Portage's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

After countless weekends spent sampling slices from nearly every pizzeria in town, I’ve finally narrowed it down to the top 12 spots that truly shine. Trust me, my taste buds have been on quite the adventure! As a local who knows the ins and outs of Portage, I’ve taken everything into account—from the crust’s perfect crisp to those mouthwatering toppings that dance on your palate.

Whether you’re a thin-crust lover or a deep-dish devotee, I’ve got you covered. Get ready to discover the flavors that make Portage a hidden gem for pizza lovers. Grab a napkin and prepare for a delicious ride through our town’s tastiest offerings!

Bam Pizza Company

Highlights
Super friendly staff
Hot Honey Jalapeño Popper pizza
Delicious ice cream options
Unique pizza offerings

At Bam Pizza Company, the experience begins long before you take your first bite. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the super friendly staff who treated everyone like family. Their enthusiasm set the tone for what turned out to be a memorable visit.

Now let’s dive into the star of the show—the Hot Honey Jalapeño Popper pizza. This culinary masterpiece is a delightful fusion of sweet and spicy, with just the right kick to keep my taste buds dancing. The crust was perfectly baked, providing a crispy yet chewy foundation for the symphony of flavors. Every slice was a revelation, topped generously with ooey-gooey cheese that melded beautifully with the jalapeños and that tantalizing drizzle of honey.

And the cherry on top? They offer exquisite ice cream options for dessert, making it the ideal ending to a fantastic meal. If you’re looking for a place that showcases unique pizza offerings in Portage, Bam Pizza Company should definitely be on your list. Overall, my visit was a blend of delightful flavors and warm hospitality, making it a standout destination for pizza lovers.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Evansville.

Cappo's

Highlights
Excellent quality and price
Great appetizers
Catering service exceeds expectations
Tasty vegetarian pizza options
Good overall experience

Cappo's in Portage is truly a gem for pizza lovers, and my recent visit confirmed why it deserves a spot on the list of the best pizzerias in town. From the moment I entered, I was greeted by a warm atmosphere that set the tone for a delightful meal. Let’s talk about the pizza – it’s a revelation! The quality of the ingredients really shines through in every bite, and for the price, it’s hard to argue that you’re getting a fantastic deal.

But it doesn't stop there; the appetizers were equally impressive. I indulged in their garlic knots, which were fluffy, flavorful, and paired perfectly with marinara sauce. The vegetarian options were not only creative but exceptionally delicious, making it a joyous stop for meat-lovers and herbivores alike.

What stood out even more was their catering service, which clearly goes above and beyond the call of duty. Whether you're planning a casual gathering or a full-blown party, Cappo’s is ready to cater right to your needs. In a nutshell, I left Cappo's satisfied and excited to return. If you’re on the hunt for a memorable pizza experience in Portage, look no further.

You might also want to check out the best food in Downtown Indianapolis.

Benchwarmer's Grille

Highlights
Pretzel Pizza Crust
Friendly and Helpful Staff
Variety for Picky Eaters
Fairly Priced Menu
Good for Bread and Cheese

Benchwarmer's Grille is a delightful hidden gem in Portage that takes the pizza game to an entirely new level! As I stepped inside, I was greeted by the friendly and helpful staff who immediately made me feel at home. The ambiance is relaxed, perfectly suited for a casual outing or a quick bite after the game.

The highlight of my pizza experience was the unique pretzel pizza crust. This clever twist adds a rich, buttery flavor that perfectly complements the fresh toppings. Speaking of toppings, Benchwarmer's offers a wide variety, ensuring that even the pickiest eater in your group will find something to love. I opted for a classic pepperoni with extra cheese, and let me tell you, it was a heavenly combination that kept me coming back for more bites!

With their menu being fairly priced, indulging in a delicious pizza here won’t break the bank. If you’re a fan of good bread and cheese, this is definitely the spot for you. So if you’re hunting for the best pizza in Portage, Benchwarmer's Grille should be at the top of your list. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Muncie.

Val's Famous Pizza & Grinders

Highlights
Homemade dressings available
Friendly and attentive staff
Delicious fried pickles
Fantastic sandwich options
Bike rack for cyclists

From the moment I stepped into Val's Famous Pizza & Grinders, I was greeted by the friendly and attentive staff who made me feel right at home. The ambiance was relaxed, perfect for enjoying a slice or two. As I scanned the menu, I couldn't resist ordering their signature pizza, renowned for its fresh ingredients and perfectly baked crust.

What truly set this pizza apart was the symphony of flavors—a delightful blend of homemade dressings and toppings that danced on my taste buds. And let’s not forget about the fantastic sandwich options, which I’ve heard are equally impressive! To complement my meal, I ordered the delicious fried pickles, which provided the perfect crunch alongside the pizza.

One of the thoughtful touches I appreciated was the bike rack for cyclists, making it a convenient stop after a long ride. Overall, my visit to Val's was a memorable culinary experience. If you're seeking pizza that balances both quality and taste in Portage, look no further than Val's. It's a slice of heaven you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Kokomo.

T's Pizza & Family Restaurant

Highlights
Consistently Good Food
Delicious Chunky Sausage Pizza
Family-Friendly Atmosphere
Great Service from Megan
Fresh Chicken Strip Meal

T's Pizza & Family Restaurant in Portage truly surprised me with its delightful offerings! Walking into the restaurant, the warm and family-friendly atmosphere immediately set the tone for a pleasant dining experience. My taste buds were tingling with anticipation as I scanned the menu, known for its consistently good food.

I couldn’t resist ordering their Chunky Sausage Pizza! Let me tell you, this pizza is a game changer. With its generous toppings and perfectly cooked crust, each bite was a celebration of flavors. The sauce was rich without overpowering the star of the show—the chunky sausage—making me appreciate the skill behind its creation.

Service was exceptional, thanks to Megan, who greeted us with a smile and checked in on us regularly without being intrusive. That personal touch goes a long way, don't you agree?

Oh, and if you’re visiting with kids, I highly recommend their fresh chicken strip meal; it’s a hit with the little ones! Overall, T's Pizza & Family Restaurant stands out as a must-visit spot in Portage if you're chasing the best pizza experience in town. I can’t wait to return for another slice! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrillville.

Miller Pizza Co.

Highlights
Delicious Chicago Deep Dish
Friendly Service
Retro Pizza Joint Vibe
Partial Baking Option
Unique Cornmeal Dough

Miller Pizza Co. in Portage is a delightful dive into the world of pizza that I simply can’t resist. As soon as I stepped in, I was welcomed by the friendly service, which instantly made me feel at home. The atmosphere has this charming retro pizza joint vibe that sets the stage perfectly for a cozy meal.

Now, let's talk about what truly matters—the pizza! I chose their delicious Chicago deep dish, and let me tell you, it was a game-changer. The crust, made with unique cornmeal dough, was beautifully flaky and golden, adding a distinctive texture. This pie isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience. The cheese stretches gracefully, and the fillings burst with flavor.

What’s more, Miller offers a partial baking option, allowing you to take home that fresh-baked aroma, which is a novelty I simply adore. If you're on the hunt for an unforgettable pizza experience in Portage, Miller Pizza Co. is not to be missed. With their exceptional offerings, they might just claim the spot as my personal favorite!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Fort Wayne.

Gelsosomo's Pizzeria

Gelsosomo's Pizzeria in Portage is a slice of heaven! When I walked in, the warm, rustic atmosphere enveloped me, promising a delightful experience. Their classic thin crust pizza is a standout—crispy, flavorful, and topped with fresh ingredients that burst with flavor. I opted for the sausage and pepperoni combo, and each bite was a joy—the seasoned meat complementing the zesty sauce perfectly. The staff was friendly and attentive, adding to the welcoming vibe. If you find yourself craving pizza in Portage, Gelsosomo's is a must-try for its delightful flavors and inviting ambiance! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Nashville.

Pizza Terra

Nestled in the heart of Portage, Pizza Terra is a delightful gem that genuinely captures the essence of artisanal pizza. The moment I stepped in, the aroma of freshly baked dough wafted through the air, making my taste buds tingle with anticipation. Their signature pies, particularly the Margarita, showcase a perfect balance of tangy tomato, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil. Each bite is a harmonious blend of flavors, leaving you craving more. The cozy ambiance paired with friendly staff creates a welcoming vibe. For a pizza experience that feels both handcrafted and authentic, Pizza Terra is an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Anderson.

J & J's Pizza Shack

J & J's Pizza Shack is a delightful gem in Portage that serves up some seriously satisfying pies. From the moment I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me like a warm, cheesy hug. I opted for their signature pepperoni pizza, and let me tell you, each slice was a perfect blend of crispy crust and zesty sauce. The generous toppings were an added bonus! The lively atmosphere made it even more enjoyable, turning a simple meal into a memorable experience. If you’re seeking pizza paradise, J & J's is definitely the spot to savor every scrumptious bite!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Indianapolis.

Aurelio's Pizza

Aurelio's Pizza in Portage is a delightful slice of heaven! The moment I entered, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough and rich tomato sauce enveloped me. I opted for the classic pepperoni, and oh, what a treat it was! The crust was perfectly crispy yet chewy, providing a delightful contrast. Each bite was a harmonious blend of tangy sauce and generous cheese. What truly impressed me was the attention to detail—even the toppings were generously applied without overwhelming the base. Aurelio's is not just about pizza; it’s about crafting a memorable dining experience! Don't miss this gem!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Goshen.

Flamingo Pizza Of Miller

Nestled in Portage, Flamingo Pizza Of Miller delivers a vibrant twist on a classic favorite. From the moment I walked in, the charming decor and friendly staff set the tone for a delightful culinary adventure. I opted for their signature Flamingo Pie, topped with fresh ingredients and a perfectly crispy crust that danced with flavor. Each bite was a symphony of taste, with a delightful balance of spice and savory goodness. The zesty sauce brought everything together, creating a truly unforgettable experience. If you're looking for a playful pizza escapade in Portage, look no further—this spot will whisk you away!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jeffersonville.

Santini's Pizza And Wings

At Santini's Pizza And Wings, I was greeted with a delightful aroma that hinted at the culinary magic within. Their signature pizza boasts a perfectly crispy crust, generous toppings, and a rich, tangy sauce that dances on your palate. I particularly enjoyed the combination of pepperoni and fresh veggies, creating a perfect balance of flavors. The wings? Absolutely scrumptious! With a variety of sauces to choose from, they were the ideal counterpart to the pizza. Santini's cleverly combines quality with a laid-back atmosphere, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Portage. Truly a stellar dining experience! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best place to eat in Indianapolis.