited various pizzerias in Avon, it's clear that better options abound. While Piezanos has its merits, for a truly impressive slice, I suggest exploring other local favorites. After all, pizza is an experience, and one should never settle for less than extraordinary.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Monical's Pizza of Avon

Monical's Pizza of Avon is a delightful stop for any pizza lover. Their crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, providing a fantastic foundation for their first-rate toppings. I savored the delicious, zesty sauce that brought all the flavors together beautifully. The variety on the menu is impressive, but their signature sausage pizza stole the show with its robust, savory flavor. The cozy ambiance makes it an ideal spot for family gatherings or a casual night out. If you're searching for a slice of heaven in Avon, Monical's should definitely be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

Bubba's 33

Bubba's 33 is a delightful surprise in Avon, serving up fantastic pizza that left my taste buds dancing! Their signature crust strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, providing an ideal foundation for their bold and flavorful toppings. I opted for the classic pepperoni, and each slice was generously adorned with perfectly-spiced, bubbly cheese. The vibe is casual yet inviting, making it suitable for families or a night out with friends. If you're on the hunt for a pizza experience that combines quality and a laid-back atmosphere, Bubba's 33 should definitely be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

The Original Noble Roman's

Nestled in the heart of Avon, The Original Noble Roman's serves up a slice of nostalgia alongside its delightful pizzas. The crispy crust is perfectly balanced, providing that satisfying crunch while supporting generous toppings. I tried their signature pepperoni pizza, and each bite was an explosion of flavor with zesty sauce and melty cheese that dances on your palate. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, making it a great spot for family outings or quick takeout. Overall, if you're hunting for a stellar pizza experience in Avon, Noble Roman's should definitely top your list! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Nonna's by So Italian

Nonna's by So Italian in Avon is a delightful gem that brings a warm, family-style feel to pizza night. Stepping inside, I was immediately enveloped by the fragrant aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings. I indulged in their signature Margherita, and let me tell you—the crust was perfectly crisp while the rich mozzarella and vibrant basil sang in harmony. The sweet tomato sauce on the base was the showstopper, elevating each bite to pure bliss. With its cozy ambiance and mouthwatering offerings, I can confidently say that Nonna's is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Avon! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse in Avon is a delightful surprise for pizza lovers! The deep-dish pizza, with its rich layers of cheese and savory toppings, is a slice of heaven. I opted for the Superior Meat variety, and the flavors were explosive yet well-balanced. The crust was perfectly crispy, providing that satisfying crunch with each bite. Pair it with one of their handcrafted beers, and you have a match made in pizza paradise! Overall, BJ's combines a vibrant atmosphere with delicious eats, solidifying its spot among the best pizza joints in Avon. Highly recommended!

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.